You're right...how could anyone criticize a guy who's been whining about teammates while playing at a level below Gilbert Arenas?
Here's a list of guys over the last ten years who've played like Roy is playing this season.
(15 FGA/gm, 3+ APG, 3+ RPG, <40% FGA)
3 Baron Davis's
3 Gilbert Arenas
2 Iverson's
2 Antoine Walker's
2 Jamal Crawford's
2 Larry Hughes
and Tyreke Evans and Brandon Jennings this year.
Or, put another way, there hasn't been a single player (other than Roy) in the last 10 years who's averaged 15 shots a game, made 40% or less of them, and had less than 4 rebounds and 4 assists per game. Not one. If you bump it up to 43%, then he's in the august company of Latrell Sprewell and Kevin Martin.
I don't deserve a guy whose play is making Latrell Sprewell look good getting in front of the mike every night talking about his teammates' deficiencies.
BTW, I didn't hear Ms. Cox, but I wonder why it's "respectful" for Duncan to tell Roy to change his game, but when WE say it we don't deserve him and we don't know what we're talking about.