To be honest, I never really understood what happened at that other place either, so I decided to take a walk down memory lane.
Looks to me like Community Moderators were largely the problem, popping into threads and insulting people like Xericx. Here's an example of someone named Cinco de Mayo coming out of nowhere and acting like an assclown in post #14. And R-star of course.
http://www.basketballforum.com/political-economy/410876-biden-asked-man-wheelchair-stand-up.html
Below is another long-ass thread. At one point Cindo de Mayo compares himself to a bouncer at a club. It's clear to see that those moderators were too full of themselves. Basel, another mod, said that ABM was originally banned for sending PM's to his friends to go to another site, calling it 'spam', if you can believe that shit. There is a HUGE difference between spam, and writing PM's to those you know.
I glanced over the last few pages of maxiep posts and while he was clearly opinionated I saw nothing wrong in the least. Right up until his last post in fact. Whatever. In the last election everyone had strong opinions, nothing wrong with that.
Bottom line, the mods seemed to just come to the board to argue, usually in a passive-aggressive manner, humorously attempting to act objective and fair, and then continually insulting members, making a mountain out of a molehill, and locking and banning everything they sought fit. It's liked being moderated by the trolls themselves, it's not going to end peacefully.
http://www.basketballforum.com/portland-trail-blazers/411778-7-members-here.html
As for the 'other' topic - I don't think Kobe raped that girl, but none of us can call it fact that he did or did not.