The problem with Nate refusing to even consider starting Miller over Blake and steadfastly continuing to start Blake, when Miller was clearly out playing him, helped foster the whole Andre and Brandon can't co-exist mentality in the local media, the fan base and most importantly on the team. Miller and Roy cannot coexist was accepted as fact by many even before the two ever set foot on the court together (they coexisted just fine down the stretch last season, before Roy got injured heading into the play-offs). That mentality was so pervasive that even earlier this year, when Brandon was totally sucking, he continued to blame his struggles on Andre and not his own diminished abilities. When you don't start your best players, you better damn well have a good reason - one that you can clearly articulate, that the players understand and accept.
Fortunately, Nate learned his lesson and didn't dick around with Gerald Wallace coming off the bench for three and a half months before moving him into the starting line-up. After all, we won more games with Nic starting the past two seasons than we will this season. Does that mean Nic should automatically start ahead of Wallace? No, you start the best players and let them get used to each other and learn their roles.
It would have been different if Blake and Andre were equal in past and current performance, but they were not. At the time Andre was coming off the bench with a PER in the 16.5 - 17 range and Blake was starting with a PER of 9 and a horrible shooting percentage. Starting Blake to placate Roy was hurting the team on the court, and causing dissension in the ranks. And just fanned the flames of the Miller and Roy cannot coexist mentality. Personally, I wanted Miller starting from day 1 in training camp and preseason so him and Roy could get used to playing together. Once Miller finally became the starting PG, Roy played his best ball of the season. Ironically, Blake's PER also shot up and his shooting improved when he was moved to the bench and allowed to go head to head with other second string PGs. When Nate finally moved Miller into the starting PG spot, the play of all three players improved - and that's why Miller should have been starting from day 1.
BNM