If you are a coach of a team and you had a choice to have any QB that is in the NFL right now, who would it be? (No historic players) Here's who I would want: Peyton Manning Runner Up: Ben Roethlisberger
uh oh bry u just set urself up for a lot of making fun of with that choice of Mike Vick i can just see BF making a list of things to say already Peyton Manning Brett Favre (2002 Chad Pennington)
Just because im a Biased Packer Fan Brett Favre Peyton Manning and as a third man i'll throw in Donavan McNabb
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (J-E-T-S 1083)</div><div class='quotemain'>uh oh bry u just set urself up for a lot of making fun of with that choice of Mike Vick i can just see BF making a list of things to say already</div> Haha. Don't I know it. I'm so used to it by now though it doesn't even phase me, I just laugh it off. I've realized that BF1 is bitter because the Bears have half a dozen QB's on their roster that can't get it done and Vick just continues to put up the W's. I'd be bitter too.
If I have to win one game, and it is life or death farve. I know he is willing to cheat and make deals with players on other teams. If we are going to play fairly Manning
If I were to take a QB who would lay down so a guy could break the single season sack record, I would have to take Favre. Because his performance with Strahan in the last game of that year almost looked convincing.
I would choose peyton manning and my backup would be tom brady. I would use brady for the super bowl.
MysteryMan is the only guy who came at all close. You all forgot about Tom Brady. I saw a lot of you picking manning, when manning has been absolutely man handled by brady in the patriots the past couple seasons. My man is Brady, simply because he wins.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (hoodie7)</div><div class='quotemain'>MysteryMan is the only guy who came at all close. You all forgot about Tom Brady. I saw a lot of you picking manning, when manning has been absolutely man handled by brady in the patriots the past couple seasons. My man is Brady, simply because he wins.</div> Your way of comparison is not a fair one. The patriots defense has handled manning quite well, and the indy defense has not been able to stop brady. Brady vs the new england defense would be completely different as would manning vs the indy defense. Manning is quite clearly better. The patriots defense is also quite clearly better.
Brady McNabb Culpepper I like QB's who are both mobile and have good passing skills (excludes Vick). Brady I put up there, just cause he has nuts made out of steel, and I would never count him out. With Manning, unless the passing game is going well, the team will struggle cause he's not capable to use his legs to make things happen.
What if someone comes along and tackles Culpepper? There would be a high chance of a fumble and a possible turnover.
He will just run away and get smushed by the LB'S...Then he will Fumble..lol..And the other team will score!