Przybilla for Redick Yes or N0?

[Blaze01]

Discussion of a Przybilla for Redick swap from the Orlando Sentinel...

http://blogs.orlandosentinel.com/sports_magic/2010/12/can-magic-afford-to-trade-j-j-redick.html

Would you do it?

Redick is a good shooter who has really seem to come on this year. Isn't that what this team needs good, young shooters? Whether Roy stays or not I think he would be a nice young piece to add to the team.

http://www.realgm.com/src_playerfile/666/jj_redick/

I doubt Rudy is coming back once his contract expires and it allows POR to deal him....I also doubt POR re-signs Joel in the offseason...

Not an ideal trade, but I would do it. I honestly don't realistically see Przybilla fetching a better return than this.....

 

[ucatchtrout]

No thank you. Not giving up a quality big for a backup SG

 

[MIXUM]

NO WAY!!!!!

signed hcp

 

[hasoos]

No thank you. Not giving up a quality big for a backup SG

A quality backup big who will only be here until end of year.

 

[RR7]

I really like JJ Redick. I just don't see how that is a good roster fit for us currently.

 

[Nikolokolus]

Sure why not. I'd probably wait to see if I could get more, but Joel looks like the two torn patellar tendons may have really taken something out of him. If this move was done I presume there would be a follow-up move to get some kind of forward-center. Maybe a Rudy for Anthony Randolph swap could be done?

 

[hasoos]

If this happens another SG has to be shipped.

 

[MIXUM]

if we are trading camby to bobcats.... no way we trade joel

 

[andalusian]

Might have to do that - opening the door to a Rudy trade.

 

[LittleAlex]

No thanks.

I like JJ Redick but Portland needs another wing player like they need another injury prone center.

 

[e_blazer]

I couldn't vote since there isn't a "HELL NO" button.

 

[RoyToy]

if we are trading camby to bobcats.... no way we trade joel

This is Joel's last year on his contract and I don't think Cho will be in favor of bringing back a guy of Joel's age with his knee injuries.

Plus, we still have Oden!!!

 

[Ed O]

Fuck no.

Ed O.

 

[STOMP]

NO WAY!!!!!

signed hcp

obsessed much?

I couldn't vote since there isn't a "HELL NO" button.

my first thought too, but I went ahead and settled for a no vote

STOMP

 

[Minstrel]

I couldn't vote since there isn't a "HELL NO" button.

Fuck no.

my first thought too, but I went ahead and settled for a no vote

Something along those lines.

 

[Carden]

That is a stupid trade. What do we benefit? We do not need anymore 2 guards.

 

[hasoos]

That is a stupid trade. What do we benefit? We do not need anymore 2 guards.

That depends on what other deals you have on the table. You will notice that when Orlando made deals the other day, they made 2, not 1 to get to where they wanted. If we could pull in Reddick but it allowed us to do something else to strengthen the team, it could work out.

 

[Nikolokolus]

That depends on what other deals you have on the table. You will notice that when Orlando made deals the other day, they made 2, not 1 to get to where they wanted. If we could pull in Reddick but it allowed us to do something else to strengthen the team, it could work out.

Pretty much my train of thought. I hate the notion of Pryzbilla straight up for Reddick, but if say Rudy (or whomever) was moved immediately afterward for a big man, then it's fine.

 

[Mediocre Man]

Not a good move IMO.


Not that it is uneven, and precious Prima Royya would get a shooter, but it's not the best value for Joel

 

[Fez Hammersticks]

This seems like merely an idea by their beatwriter.

 

[oldmangrouch]

But...but...but...it would make Roy happy!

(for the record, I am in the "hell no!" camp)

 

[BrianFromWA]

I like Redick a lot, and I think he's half-a-step away from being a Kyle Korver/Mike Miller/James Jones-level lights-out 3pt bomber. He's very, very efficient and doesn't make a ton of mistakes...

Getting talented players is not a bad thing. Redick qualifies. He's fairly one-dimensional, but he's quite useful. I don't love giving him up for Joel straight-up, but I'm not going to barf if it happens.

 

[Blazinaway]

I like Redick a lot, and I think he's half-a-step away from being a Kyle Korver/Mike Miller/James Jones-level lights-out 3pt bomber. He's very, very efficient and doesn't make a ton of mistakes...

Getting talented players is not a bad thing. Redick qualifies. He's fairly one-dimensional, but he's quite useful. I don't love giving him up for Joel straight-up, but I'm not going to barf if it happens.

I like him as well, especially for acquiring a good asset to keep or even trade again - however is his salary high or reasonable? or should you try to trade przy for brandon bass?

 

[bodyman5001]

No way.