Put Carcillo in

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Register Log in
No...put Miller in for Fast. That is the move I make. You put Carcillo in and which 4th line player moves into the top 9? Fast made a sloppy play that led to a Flyer PP, and then a PPG. Get Miller in.
 
Nah Miller has done nothing.. Carcillo as experience in the playoffs and has played well. They can double shift Nash who needs to get it going or get outta town
 
So which clear 4th line guy do you put in the top 9? And remember there is no fighting in playoff hockey struds.
 
Its not often i agree with Struds but im totally with you here. He has an edge against Philly too. Take Dorsett out and maybe replace Fast with Miller.
 
Carcillo is shiftier around the net and gets under peoples skin more than Dorsett. Plus he wants to stick it to his former team im sure. Let Dorsett play if they face Columbus.:)
 
So you would take Dorsett out. I could get on board with that a lot easier than Fast out for Carcillo. I find it interesting that struds makes a suggestion then has no response for the top 9, but I guess that is par for the course.
 
If you're going to take Fast out then Miller would be the guy to replace him. Only Carcillo for Dorsett, who are almost the same player makes sense.
 
The end of game debacle with the goalie pull thing is really annoying. If it's under 1'30 left I believe you have to pull the goalie once the puck gets into the other end, whether they retrieve it or not. If you try and wait for the perfect time it always backfires, especially for the Rangers. This is the 2-3rd time it's happened this year.
 
I would get miller in there for fasth. Use Carcillo for Dorsett. I like the suggestion to double shift Nash to try and get him going. Richards looked like he was on fumes today after playing well game 1. Though he's playing there looks like an imposter in there for the real Mcdonagh. Guys are going around him like he's not there and everybody is bodying him off the puck. Looks like a real lack of strength in that shoulder but its the playoffs so if he can't hurt it further he's got to be out there. I hate strahlmans game against a physical team like philly or anyone else for that matter. Hope he doesn't shit in his pants in philly.
 
the only question i have had all year about AV, his opinion of carcillo
 
Sorry I dont hang around the internet all day chucky

Put Carcillo on the 4th line and move Dorsett up to play with Richards and Hagelin. Then give Nash some shifts with them
 
Put Nash on the bench. He is the biggest disappointment we have. Just be physical with him and he disappears. same old same old.
 
You just post in numerous other threads way after that question right...LOL.

Anyway, that says it all. You want Dorsett in the top 9. I'll leave that one alone.
 
I'd also like to see Carcillo in and would do it for Dorsett. He's shiftier around the net and agree there'd be a little motivation factor against Philly. That said, changing the 12th forward is not gonna be the difference. Fact is we lost because Philly was hungrier, skated harder, and moved the puck quicker. They were more desperate. There will be ups and downs and no one said it will be easy. Still think we take one there and win it in 6 or 7.
 
I dont think Dorsett has played that bad. He can skate with Hags and Richards.

Miller wouldnt be bad but i doubt AV puts him in unless there is an injury
 
Carcillo on line one with Nash..lol... you never know av did it once and it worked

Sent from my SM-G900P using Tapatalk
 
To be realistic. ..we lost one game and line up changes must happen?

Sent from my SM-G900P using Tapatalk
 
BigDaddyAl1973 said:
To be realistic. ..we lost one game and line up changes must happen?

Sent from my SM-G900P using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

While i agree that after only 1 loss there's no need to go and change the lines, i also agree with your previous post right before this one that Carcillo has played on the 1st line before and actually worked, so i wouldn't be opposed to it again. If there is 1 opponent we could benefit from having 2 tough guys in the lineup (Carcillo / Dorsett) it's Philly.
 
Ill agree to that for the fact we need more aggitating and agression in this series...I would think about sitting d moore and let Boyle center Dorsett and carcillo

Sent from my SM-G900P using Tapatalk
 
That'd be a nice, tough 4th line, but if AV wants to play Carcillo alongside Stepan and Nash, i'd have no problem with that either. Maybe having an agitator on his line will wake Nash up too. He needs to be our best forward in the playoffs so it's important to get him going.
 
BigDaddyAl1973 said:
To be realistic. ..we lost one game and line up changes must happen?

Sent from my SM-G900P using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

True but to me it makes no sense to have somebody like Fast out there and Dorsett is just completely useless.
 
good idea Carcillo - Stepan - Nash. Then they can move St. Louis with Richards, or Nash with Richards..... Nash has got to wake up. If you look at top guys on the Avs, Ducks, Habs, etc their top guys are getting it done
 
Avs and Ducks both got shut out last night. If we got shut out in the playoffs, even if we were up 2 in the series, all hell would break loose on this board. Nash has 13 shots in 2 games this series. He will break through soon in a big way I bet. Compare that with Giroux's ZERO.

As for this thread, Carcillo is not going to be the reason this teams wins or loses. Replace Fast with Miller if we want to make a change that might actually make a difference.
 
Miller appears to be in the doghouse, though.
 
BTW Prod, while i agree Carcillo is not going to be the reason this team wins or loses this series, he can be a considerable contributor to the team winning with his agitating style of game against a tough team. If we were playing, say, the Wings, i would see no need for Carcillo, but against the dirty Flyers i see value in having him in the lineup.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

sorr
Carcillo could get a suspension of 10-20 games
Replies
27
Views
1K
Ranger71
Ranger71
J
Any word on the Carcillo hearing?
Replies
2
Views
660
jamsim67
J
C
Jesper Fast Called Up
Replies
6
Views
706
Ranger71
Ranger71
dumpstralmannow
Hoping Girardi is signed soon, Cally gets the boot
Replies
11
Views
857
Ranger71
Ranger71
C
Oilers Game
Replies
20
Views
2K
BigDaddyAl1973
BigDaddyAl1973

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top