Event Poll...Who would you rather have as GM?

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Register Log in

Who would you rather have as GM?

  • Dave Dombrowski

  • Brian Cashman

Results are only viewable after voting.
Neck & neck, this thing could go down to the wire.
 
bern_baby_bern said:
Neither. Dombrowski's won nothing. Learned that he desperately needed a bullpen in 2012 but didn't address it and watched his BP blow 2013, gifting an ALCS to the Red Sox. When he wins a WS I'll give him due props, until then he's another Beane. My opinion of course, sure I'll be smited for it.
Click to expand...


Sounds good, but you have to give Dombrowski some credit....
His Tigers HAVE WON... a WS game - (1-8) in two WS.
 
blgridesagain said:
Sounds good, but you have to give Dombrowski some credit....
His Tigers HAVE WON... a WS game - (1-8) in two WS.
Click to expand...

...then why didn't you vote for either him or Cashman?... I ask because the person you're trying to piggy-back actually voted for Dombrowski........Derp
 
Mattingly23NY said:
No one can strike a deal like Beane, no one......

No one has done more with less, than Billy Beane.......while averaging the 4th lowest payroll, in the last 7 years, (2008).

Beane gets the most bang for his buck.......Who else on God's Green Earth, goes to Post Season Play more often, than most, with less?

NTM- who else has ever acquired any player in a trade, for only 1$.....?
Click to expand...
yankeesince59 said:
...then why didn't you vote for either him or Cashman?... I ask because the person you're trying to piggy-back actually voted for Dombrowski........Derp
Click to expand...

I said my piece.
blip...blip....blip....blip....
 
...and you said it without the aid of an interpreter...how impressive.

...btw, the vote stands at 7-0...but then again, it's still early.
 
And they're coming up at the far turn, its Beane on the outside, Dombrowski coming up on the inside & bringing up the rear is Cashman.
 
^^^Cashman doesn't "bring up the rear"....he takes it in the rear, and evidently likes it.
 
Dumbrowski's Tigers 1-8 W-L record in world series games.
But I guess he's thrilled leading 7-0 in the bobblehead poll.
 
Well if you only value GMs by WS W-L record, than I think your giving Cashman too much credit and not enough credit to Stick.

upload_2015-4-30_19-50-14.jpeg
 
blgridesagain said:
Dumbrowski's Tigers 1-8 W-L record in world series games.
But I guess he's thrilled leading 7-0 in the bobblehead poll.
Click to expand...


...the poll question had nothing to do with WS Titles, but you already knew that. right?...It was simply about who is the better GM. And according to the poll Dombrowski is better, period. Don't like the results?...tough.

...if you like to list your reasons why you think Dombrowski is "dumb" and why you think Cashman is a better GM, lets hear it. But you might also want to consider the Yanx's PS record vs the Tigers. Here's a hint; the Tigers bounced the Yanx from the PS in 2006, 2011, and 2012. Cashman's Yanx are 0-3 vs Dombrowski's Tigers in the PS.

...as per usual, your twisted logic makes no sense.
 
How is this even a debate? And honestly I STILL don't understand how Cashman even got the job to begin with, wasn't he only about 27-28 when it was given to him? I mean what exactly did he do to warrant such a position?
 
Rick2583 said:
How is this even a debate? And honestly I STILL don't understand how Cashman even got the job to begin with, wasn't he only about 27-28 when it was given to him? I mean what exactly did he do to warrant such a position?
Click to expand...


...George Costanza got Cashman the job.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top