Cable Modem Question

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

BoBoBREWSKI

BURP!
Joined
Sep 17, 2008
Messages
14,732
Likes
6,459
Points
113
Can I have 2 working modems hooked up to 2 different cable outlets? I'm asking because our XBOX 360 is upstairs and our modem/computer is downstairs. It would be cheaper to buy a modem and hook that up to the xbox then to buy the xbox wireless adaptor. Are there certain modems that will/wont work with Comcast cable internet?
 
Totally uninformed opinion but I don't think you could add the second cable modem... but I'm not positive...
 
Well, both the cable ports (outlets) would need to be hot. And only Comcast modems will work with Comcast internet.

I think for you, you are going to need to get a hub and run a cable down to your XBox.
 
Well, both the cable ports (outlets) would need to be hot. And only Comcast modems will work with Comcast internet.

I think for you, you are going to need to get a hub and run a cable down to your XBox.

Hmm...I mostly agree, but I have bought cable modems from the store to use with Comcast so while there may be compatibility considerations, I don't think it needs to be a "Comcast" modem.
 
Well, both the cable ports (outlets) would need to be hot. And only Comcast modems will work with Comcast internet.

I think for you, you are going to need to get a hub and run a cable down to your XBox.

Actually you can buy your own cable modem and use it with Comcast. They have a list of compatible modems on their website.

But yes he should just get a router.
 
I have a wireless router. But the wireless adaptor for the xbox is $90. I can buy a modem for $25.
 
Hmm...I mostly agree, but I have bought cable modems from the store to use with Comcast so while there may be compatibility considerations, I don't think it needs to be a "Comcast" modem.

Oh cool! I didn't know that!

Actually you can buy your own cable modem and use it with Comcast. They have a list of compatible modems on their website.

But yes he should just get a router.

Good to know! I want to replace mine then!

Get a router.

Why would he need a router? Do you eat cereal with a forklift? A bit overboard. He is just setting up his XBox on a home network. No need to specify where you are routing traffic to. A hub will suffice and save him money.

I have a wireless router. But the wireless adaptor for the xbox is $90. I can buy a modem for $25.

Your wireless router should have RJ45 ports on the back, just run a cable from that to your XBox. Save some money.
 
Oh cool! I didn't know that!



Good to know! I want to replace mine then!



Why would he need a router? Do you eat cereal with a forklift? A bit overboard. He is just setting up his XBox on a home network. No need to specify where you are routing traffic to. A hub will suffice and save him money.

I don't know as much as you do but from what I understand a router has a built in firewall while a hub doesn't. You can get a nice wireless router for $40 on sale.
 
A hub is less reliable than a switch, too. A switch will store and forward packets, while a hub lets packets collide and basically wipe each other out.

It is insane to put your computers on the internet not behind a router, and a wireless one is perfectly sufficient to prevent your computers from being hacked, for the most part.
 
My wireless router is downstairs, the xbox is upstairs. I'd rather fork over the $90 for the xbox wireless adaptor than have an ugly cable running thru the house.

There is a cable outlet right by the xbox. That's why I thought getting a modem for $25 would be the easiest option.
 
A hub is less reliable than a switch, too. A switch will store and forward packets, while a hub lets packets collide and basically wipe each other out.

It is insane to put your computers on the internet not behind a router, and a wireless one is perfectly sufficient to prevent your computers from being hacked, for the most part.

Well, it let's them collide, yes. But you make it seem like thats all it does. If you have a very small network, a hub is fine. You don't need a switch or a router.
 
My wireless router is downstairs, the xbox is upstairs. I'd rather fork over the $90 for the xbox wireless adaptor than have an ugly cable running thru the house.

There is a cable outlet right by the xbox. That's why I thought getting a modem for $25 would be the easiest option.

The cable modem might be cheap, but the cable company would charge you monthly for access I'm sure. I mean, if you're paying for it already and add a second modem, they'd charge you double.
 
The cable modem might be cheap, but the cable company would charge you monthly for access I'm sure. I mean, if you're paying for it already and add a second modem, they'd charge you double.

Actually Comcast only charges $5 a month for an extra IP address. Each modem will have its own IP addy but you only pay for one line.
 
Can I have 2 working modems hooked up to 2 different cable outlets? I'm asking because our XBOX 360 is upstairs and our modem/computer is downstairs. It would be cheaper to buy a modem and hook that up to the xbox then to buy the xbox wireless adaptor. Are there certain modems that will/wont work with Comcast cable internet?

I believe if you doa google search out there you will find that many people have found a Linksys Wireless adaptor will work in place of the Xbox proprietary adaptor and save you a ton of money. Then as long as you have a router with wireless, you should be good to go.
 
Actually Comcast only charges $5 a month for an extra IP address. Each modem will have its own IP addy but you only pay for one line.

IP address is different than a whole second modem.

http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=257417

I use to be a Comacast installer and can answer this one.(Note: left the company mid-2004 but I'm sure not much has changed on the back-end of things)

Short answer:No
Long answer:It's possible, but.....

Brief explanation: This was a common thing I heard when I did hi-speed installs. Most people think 'One modem is fast then 2 must be faster', but that's not quiet correct. People think that if they have a modem for each computer that each one as a fastest connection possible. But if you think about it, both modems hook into the same cable that feeds your home from the pole(or underground line). They would both be connected to it via a splitter in your home. The internet signal is broadcast across the cable via a certain frequency bands. For example my area used the freq's around the 729MHz band for internet use. Even though there are in reality multiple channels/bands available(we had up to 3 in my area), your mulitple modems would be trying to use the same part of the 'pipe'(freq range) at the same time. Slowing down the speed across all of them. So to get equal speed over mulitple modems, you would have to have one 'drop' (physical cable feed) per modem going to your home from the 'tap'(were your cable line connects to the main line at the pole). Most cable company networks are only designed to have one 'drop' per residence to keep overhead costs down. Also on the network side of things, you can only have one active modem on an individual customer account. I believe this is a limitation of the software they use. If you try to add multiple modems on one account, none of them will be able to get a ip address because the 'headend'(backbone of the network) doesn't know which one is suppose to be active. In theory you could get mulitiple drops if your home was setup as a MDU(multiple dwelling unit-apartment), but more then likely they would not allow it or charge you a small fortune to do it.

For most use, your not going to max out your single connection anyways. That's why home networking is the most popular way to go. Just use your Airport Express to connect both computers to the modem. If you want a faster 'wired' connection, then look into wireing your home for ethernet. Then just share your internet over a wired router.(persoanl note: make sure you get a good one. my month and a half old linksys router went out about a week ago. seocond one in a year)

Hope this wasn't too long winded. Hope this helped some.

Edit: Speed wise, the cable modem speeds(3-8Mbps depending on area) means the speed of the conection of the modem to the internet. The 802.11 speeds(example-54Mbps) means the speed of the wired/wireless router connection to your computers. Meaning that your computer to computer home network will be faster then any of their connections to the internet.

http://jimwarholic.com/2007/10/comcast-modem-chat-session.php

James > Can I hook up another extra modem on my current system, by just getting an extra IP address and calling my extra modem number into Comcast central?

Allan > Hello James, Thank you for contacting Comcast Live Chat Support. My name is Allan. Please give me one moment to review your information.

Allan > No, you would need to have a second subscription to the Internet service.
 
Thanks guys. I've found xbox wireless adaptors on ebay for under $50, so I might just keep it easy and go that route.
:cheers:
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top