Controversial replay rulings in OSU-Arizona game call issues into question

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

tlongII

Legendary Poster
Joined
Sep 15, 2008
Messages
17,358
Likes
12,116
Points
113
http://www.portlandtribune.com/sports/story.php?story_id=128691796521831900

The Beavers came out on the short end of instant-replay review — or lack of it — at least four times, which might be considered luck of the draw in most circumstances.

Not so much, though, when the replay official is a Tucson citizen, an Arizona grad and, according to one source, a donor to the school’s athletic department.

The man working Saturday was Jim Fogltance, a former Pac-10 football crew chief who earned his degree from the UA in 1967.

Among the disputed plays:

• Rodgers’ first-quarter catch of a low ball that was ruled a reception by the game officials. After review, the call was overturned.

• Rodgers’ 3-yard catch later in the quarter that was ruled a touchdown by the game officials. After review, the call was overturned.

• A first-quarter bomb caught by Arizona’s Juron Criner that was ruled a touchdown by game officials. It appeared that Criner landed on the 1-yard-line and rolled into the end zone. After review, the call was upheld.

• Then, a catch by an Arizona receiver — similar to the Rodgers’ play — that was ruled a reception by game officials. Fogltance chose not to review the play.


Just a terribly officiated game. The Beavs were lucky to win it with all the home-cooking going on.
 
I did think the first one was on the fence and kept telling myself that they have to use independent judgement on those things.

But that 2nd one I was shocked at as you could clearly see green grass come up from his spikes which tells me while he's close to the line, he's definitely pulling up green grass from the bulk of his spikes. And they overturned it, which I couldn't believe you could call that indisputable evidence. So it makes more sense now.

Hopefully they'll have some punishment. Something like USC and ban them from post-season play (Yah right - it will get swept under the rug).
 
They should of had THE HCP down there!
 
Yes James Rogers Got F@*&ED, by the officials and the opponents who couldn't cope with his dominance

Hopefully OSU's core (Defense, Lines) are just a strong next year when he comes back
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top