I’d love to have Aldridge back. Presuming we don’t give up too much to get him back, I think you are crazy/biased if you don’t want him back.
The way I see it, it is all contingent upon a few factors.
1. Whitesides fit here, and the probability of his long term commitment to the franchise.
2. Nurks recovery progress and ability to be as productive for us as he was prior to injury.
3. Dame/CJs willingness to have him back
4. Aldridge’s willingness to fill the role he is asked to fill, not the one he may want to fill.
Now if Whiteside does not fit as hoped, or he makes it clear he wishes to depart in FA then I would say a Whiteside for LA swap is well within the realm of possibilities.
Likewise if Nurk comes back and is able to contribute as he has, even if in limited minutes, then I believe regardless of where we are with Whiteside(unless he is playing the best ball of his career) that a Whiteside - LA swap is again in the realm of possibilities.
As for #3 and #4, I don’t think Dame or CJ would have any problem welcoming LA back, so long as #4 is met; which would mean that Aldridge has to be part of the bigger whole, that Dame and CJ don’t have to change ‘what they do’ in order to acclimate Aldridge into the picture.
For #4 I don’t think LA would have a problem if his role here wasn’t exactly the same as before. That he isn’t “the guy” per say, but he’s “the guy” in the sense that he is a key piece for a championship caliber team.
Let’s be honest here... If Nurk is healthy being Nurk, and we add LA as well; then our S5 of Dame-CJ-Hood-Aldridge-Nurkic WOULD be a championship contending team for years. A well balanced S5 in terms of defense and offense, floor spacing and options for where/who to go to in offensive sets.
All in all, I think it makes more sense for Aldridge to return in FA than it is for him to return as part of a trade. But I do think we would be the undisputed #1 on his list if he ever leaves SA. Perhaps at that point we could have him on a ‘favorable’ contract as well.
I do think it is highly probable that we will see LA in a rip city jersey again some day. Book it!