Giants report card game 1

[kreidertime]

Coughlin - F. Doesn't have a clue any longer. He lets his coordinators do what they want without over-seeing it.
McAdoo - F- Dallas is not a good or talented defense. He continues to make them look solid. His call at the goal line was one of the dumbest I've seen in years. He failed miserably.
Spags- A. Just saw OO was inactive. Now he gets an A
Eli- D Some of his throws were atrocious and he couldn't find holes in a defense that is really not very good.
Vereen - B Was solid
Odell - C Needs to do more. Made a huge play that should have sealed the game if not for our dumbass coaching staff.
Randle F - What a joke. Guy just doesn't get it.
Donnell B He didn't fumble which is a good day for him.
Williams D Sucked
Jennings B- Made a few nice plays
OL C+ Eli wasn't hit much but they still suck blocking for the run.
DL C No pass rush, decent against the run
LB B Thought they actually played well. Especially Unga
DB A- Other than the last drive, they played very well
ST B+ No real mistakes

 

[cagedlion]

In a nutshell, Giants last O drive was the worst I have
ever seen. Giants commit Hari-Kari. My first thought as
to why Giants lost was wrong.......Eli was not solely to blame.
TC and OC displayed the worst clock management and
horrible play selections to give the game to Dallas.

Offense D
Defense C
Sp T B+
Coach & staff F

 

[kreidertime]

Defense was not a C. More like a B+. They would have given up only a FG if not for a absurd pass interference call which the official made up and less a touchdown with proper time management. So basically, only 17 points at Dallas. Can't blame them. This is on the incompetent offense and coaches.

 

[Messiah717]

I think for the people they have out on the field the defense gave about the best effort you could've hoped for. They should've never of been put in that situation.

 

[Pastafazul]

Saw enough of game to say I was very impressed by the players, they took a 100 thou hostile fans out of the game for the most part, the last 5 minutes of that game was an atrocity by the defensive decision to play what I perceived to be a prevent D which only seems to prevent you from winning the game, prior to the last 5 minutes , the cowboys were out if it... Cannot stand coaches who manage a game to lose!

Where was Cruz? And f n Parker dropping those 2 game changing passes. Holy shittttt, Eli wtf!!! Throw a fookin spiral .... I did not expect to watch as much of that game, nor did I expect much from giants , but what did I get? No fookin sleep

What do we get out of this game? HAve no fookin clue

 

[Hammerojustice]

I was thinking the D was better than anticipated... O was rough, heard Odell might have played with a concussion... that would suck... I'm at a loss for who to blame for the end of the game with Eli telling Jennings not to score, but then them calling a passing play...

 

[cagedlion]

The D gave up two TDs in last five minutes.....that is
no B+. In fact, for three periods they played well;
4th quarter was a bust.

 

[kreidertime]

Wrong. One was not a TD. It was 4th down but the corrupt officials made up a pass interference call. The second TD should have never happened if our stupid 21 million dollar QB new how to count. The defense was tremendous all night. It was the piece of crap offense which sucked.

 

[cagedlion]

Let's blame the ref. D still gave up 2TDs.
For 55 minutes the D did its job.