DYC Sig Comp: Votes Round 3

[Oranje]

Ok everyone, we hav a new voting system for the rest of comp.

each sig will be marked out of 15.

10 of those marks will be how well the sig symbolises the theme.

the other 5 will be for overall appearance.

dont forget to to state ur reasons behind ur votes.

1st up is wolf vs. 12th

wolf:

12th:

next up is, two vs. echo:

two:

http://i21.photobucket.com/albums/b260/sty...arjenrobben.jpg

echo:

http://i183.photobucket.com/albums/x268/ec...oronaldosig.jpg

the theme for this round is:

Twinkle Toes. a player with the pace and touch to beat several defenders. when voting for each sig, keep this in mind.

voting finishes wednesday 9pm AEST

 

[bbwMax]

OK Wolf vs 12th.

Wolf 5/10, 5/5 Overall 10/15 Not completely Relevant but one of my favorites. Nice sig all round IMO

12th 7/10 4/5 Overall 11/15 OK and i like the Roma Bit which shows more relevance to the theme IMO



Next

Two vs Echo

Two 9/10 4/5 Overall 13/15. Sig is the relevant to the theme IMO. Nice sig overall.

Echo 9/10 5/5 Overall 14/15. Sig is also the relevant to the theme and the best executed IMO

 

[Oranje]

lol max u have to score each sig out of 15.

10 for how well it presents the theme and 5 for overall appearance

 

[bbwMax]

<div class="quote_poster">Oranje Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">lol max u have to score each sig out of 15.

10 for how well it presents the theme and 5 for overall appearance</div>

i'm not 'on the ball' today

Edited my original post Oranje

 

[twofivefive]

Max, didn't you read what he said? State why and use the new voting system.

Wolf: 0/10 for theme, 2.5/5 for looks. The theme is not shown at all, it's just a picture of Ibrahimovic and his name. The sig looks alright but I don't like the cut, it seems like you've cut the back of his head too far and his mouth/cheek not enough.
Rodney: 2/10 for theme, 3/5 for looks. The theme is shown a little bit because you've shown that he's scored a goal, but nothing really about footwork and things like that. I don't really like the blending of the cut but the background looks alright and the text is really good, except the pixel font should be a bit better.

So my vote goes to The 12th Man.

 

[Oranje]

<div class="quote_poster">Max Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">

i'm not 'on the ball' today

Edited my original post Oranje

</div>

lol no problem man

 

[The 12th Man]

<div class="quote_poster">twofivefive Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Max, didn't you read what he said? State why and use the new voting system.

Wolf: 0/10 for theme, 2.5/5 for looks. The theme is not shown at all, it's just a picture of Ibrahimovic and his name. The sig looks alright but I don't like the cut, it seems like you've cut the back of his head too far and his mouth/cheek not enough.
Rodney: 2/10 for theme, 3/5 for looks. The theme is shown a little bit because you've shown that he's scored a goal, but nothing really about footwork and things like that. I don't really like the blending of the cut but the background looks alright and the text is really good, except the pixel font should be a bit better.

So my vote goes to The 12th Man.</div>

thanks for the glen. That was the first time i used a pixel font. It turned out ok

255 - The effects in the bg are good. The text is great and suites the theme. The only thing that lets it down is that it looks similar to ur Downing sig. BUt its still great. Theme 6/10 Looks 3/5

Echo - Its ok. Not ur best but ok. It is similar to glens where you have his feet in shot which makes it look good. I dont really like the blending of the main picture. The text looks great. Theme 6/10 Looks 1.5/10


Edit: BTW i thought the theme was a player who bet a defender with his footwork to score a goal.

<div class="quote_poster">Quote:</div><div class="quote_post">your sig is to show one of these players celebrating a famous goal, after beating defender(s). for example, giggs running around with his shirt off after the fa cup semi final against arsenal</div>

 

[Oranje]

two and echo really hit the theme on the head.

and yes two nice sucking up

, go robben

 

[twofivefive]

Rodney, with pixel fonts, you need to set the anti-alias to none or else it comes out like yours where it's not clean and sharp. You should use a pixel font for the little The 12th Man thing too.

So what is it, 2-0 to me and 2-0 to Rodney?

Oranje, weren't you going to vote this round too?

 

[The 12th Man]

<div class="quote_poster">twofivefive Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Rodney, with pixel fonts, you need to set the anti-alias to none or else it comes out like yours where it's not clean and sharp. You should use a pixel font for the little The 12th Man thing too.

So what is it, 2-0 to me and 2-0 to Rodney?

Oranje, weren't you going to vote this round too?</div>

ohk ill try that tonight because im making a chelsea sig for a friend

 

[echo369]

wolf - 0/10 didnt show the theme at all.. 2/5 dont really like the text background or the effect on the cut

12th - 0/10 even though it shows hes scored a goal, that doesnt show that it was from fancy footwork (also, for everyone else, it didnt have to be a goal, it couldve just been in play).. 2.5/5 you got an extra .5 because your background was better but dont like the text or the way the cut is blended in..

12th gets the vote

 

[echo369]

2-0 to glenn and 3-0 to rodney

 

[Oranje]

wolf - theme 2/10. theres no real elements of the theme, except for the player wolf has chosen. appearance - 4/5. wat can i say, its another typical (great) effort with his sigs. ive always liked wolfs work. overall 6/15

12th - theme 4/10. its very similar to wolfs in presentation of the theme, except for the goal he's chosen as his symbol of twinkle toes. appearance 3/5, text is good as well as colour. overall 7/15

two - theme 9/10. the ball at his feet, the expression of concentration and focus and the look of, "dont bother, ill get past u." its wat this theme is about. appearance 4/5. is that his knee next to his head?! appearance 13/15

echo - theme 8/10. very similar in two presentation of the theme. appearance 4/5. the only thing i didnt like was the text, but very nice. overall 12/15.

 

[Oranje]

guys, i think ur being too harsh with wolfs sig. dont forget the players themselves also symbolise the theme. after all, they have the twinkle toes, not the sig.

 

[echo369]

im never gonna win lol.. ive only got 2 votes in this whole comp lol..

 

[Oranje]

<div class="quote_poster">echo369 Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">im never gonna win lol.. ive only got 2 votes in this whole comp lol..</div>

urs was a good effort this round but.

too bad u came up against two

he had inspiration from the oranje!!

 

[twofivefive]

Oranje, I made that sig knowing you'd like it just because it's a Dutchman

only joking

.

 

[Oranje]

<div class="quote_poster">twofivefive Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Oranje, I made that sig knowing you'd like it just because it's a Dutchman

only joking

.</div>

lol hey man im credible!!

 

[echo369]

i knew i shouldve submitted an arjen robben sig

 

[twofivefive]

Too bad your Arjen Robben sig was shit lol. Nah, it wasn't that bad, just some (major) changes and it would have been good

 

[Oranje]

lol it aint coz it was robben!! coz it was good!

i knew i shouldnt have voted!

 

[Wolf]

<div class="quote_poster">twofivefive Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">
The sig looks alright but I don't like the cut, it seems like you've cut the back of his head too far and his mouth/cheek not enough.
</div>

lol, cut. its not a cut it a stock photo, thats just the way its been blended.

 

[echo369]

lol if i just took the picture, the scanlines, brushes, bar, text and void on it it wouldve looked class