Just for fun all time Blazers starting 5

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

I think Roy was one of the top 2-3 most skilled Blazers ever. He was unstoppable at his best. If his career goes 10 years, he’s a 8 or 9 time all star with multiple all nbas. His teams would have gotten deeper into playoffs eventually. He and Lillard are the only guys opponents have “feared” in the last fifteen years or so.
Roy was great his third year here. I actually looked at the playoffs stats again, he was super good against Houston. He was 2nd team all NBA and had MVP votes. So I'll agree with you how excellent he was that one season.

Year prior Roy was in his second year working to lead the Blazers after Zach and couldn't get the Blazers to a winning record. Year after he got injured and was never the same.
 
Assuming they're healthy, of course:

Lillard
Roy
Drexler
Aldridge
Oden (in his very short prime, he was a monster)
No.

Oden was never a monster. It was exciting to daydream of how dominant he could be, unfortunately we never saw that.

I was in the arena when his kneecap shattered. He was averaging 11ppg 8rpg (career highs). He also was averaging 4 fouls per game.
 
So best players who played on the Blazers, not that they were at their best when on the Blazers:
G - Lenny Wilkens
G - Drazen Petrovic
F - Clyde Drexler
F - Scottie Pippen
C - Bill Walton

6th & 7th men - Sabonis and Walter Davis
All HOFers who at one time played on the Blazers
 
I didn't see the part in the OP about best player in their prime even if it wasn't with the Blazers, and that got me to thinking about the Walton-Sabonis comparison.

Sabonis never really had a prime. Injuries robbed him of it. And still an all-time great.

Walton was the greatest fundamental C I ever watched. Offense was the weak point of his game and he went something like 21-of-22 from the field in a Final Four game.

Sabonis was a mountain of a man as a teenager, great size for a C even when the Cs were true behemoths. He had the agility of a 3, and passed like some of the best PGs. If you think Karl Malone was intimidating filling the lane on the break, Sabonis before the injuries was twice that.

I think, had neither had major injuries and we might have gotten to see Walton v Sabonis in the Olympics, people still would be talking about it. I come back to this, though: As great as Walton was, Sabonis was everything and an even better athlete. Walton could outmuscle Kareem. He couldn't do that to a healthy, 25-year-old Sabonis. Sabonis brought all the skill and type of play Walton did, but he just was a little bit better in most phases and more athletic. I think Walton would be worked to the max on defense trying to contain Sabonis, and I'm not sure that would happen on the other end of the floor.
 
And, yeah, if it's best in their prime even if prime wasn't with the Blazers, I don't know how Moses Malone isn't the PF.
 
And, yeah, if it's best in their prime even if prime wasn't with the Blazers, I don't know how Moses Malone isn't the PF.
and Sabonis would be the starting center if prime at anytime in their career is the criteria
 
Man, anyone who doesn't have Lillard in their starting 5 is out of their God-damned mind.

Lillard
Drexler
Pippen
Sheed
Walton
 
The fact that this conversation is still going on..... tells you that it's peak offseason.
 
So best players who played on the Blazers, not that they were at their best when on the Blazers:
G - Lenny Wilkens
G - Drazen Petrovic
F - Clyde Drexler
F - Scottie Pippen
C - Bill Walton

6th & 7th men - Sabonis and Walter Davis
All HOFers who at one time played on the Blazers
When was Lenny Wilkens ever better than Lillard? And when was Drazen better than Roy?
 
Damon Stoudamire
Damian Lillard
Brandon Roy
Sidney Wicks
Buck Williams

bench:
Malcom Brogdon, Geoff Petrie

[all Rookie of the Year winners]
 
And, yeah, if it's best in their prime even if prime wasn't with the Blazers, I don't know how Moses Malone isn't the PF.
Well - besides the small fact Moses Malone never played a game for the Blazers.
 
Man, anyone who doesn't have Lillard in their starting 5 is out of their God-damned mind.

Lillard
Drexler
Pippen
Sheed
Walton
Lillard is almost a top 5 Blazer PG - but once Jrue plays a game he will knock him down to 7th if we're using his Bucks/Celtics play;

Porter
Pippen
Lenny Wilkens
Andre Miller
Strickland
Dame
 
Last edited:
When was Lenny Wilkens ever better than Lillard? And when was Drazen better than Roy?
Lenny Wilkens was certainly better than Lillard. He was #2 in MVP voting in 1968 behind Wilt - he was ahead of Oscar Robertson and Elgin Baylor. Dame was never close to that level of player.

Its surprising two years later how much Blazer fans still overrate Lillard.
 
I didn't see the part in the OP about best player in their prime even if it wasn't with the Blazers, and that got me to thinking about the Walton-Sabonis comparison.

Sabonis never really had a prime. Injuries robbed him of it. And still an all-time great.

Walton was the greatest fundamental C I ever watched. Offense was the weak point of his game and he went something like 21-of-22 from the field in a Final Four game.

Sabonis was a mountain of a man as a teenager, great size for a C even when the Cs were true behemoths. He had the agility of a 3, and passed like some of the best PGs. If you think Karl Malone was intimidating filling the lane on the break, Sabonis before the injuries was twice that.

I think, had neither had major injuries and we might have gotten to see Walton v Sabonis in the Olympics, people still would be talking about it. I come back to this, though: As great as Walton was, Sabonis was everything and an even better athlete. Walton could outmuscle Kareem. He couldn't do that to a healthy, 25-year-old Sabonis. Sabonis brought all the skill and type of play Walton did, but he just was a little bit better in most phases and more athletic. I think Walton would be worked to the max on defense trying to contain Sabonis, and I'm not sure that would happen on the other end of the floor.
I wouldn't be surprised if prime healthy Sabonis played Walton and was clearly the best. The problem is its all theoretical as we don't have games of that Sabonis against the NBA greats. We have Sabonis dominating David Robinson for a game but other centers like Hakeem did that later as well. Walton did dominate the NBA at his peak even if it was only a couple healthy seasons - thats over 100x the sample of Sabonis.
 
If it’s prime im pretty sure Sabonis was a top 5-10 player in the world in his prime.


Oh Sabonis was certainly top5 if not higher. Walton was #1 at times - as evident by his finals MVP and following regular season MVP.
 
No.

Oden was never a monster. It was exciting to daydream of how dominant he could be, unfortunately we never saw that.

I was in the arena when his kneecap shattered. He was averaging 11ppg 8rpg (career highs). He also was averaging 4 fouls per game.
I was there, too. The impact he had on both ends of the floor was dramatic, regardless of individual stats.

Besides, this is a thought experiment, and the thought of watching those five guys play together, each in full health and in his prime, gives me minor chubbage.
 
Lenny Wilkens was certainly better than Lillard. He was #2 in MVP voting in 1968 behind Wilt - he was ahead of Oscar Robertson and Elgin Baylor. Dame was never close to that level of player.

Its surprising two years later how much Blazer fans still overrate Lillard.
OK. I disagree.
 
Lenny Wilkens was certainly better than Lillard. He was #2 in MVP voting in 1968 behind Wilt - he was ahead of Oscar Robertson and Elgin Baylor. Dame was never close to that level of player.

Its surprising two years later how much Blazer fans still overrate Lillard.

what is surprising is the bile you have for Dame
 
On the man's birthday no less.


yeah...I'm old enough to have seen Wilkins play when he played for the Hawks, and later for the Sonics. Wilkins was a good player; a cerebral player. But at no point in time was he as good as Dame
 
I feel like in order to make this a true Blazers starting 5, you have to go with how they played as Trail Blazers, what stages of their career they were at when here in Rip City.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top