Here's how I'd rate this game. (For Xbox 360 by the way)Music - 1.5/2: I personally like the music. I guess it all depends on your taste in music. I thought it'd be more screaming stuff, considering everyone was saying how emo it is, but I haven't heard one song where they scream.Gameplay - 3/3: I thought this was great. Controls seem crisp (as far as I've noticed) and easy to pick up. I love this lead blocker thing, it's very fun.Graphics - 2.5/3: Players and all that look great. But some small things make me mad. When it's a rainy game, and it gets muddy and their's puddles on the field, water doesn't splash around when you run through it. When you fall in the mud, your jersey doesn't get dirty. The "clear" visor isn't clear in any way shape or form. These are just some small things, so I didn't take off much.Features - 2/3: There were a lot of cool features in this game. But I HATE when you unlock Hall of Famers, you can't delete them. This ruins franchise mode completely, considering teams have players like Sammy Baugh, Carl Eller, Barry Sanders on their team, and that takes soo much fun out of it. You cannot edit players either (i.e. edit Brandon Lloyd so he doesn't have long dreadlocks, or change Tye Hill's number to his actual number). The mini-games are fun. 40 yard dash, bench press, and the other games (one for QBs, one for RBs, WRs, etc). But they would be much better if you could pick which player you want to be for each drill. Rather than the fastest player on whatever team you chose for the 40, and the left tackle (I think, maybe it goes by strongest, I haven't really looked. i've just noticed that i've been a left tackle each time) for the bench press.Superstar mode - 2.5/3: I guess a lot of people will like it. It's pretty in depth and fun. But too unrealistic for me. You can run the 40 in over 5.0 seconds and end up with speed in the high 90s. That's ridiculous. You usually don't get picked in the high rounds, but you still have an overall in the high 80s to mid 90s? That's bogus. I don't like the camera view that much during games. It's tough for QBs to see all of their receivers on the field. I'm a little disappointed in its unrealisticness (if that's a word), but it's still pretty cool.Overall - 11.5/14: I think this game is fun, and can be addicting. I suggest you turn the difficulty up to All-Pro though right away (if not All-Madden). It's definitely a buy. It'd be a B+ or maybe even A- if I gave it a letter.