<div class="quote_poster">Quoting virve119:</div><div class="quote_post">Livingston #1? Seriously, am I the only one who thinks this guy is seriously overrated. He's about as athletic as a tree, he's 6'8" and can't dunk.</div>
Livingston doesn't have a 40+ inch vertical or anything, but he's tall and long, of course he can dunk, he can do some nice ones to, but that's the stupidest thing I've heard. Dunking doesn't make a good basketball player, if it did, Andre Emmett would be a star right now. Outside of that, while he's not extremely explosive, or a "high jumper", he's extremely quick and fast at 6'7, I'm pretty sure quickness and speed are part of athletic ability.
<div class="quote_poster">Quote:</div><div class="quote_post">You're not alone, I also happen to think Livingston is trash (at least at the fourth pick last year, but hey, what do you expect from the clippers), way worse than Telfair, who is way worse than Jameer Nelson. Very much of a reach at 4 last year to me. But hey, if their logic is right he's gonna beamazing, because height isall that matters and he's 6'8 point guard. Actual bball abillity never mattered to anyone.</div>
To both you and virve, did you even watch the guy play, or are you doing the bad thing, and looking at stats without knowing the situation or watching the player? I'm assuming the second option is right, because up till now, I haven't seen anyone who watched Livingston play during the end of the season [when he was actually getting minutes], and was not impressed.
Livingston now is somehow WAY worse than Telfair who has shown nothing yet except being high up in the league in turnovers PER 48 mins, while averaging minimal assists, and WAY worse than Jameer who didn't do anything extremely special in his rookie year either, wow, very interesting.
Let me explain to you why they want to see Livingston.
1) He only played 30 games last season, not many people who aren't Clipper fans got to see him, as you guys are showing, and many have heard so much, but not seen.
2) He's a very exciting player, and that's without dunking, he throws passes you wouldn't even see coming.
3) After coming back from injury, and to end the season, he averaged 11 PPG, 4.4 RPG, 7.4 APG, 1.4 SPG, 2.9 TPG, and 44% FG. A good amount of his turnovers during the year were from him finding teamamtes with passing in situations where they didn't even think the ball could get to them.
Jameer Nelson can score better, but he's not that exciting a player, and he played 79 games. You won't find him getting many highlight reels unless he's just passing to Howard and having him to his thing. Telfair, while he's nice also didn't show as much flair as Shaun, and also played 68 games, while we haven't seen as much of him, we've seen a lot less of Shaun.