I've never been a huge Monroe fan. He's sort of a bigger, slightly better version of J.J. Hickson. Like Hickson, I wouldn't mind a guy like Monroe coming off the bench to back up the starting center and PF positions, but if we lose Aldridge and replace him with Monroe in the starting line up, we're fucked.
A couple red flags about Monroe:
I'm always leery of guys who put up good numbers on crappy teams. Call it the Kevin Love factor. Love put up comically big numbers on some comically bad MIN teams. Monroe has been in the league 5 years and has never played on a team that's won more than 32 games. His numbers have been solid, usually in the 16 pt/9 reb range as a starter on a bad team. Like Love, whose numbers were much higher in MIN, put Monroe on a good team with other scoring options and his numbers will likely drop. Again, this is why I say were fucked if we think we can replace Aldridge's 23/11 with Monroe's 16/9 (or less).
The second red flag is that while Monroe isn't quite the net negative type player that J.J. Hickson is, according to 82 games, Monroe has had a net negative production in 2 of his 5 seasons in the league. He always puts up good "Own Production" numbers, but usually gives up almost as much as, or more than, he gets. The good news is, this season was his best net production to date with an Own Production of of 22.8 and an Opp Production of 18.5 for a Net Production of +4.2 (their rounding error, not mine). Still, with an Opp Production of 18.5, he's not exactly a defensive stopper.
Compare this to Aldridge's Own Production of 24.1 and a Opp Production of 13.7 for a Net Production of +10.4, you can see why I say if we replace Aldridge with Monroe in our starting lineup we're fucked big time.
So yeah, I'd love Monroe to back up the 4 and 5 positions, but as a replacement for Aldridge, no thanks.
BNM