OT Cashman or Boone?...serious question.

[yankeesince59]

Just curious as to how everyone else feels...if you could choose only ONE scenario, would you rather have Cashman canned, or Boone?

 

[yankeesince59]

For me, it's no contest...it's Cashman.

Boone can't help that he's simply NOT very good at his job and should have never been give the job in the first place...and Cashman was instrumental in Boone getting the job...and Cashman continues to back him.

In nearly 25 years, Cashman has yet to build a championship team of his own design, and no, 2009 doesn't count either. The Boss is screaming from his grave, "GET RID OF THIS POS"



Edit; "NOT very good at his job"

 

[Messiah717]

Easily Cashman. I'll say this for Boone. The players have responded to him. When the players give up then that's the end.

 

[cagedlion]

^^^^^
Cashman has been the puppet master of the Yankees organization. He has not been able to provide the team
with right players to bring a long sought championship. The ax should fall on this guy. All reasons why
this team does not win a World Series really point to Cashman. The inept manager, the linear players are his
decisions, and as long as he keeps pulling the strings Yankees will be void of any championship.

 

[yankeesince59]

I'm also not sure that Hal is any smarter than his late dim-witted brother, Hank.