Sorry Rob...

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Register Log in
Rick2583

Rick2583

Chairman of the board
Joined
Jul 9, 2013
Messages
15,629
Likes
719
Points
113
Donnie baseball & your LA Dodgers have been eliminated 3 games to 1
 
...not that his moves or lack thereof cost the Dodgers in the NLDS, and not that I was not a huge fan of Mattingly, because I was...but he has not impressed me as a manager.
 
yankeesince59 said:
...not that his moves or lack thereof cost the Dodgers in the NLDS, and not that I was not a huge fan of Mattingly, because I was...but he has not impressed me as a manager.
Click to expand...


Agree.

___________________________


Re: 2014 playoffs up to date......
Quote Originally Posted by Rick2583 View Post
Me too, I love Donnie but some of the players there are just a little to cocky for me. Mainly the loose cannon they call Puig.
_____________________________


(blg post 6)

I also love Donnie Baseball but from what I've seen and heard past couple of years...he's not a good manager...and I'm afraid he's a bad manager. And don't tell me he doesn't have good players. lol

Okay, there - I said it. Now the Dodgers will go out there and win the whole thing. lol
 
Last edited:
Hated the Dodgers when they were in Brooklyn, no change when they went to LA. Felt bad for Mattingly though the man deserves better.
 
He just doesn't seem to fit as a manager. That being said I'm sure they thought they would ride the back of Kershaw but as great as he is terrible in the post season.
 
I haven't heard Mattingly is a bad Mgr. Yet, I have heard tons of press, and analysts point out over and over, Donnie has had more than his hands full, babysitting over priced and hyped Personalities, ie, Puig, Ramirez, even Kemp when he wasn't ready to play CF.....

Any way you slice and dice it, I'm not sure what criteria to use to grade Don's report card, as a skipper. If its merely the lack of going forth to the Series then sure he's failed. If its not pulling Kershaw out prior to a 3 run HR, then that's debatable. The game today, was literally a game of inches. Kershaw gave up 2 hits prior to the bomb, should he of pulled Kershaw then? Questionable at best, since those two hits off the glove of Gordon and Ramirez, were so close, it truly is a game of inches......

Would I of pulled Kershaw at that point, just prior to his hanging curve HR. One knock on Kershaw's last two outings, was sooooo predictable, ie, Kershaw gets the count with 2 strikes with nothing but Fastballs, then throws the big hook, and that much was too predictable. St. Louis batters were waiting on that pitch, too dang predictable. I'm not sure how Donnie was to blame, since the Cards have an approx 4.00+ ERA against the Bums since 2013, and of course Kershaw lost 2 NLCS games last year. Should Don started Greinke as his #1 SP. I think he should have. Greinke was the Pitcher last year, who stopped the bleeding.....and Zach is a pretty damn good hitter too......

So guys, please help me out, in what sense would you give Donnie a failing grade as a Mgr. I'm totally open minded on this one, and would appreciate any info ya'll provide on Mattingly as a Mgr.....I'll respect any input given....and thanks for as much....:smile:

Back to the Bums, when I moved to California in 68, I lived an hour south of Frisco and Oakland. In 67, I lived in Shreveport, home then of the AAA Giants, and note: I hated those effing Bums, but loved Mays, McCovey, Marichal, Perry, McCormick, et al. Even got all of these guys autographs in a exhibition game in Shreveport, and again in Candlestick, when the OF fence was nothing but a chain link.....

I went to Candlestick and Oakland to see some great History in the making. Saw a double header of the A's vs. those great O's teams...and of course Mays and Mantle were my favorite players of that era......

then I moved to Southern Cal. Had mixed feelings about the Bums, I always admired Koufax, and saw him Pitch in L.A. (on vacation in 64) Drysdale too, and didn't mind the Alston Teams. Tho' I'd root for the Giants any day over L.A.

then along came Tommy f'kng Lasorda, like the movie Fletch, I've never despised a shit head of a Mgr, than Lasorda, he ruined any taste for Dodger blue. Lasorda IMHO was one of the worst Mgrs, IMO in the history of the game....Just my 2 cents. If not for the scouting reports, Gibson would of never had that back door slider which he was told to wait on with 2 strikes, shades of waiting on Kershaws 2 strike hanging curve.

anyway-yes, I even got a disdain for Vin Scully, as I once said, if I hear another effing "Farmer John" Ham, bacon and hot dog commercial I would never watch another Bums game.....

So there you have it, the only time, I even watched regular season Bums games, was when Torre came to L.A. and with Don at the helm, I've enjoyed those games, but disdain players like Puig and Ramirez, they have their heads up their asses.

should Matttingly of benched both for insubordination???? Therein lies the Question and more if you want to toss as much this way, I'd appreciate it.....
'
Thanks band of brothers....! :smile:
 
Sorry for such a long post, but I'd love some input on Donnie BB, as a "bad mgr", again, I wont debate or even argue, defend any info provided, I'm just curious not how, but why others perceive Don as a "bad mgr"....Thanx...!

As a player, #23 was one incredible player, seeing how he was drafted as the 25th Pick of the 19th round, 493 overall....Don made $35.000 in his 1st year, 1983. He wasn't expected to be the cornerstone of the Yanx....and the rest is history....!


BTW-Rick can you pass the Kleenex? LMAO....J/K
 
Mattingly23NY said:
Sorry for such a long post, but I'd love some input on Donnie BB, as a "bad mgr", again, I wont debate or even argue, defend any info provided, I'm just curious not how, but why others perceive Don as a "bad mgr"....Thanx...!

As a player, #23 was one incredible player, seeing how he was drafted as the 25th Pick of the 19th round, 493 overall....Don made $35.000 in his 1st year, 1983. He wasn't expected to be the cornerstone of the Yanx....and the rest is history....!


BTW-Rick can you pass the Kleenex? LMAO....J/K
Click to expand...


The Nats just tied the Giants up at 2 in the top of the 7th, if this series goes back to Washington I think the Giants are screwed.
 
Rick2583 said:
The Nats just tied the Giants up at 2 in the top of the 7th, if this series goes back to Washington I think the Giants are screwed.
Click to expand...

With that I give you Matt Thorton....
 
Rick2583 said:
The Nats just tied the Giants up at 2 in the top of the 7th, if this series goes back to Washington I think the Giants are screwed.
Click to expand...

Loaded, 1 out in the bottom of the 7th.
 
Last edited:
Rick2583 said:
The Nats just tied the Giants up at 2 in the top of the 7th, if this series goes back to Washington I think the Giants are screwed.
Click to expand...

ahhh yes, a run scores on a bases loaded passed ball, I hope the Giants pull this one off, and beat those red birds, oh shit, they got to win this game....!!! ie, Beat the Nats 1st, and another passed ball, Me-Thinks the Nats ae screwed, hope so anyhow- :smile:
 
Mattingly23NY said:
ahhh yes, a run scores on a bases loaded passed ball, I hope the Giants pull this one off, and beat those red birds, oh shit, they got to win this game....!!! ie, Beat the Nats 1st, and another passed ball, Me-Thinks the Nats ae screwed, hope so anyhow- :smile:
Click to expand...

Noooooo......I want to see the Nat's vs the cards.
 
Mattingly23NY said:
Cheers Rick to another NLCS courtesy of Frisco.....!
Click to expand...



Yeah my friend there seems to be a pattern forming here, the even years belong to the Giants of late. 2010, 2012 & now here we are in 2014. GO GIANTS!
 
Loved Donnie Baseball as a player but honestly never knew that he had managerial aspirations until he tried for the Yankees job. As far as this Dodger Team goes he's had some real "head cases" needing a good swift kick in the pants. Did not help that Kershaw stepped on his tallywhacker in both games but as we Yankee fans are well aware of the Dodger bats went cold. Once again we will probably hear Adrian Gonzales say that God did not want the Dodgers to win. Gonna be a long winter in Los Angeles and Anaheim this year. The Angels may have been better off re-signing Torii Hunter than spending all that cash for Junkie Josh.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top