To me with Staal it is about his play on some level for sure, clearly he is not close to the dman he used to be, but I think it is even deeper than that. The guy wants 5/6 years 5.5/6 mill per, and I just don't see how we can possibly re-sign him to that type of deal given our team makeup and the cap situation. Frankly I think it would be flat out crazy to do so.
Boyle signed for next season. Girardi signed for many more seasons. Klein signed for a few more seasons. McD signed for many more seasons. We have some kids close. Moore will be here. I just don't see the need for Staal with that type of contract.
We should play out this season, if we are in it at the trade DL and can get back a good top 4 dman trade Staal. If we cannot get a good return (and this is the most likely option) we let the season play out and Staal can walk this summer, I am okay with that in his case. If we are out of it (unlikely) we deal Staal for something future at the trade DL.
This has been my opinion since early summer and has nothing to really do with his play through 9 games, but that has locked in my opinion even more.