Mp3 Players?

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Chutney

MON-STRAWRRR!!1!
Joined
Jul 8, 2004
Messages
12,944
Likes
46
Points
48
I've put some money aside from my work to finally buy a decent mp3 player. I've usually just stuck to CD's, so I really don't know what's out there and what's worth my money. Was originally thinking of just grabbing an Ipod, but then some people recommended mp4's and a whole bunch of other things, so I don't know anymore.

Does anybody have any recommendations/opinions? Money isn't that huge of a concern, but I really don't know what the standard price is out there. Also, I'm not really looking for video players and all that other crap. Mainly music.

Thanks.
 
if ur not looking for video just get like a nano its small and its just music. but it also matters how many songs u wanna put on cause u can always get a decent one but the size wont be that great
 
Ya, it depends how many songs you want to get on there. If you don't want like 7,500 songs, then I'd just get a regular I-Pod
yup.gif


BTW--What the hell is a MP4?
 
Get the iPod video. It's the sh*t. I have one and there's nothing to dislike about it. You have to convert the videos to mp4 for it work on the ipod, but it's really not a hassle since you can find many videos on the web as mp4's, and there are plenty of easy programs out there to convert.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Quoting I-Miss-MJ:</div><div class="quote_post">mp4 is ipod video files.</div>
theres also mp4 players which are made to play them
 
<div class="quote_poster">Quoting P.A.P.:</div><div class="quote_post">Get the iPod video. It's the sh*t. I have one and there's nothing to dislike about it. You have to convert the videos to mp4 for it work on the ipod, but it's really not a hassle since you can find many videos on the web as mp4's, and there are plenty of easy programs out there to convert.</div>
he said he doesnt want videos so theres like no point to getting a video, but i see what your sayign cause i got a video over a nano, and i thought i wasnt gunna put videos on it but i eventually did
 
<div class="quote_poster">Quoting P.A.P.:</div><div class="quote_post">Get the iPod video. It's the sh*t. I have one and there's nothing to dislike about it. You have to convert the videos to mp4 for it work on the ipod, but it's really not a hassle since you can find many videos on the web as mp4's, and there are plenty of easy programs out there to convert.</div>


what program do you use?
 
I've been using a Rio Carbon for the last few years and I like it alot. I don't listen to that much music so 5 gb is plenty for me and its pretty cheap compared to Ipod's (which I would never buy because there was close to 40 stolen at my school last year).

As for which MP3 player is right for you, it depends on how much music you have/want on it, what you're using it for (i.e. jogging, listening to while traveling, etc.) and what your price range is. Theres obviously alot of different Ipods out there but theres also Creative Labs mp3 players (which I really like), Rio, Dell, etc.
 
Hey Chutney, seeing how you live in Toronto, my only suggestion would be to go to Canada Computers in Pacific Mall. The mp3 players there are a lot cheaper than other store, including Wal Mart. And they're brand name players, not a bunch of no-name brands.

Anyways, I just got a 1gb rca mp3 player there a few months ago for $110, whereas in other stores like The Source or the Bay, they were selling the exact one for around $200.

Here's a link to their mp3 player selections and prices. Sometimes they have different selections when you actually go there though, but it should give you an idea about the prices.
http://www.canadacomputers.com/index.php?d...rt=0&numPages=3

btw, I'm not spamming. I don't work there nor do I know anyone that works there. Just giving some friendly advice.
 
CanadaComputers is not as reliable as Best Buy or FS IMO though.

Chutney, how much music do you have? Are you very active with an MP3 player (ie jog)? Do you care about battery life? Scratches? Sound quality?

It's easy when buying an MP3 player to just see iPod and think of it as the shiznit. Fact is there are a lot of other players out there with the same functionality as the iPod and one-ups it. I have four MP3 players from different generations and different sizes, and all of them are better than iPods. If you want to stand out amongst the crowd of white headphones, look elsewhere. Creative, iRiver and Samsung all have some very solid MP3 players. I myself just bought one two weeks ago.
 
Thanks a lot for all the feedback guys.

So I guess mp4 just mean videos as well. Didn't know. I just want music though.

I tend to download songs in bunches, and I have a lot. I had an early Rio one (200 something MB's) that I was happy with. However, I'm kinda clumsy and I dropped it and broke the screen. It kept on working for a while, but eventually stopped completely.

My main concerns with an mp3 player are size and battery life. Is there a big difference in sound quality between brands? I don't really know. I would like it to be fairly durable, but I intend to be far more careful with it this time and probably won't use it for jogging or anything. So yea, battery life and size are the most important things for me.

And thanks for the info dunksworth. I'm focusing more on the exact one I'm going to get right now. But when I go to buy it, I'll definitely be comparing prices.

Again, thanks a lot for the help.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Quoting I-Miss-MJ:</div><div class="quote_post">what program do you use?</div>

xilisoft PSP video converter

Chutney, regarding the ipod video's battery life, it's great. I don't know the exact battery life, but it's good for about 8-10+ straight hours depending on the volume level you keep it at. Watching video's kill the battery faster, but regardless, it still has very good battery life. Plus when you're updating your iPod, it charges automatically too.

As far as size, the iPod video is actually smaller than the previous generations, it's thinner, and the wider screen makes it seem like it's bigger, when it isn't. I have a case for it, and I'm not careless, but it has fallen a few times, but thanks to the case, which is nothing special, no damage has been done to it. You can just put it in your pocket, or clip it to your belt/pocket if you like, and it doesn't seem like a distraction or anything.
 
Everybody I know that went with an mp3 player that wasn't an ipod, ended up breaking it somehow, and getting an ipod.

I've been using ipods for like 4 years now. I had one of the original ones, and that thing took a nice beating and never broke. I even had a flood in my apartment one day, and it sat, submerged in soapy water for a few hours without breaking.

If you're clumsy, you probably need the most reliable one you can get. I'd go with an ipod. Unless you want to be like my friends and go with something else first. When you break that, you'll end up with an ipod anyway.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Quoting dunksworth:</div><div class="quote_post">Hey Chutney, seeing how you live in Toronto, my only suggestion would be to go to Canada Computers in Pacific Mall. The mp3 players there are a lot cheaper than other store, including Wal Mart. And they're brand name players, not a bunch of no-name brands.

Anyways, I just got a 1gb rca mp3 player there a few months ago for $110, whereas in other stores like The Source or the Bay, they were selling the exact one for around $200.

Here's a link to their mp3 player selections and prices. Sometimes they have different selections when you actually go there though, but it should give you an idea about the prices.
http://www.canadacomputers.com/index.php?d...rt=0&numPages=3

btw, I'm not spamming. I don't work there nor do I know anyone that works there. Just giving some friendly advice.</div>
wat kind of rca did u get i got a lyra (its old and its pretty big) it was 20 gigs for 100$
 
<div class="quote_poster">Quoting 44Thrilla:</div><div class="quote_post">Everybody I know that went with an mp3 player that wasn't an ipod, ended up breaking it somehow, and getting an ipod.

I've been using ipods for like 4 years now. I had one of the original ones, and that thing took a nice beating and never broke. I even had a flood in my apartment one day, and it sat, submerged in soapy water for a few hours without breaking.

If you're clumsy, you probably need the most reliable one you can get. I'd go with an ipod. Unless you want to be like my friends and go with something else first. When you break that, you'll end up with an ipod anyway.</div>

same here man, i had an original for so long the battery went out, so then i got a vid, all the other ones seem to break
 
<div class="quote_poster">Quoting thedude9990:</div><div class="quote_post">wat kind of rca did u get i got a lyra (its old and its pretty big) it was 20 gigs for 100$</div>
20 gigs for only 100 bucks? sounds like a steal!....

But yah, mine is a rca lyra but it's tiny and fairly new. That probably explains why mine cost more for less memory.... Oh and keep in mind that I'm paying Canadian dollars so it'll be a little more than what you'd pay.
 
B00009QSET.01.LZZZZZZZ.jpg
i got it when it first game out its the same one but it says 20 instead of 40
 
Ok what is exactly MP4?? Is it the file types for music or is it the actual thing meaning the player posted in pic above?? so is it file types for music or the player itself??
 
in the pic thats a mp3 player,

a mp4 is a file, a mp4 player is what plays mp4 files
 
<div class="quote_poster">Quoting 44Thrilla:</div><div class="quote_post">Everybody I know that went with an mp3 player that wasn't an ipod, ended up breaking it somehow, and getting an ipod.

I've been using ipods for like 4 years now. I had one of the original ones, and that thing took a nice beating and never broke. I even had a flood in my apartment one day, and it sat, submerged in soapy water for a few hours without breaking.

If you're clumsy, you probably need the most reliable one you can get. I'd go with an ipod. Unless you want to be like my friends and go with something else first. When you break that, you'll end up with an ipod anyway.</div>
Hmm really? I haven't heard of any players other than iPods breaking. iPods are not really known for their quality. Every iPod has been so scratchable, and their battery life is crap after a year.

As for the iPod lasting 14 hours played continously, almost every other player does that too, and goes further. The Samsung equivalent goes for 25 hours of music; the Creative Zen Vision:M has 14 hours of music and 4 hours of video playback time. Almost every equivalent of the iPod Video one-ups the iPod in terms of battery life.

Now there will be nothing as "cool" as the iPod but in terms of functionality, iPod's middle of the pack. It has a great browsing system and others get knocked on for not being as intuitive, but everyone who's not retarded can master any navigation system on an MP3 player within a week.
 
I prefer anything designed by Creative Labs. Their quality is top notch and the price difference between most other brands makes it even more worthy of a purchase. I especially love the models they put out in French electronic shops. The size of the MP3 player also matters and to have one of their 40GB models very small and at only $250 (one time I seen it on sale for $130) is a nice little combo.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Quoting Locke:</div><div class="quote_post">CanadaComputers is not as reliable as Best Buy or FS IMO though.</div>

Well their service obviously won't be as good as Best Buy or FS, but it's still better than a lot of other local computer speciality stores. They're making a ton of money right now so they're not as stingy as others stores in regard to returns and whatnot (they actually have a return policy whereas some have the "all purchases are final policy").

And the amount of money you save going to Canada Computers more than makes up for the supposedly superior service you may get from going to BB/FS. But personally, I haven't had a single problem with CC's service. Granted I haven't attempted to return anything there yet, but when I bought the products initially, they were very helpful.


<div class="quote_poster">Quote:</div><div class="quote_post">Hmm really? I haven't heard of any players other than iPods breaking. iPods are not really known for their quality. Every iPod has been so scratchable, and their battery life is crap after a year.

As for the iPod lasting 14 hours played continously, almost every other player does that too, and goes further. The Samsung equivalent goes for 25 hours of music; the Creative Zen Vision:M has 14 hours of music and 4 hours of video playback time. Almost every equivalent of the iPod Video one-ups the iPod in terms of battery life.

Now there will be nothing as "cool" as the iPod but in terms of functionality, iPod's middle of the pack. It has a great browsing system and others get knocked on for not being as intuitive, but everyone who's not retarded can master any navigation system on an MP3 player within a week.</div>

I agree, I've heard mostly complaints from ppl who own iPods... that's why I went with a cheap mp3 player.

Another thing about the battery with iPods, when it completely dies or gets to the point where it won't last too long, you gotta buy a new iPod. And also, if it dies on you, you gotta wait for it to recharge before using it again. Whereas with most mp3 players, you can just pop in another battery and start listening right away. Oh and another thing, from what I heard, the battery life isn't as long as advertised. Probably other ppl have better experiences with their iPods, but my friend's iPod nano only lasts for 6 hours at most.

Another thing that I find makes mp3 players better is the fact that they're so cheap that you would care less if it get's scratched, dented or even broken or lost. For example, I listen to music when jogging or biking so there's always a possibility that it may take a beating once and a while, but since I have a cheap player, it's not really a concern. Whereas with iPods, I know it'll be a huge concern. Most ppl that I know who own iPods are extremely paranoid about them. They gotta buy all these protective coatings and they get a panic attack if they think they lost it.

Regular mp3 players don't have all the cool functions as iPods, but if you're like me and all you really care about is listening to music, then there's no need to shell out the big bucks for an iPod.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Quoting Locke:</div><div class="quote_post">Hmm really? I haven't heard of any players other than iPods breaking. iPods are not really known for their quality. Every iPod has been so scratchable, and their battery life is crap after a year.</div>
Yeah, I've got this one friend who's gone through 4 Ipods in about 6 years because either the battery stops working or something with the harddrive gets messed up. But he keeps going back because hes a Mac fan and they're the coolest thing on the market.
dunno.gif
 
People are just retarded...

If the battery dies off too quickly for the Ipod (below norm) you probably should send it back to get the battery replaced, or buy the battery yourself and switch it. That's what I've done and its worked fine for me.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Quoting AznxBaller:</div><div class="quote_post">People are just retarded...

If the battery dies off too quickly for the Ipod (below norm) you probably should send it back to get the battery replaced, or buy the battery yourself and switch it. That's what I've done and its worked fine for me.</div>
What a hassle would that be though? If I don't remember wrong, you got your iPod late last year, so the fact that you've already had to change the battery is a testament to how crappy the iPod's battery life is.

When I buy a mp3 player, I want at least two years of trouble-free performance, not where I have to service it every three months like an used car.
 
Well I've had my iPod video for nearly 6 months and haven't experienced any battery life problems. Hopefully it stays the same, but I'm very satisfied with it. How many mp3 can hold 30 GB of mp3's? or even 20? Even if a few do, I'm sure they probably have some battery life problems. I have plenty of music on my computer so I need this more than a regular mp3.
 
i have a rca lyra 20 gigs and it has a really good battery life, me and my cousin turned his video and my lyra and it was about the same time it was maybe a 2 min diffrence
 
<div class="quote_poster">Quoting AznxBaller:</div><div class="quote_post">People are just retarded...

If the battery dies off too quickly for the Ipod (below norm) you probably should send it back to get the battery replaced, or buy the battery yourself and switch it. That's what I've done and its worked fine for me.</div>
Like Locke said, its a hassle plus it costs $60 but I guess thats what it costs for the coolest mp3 player out there. I'm perfectly content with something that looks like crap but will be durable, reliable, and cheaper and an Ipod.
 
I've had my Creative Nomad Zen Xtra for awhile now and i've had no problems with it. It was much cheaper than an ipod ($200) and it has alot of space (30gb). It's biggish and ugly but if you don't care about looking cool with your ipod or about carrying a little more weight i'd go with the Nomad. It's a good bargain if you're a little cost conscious.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top