Sheed was the #1 reason why that series with the Lakers went 7 games. We had no answer for Shaq and Kobe, but they had no answer for Rasheed.
Not really. Yes, Sheed had a great series against the Lakers, but he did most of his damage in games we lost. His two highest scoring games in that series were 34 points in Game 4 and 30 points in Game 7.
Games 5 and 6 were the critical wins that allowed us to stretch the series to 7 games.
In game 5, Sheed had 22 points on 7-21 shooting. Scottie Pippen had a turn-back-the-clock game of 22 points on 8-12 shooting.
In game 6, Sheed was 3rd on the team in scoring at 18 points. Smitty led the team with 26 and Bonzi chipped in 20 off the bench.
Besides, we lost that series, so Sheed didn't "lead" us anywhere. He was an important part of those teams, but I can't think of a single example of Sheed ever leading us to a series win. I'm sure there had to be something, maybe a first round win over a lower seed, but he never "led" us to the WCF, as the OP claimed, or beyond.
And, he didn't "lead" DET to a championship. In fact, it was his boneheaded play of leaving Robert Horry wide open for the game winning 3 the following season that cost DET a chance at a repeat. And then how many times did he guarantee they'd win a series and fail to deliver?
Great role player, yes, without a doubt. Great leader, not even close.
BNM