Rate My Signature Thread (3 Viewers)

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Register Log in

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 4 (members: 0, guests: 4)
<div class="quote_poster">Carter Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">I actually think it looks really good. It looks like a sig Trench would make. 9.5/10</div>

ouch. lol. I give it a 5/10. No real consistency with anything. Colors are all over the place, effects are very random. Not feeling the sig. Keep working at it.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Trench Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">ouch. lol. I give it a 5/10. No real consistency with anything. Colors are all over the place, effects are very random. Not feeling the sig. Keep working at it.</div>

Seriosly? I didnt think it was that bad... How are the effects random?
 
Dwight - I love it. I like the watery effects. 9/10

Rate:
DurantSig.jpg
 
Dime for sure. Love the scrappy look.

Rate this, my second sig in PaintShopPro (kinda threw stuff together, experimented with different tools):

iggyzf0.png
 
<div class="quote_poster">Epidemik Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Dime for sure. Love the scrappy look.

Rate this, my second sig in PaintShopPro (kinda threw stuff together, experimented with different tools):

iggyzf0.png
</div>

Eh, im not feeling it at all, 5/10 6/10 cause its not photoshop and cuz im new too. Render isnt that good, the big white splots are kinda random and not that good, the render is kind of bright, and the cutting on some parts isnt very good.Also, wahts up with the small bits of blue around the head and arm? But it is an improvement from the first IMO, keep working at it.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">

Seriosly? I didnt think it was that bad... How are the effects random?

billups.jpg


billupslght.jpg
</div>

look at it carefully. There are so many colors and the saturation in the background is terrible. The sigs have to have some kind of FLOW to it. The background has to fit the render. Yours looks as if you just put a photo of Billups on top of a random made background rather than place the background around the render... MAKE SENSE??? Its hard to explain, but your sig doesnt have any type of flow and the background really doesnt match the render too well. The Render itself it not blended in the background at all, and the pistons logo doesn't look like it really fits. The left side looks like blood on a wall, the right side looks like some kind of lighting. then you have a faded out Billups render that does not really look like it fits.

Im not trying to take anything away from your efforts, but I've been on boards with very "GOOD" designers who's critques are very harsh. You rarely see a 10/10 period. Unfortunately that site went down.

Keep practicing, but I will CALL is as I see it.

I suggest you find more GFX forums and get them C+C for you. Im sure they'll say the same things I just did.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Eh, im not feeling it at all, 5/10 6/10 cause its not photoshop and cuz im new too. Render isnt that good, the big white splots are kinda random and not that good, the render is kind of bright, and the cutting on some parts isnt very good.Also, wahts up with the small bits of blue around the head and arm? But it is an improvement from the first IMO, keep working at it.</div>

The white blotches weren't my doing, I used a premade background from the link NTC had. The blue parts are apart of the faded sixers logo. But yeah, I'll keep working at it.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Trench Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">look at it carefully. There are so many colors and the saturation in the background is terrible. The sigs have to have some kind of FLOW to it. The background has to fit the render. Yours looks as if you just put a photo of Billups on top of a random made background rather than place the background around the render... MAKE SENSE??? Its hard to explain, but your sig doesnt have any type of flow and the background really doesnt match the render too well. The Render itself it not blended in the background at all, and the pistons logo doesn't look like it really fits. The left side looks like blood on a wall, the right side looks like some kind of lighting. then you have a faded out Billups render that does not really look like it fits.

Im not trying to take anything away from your efforts, but I've been on boards with very "GOOD" designers who's critques are very harsh. You rarely see a 10/10 period. Unfortunately that site went down.

Keep practicing, but I will CALL is as I see it.

I suggest you find more GFX forums and get them C+C for you. Im sure they'll say the same things I just did.</div>
Ok, thanks, so set the background around the render, to make it flow, i got it. Any more tips or anything?

<div class="quote_poster">Epidemik Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">The white blotches weren't my doing, I used a premade background from the link NTC had. The blue parts are apart of the faded sixers logo. But yeah, I'll keep working at it.</div>

Then you should manipulate the premade, to make it fit it better. And it just doesnt look like the blue fits, maybe leave that part out next time?
 
9.5/10 I like pretty much everything. The font could be more creative though.



SeanLivingstonSig3.jpg
 
8/10 Clean sig overall, just the picture quality is a bit blurry.
 
6/10 for Roy sig. Very blurry render. Not feeling the bg much.
7/10 for the CP sig. Still kinda blurry. Oversaturated too.
7/10 for the Harrington sig. Again Blurry.

I just made this today.
loveandbasketball-1.jpg


Rate.

This was the original stock. hehe. He was white at first! Had to make him look darker like me!! LOL

130611018_3236ebe6b3_b.jpg
 
I like it. Good job with the darker skin. Not so sure what's going on with the transparent pattern though. Good photo manip.

VCartersignature2.jpg


Diesel.jpg


ReggieBush.jpg
 
^ They all need more. Very little effects and minimal text. All about a 6/10

Rate:

1rootsiggrd9.jpg
 
9/10 for the carter one. The simplicity os perfect for the sig. 6/10 for the rest. I agree, they need more.
 
Rate:

The_Roots_by_N4S_by_BBallCentral_GF.jpg


Trench, concept and idea are good but not fully executed. The pic is really choppy and the ball is somewhat oval. Also think the text could be replaced somewhere in the sig.
 
<div class="quote_poster">N4S Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Rate:

The_Roots_by_N4S_by_BBallCentral_GF.jpg


Trench, concept and idea are good but not fully executed. The pic is really choppy and the ball is somewhat oval. Also think the text could be replaced somewhere in the sig.</div>
9/10
I like the effects, what did you do to the layer with those lines? Too bad its too big for the forum.

Check this, ive been in a slump and cant come up with anything real good, but heres my latest: C+C
roadtochamp.jpg

The background is a photomanip i did, of a road, and if you look closely, the Larry O'Brien(Sp?) Trophy is at the end.(Get it, road to championship?)
 
<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">9/10
I like the effects, what did you do to the layer with those lines? Too bad its too big for the forum.

Check this, ive been in a slump and cant come up with anything real good, but heres my latest: C+C
roadtochamp.jpg

The background is a photomanip i did, of a road, and if you look closely, the Larry O'Brien(Sp?) Trophy is at the end.(Get it, road to championship?)</div>

They look like they are about to suck...
 
<div class="quote_poster">Carter Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">They look like they are about to suck...</div>

What?
 
<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">What?</div>

Wtf? I think it's againt guidlines to post it. So PM me if you want to know.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Carter Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Wtf? I think it's againt guidlines to post it. So PM me if you want to know.</div>

Oh, lol. I dont know, I couldnt find ANY good pictures of Yao, and the tmac one was of him dunking.See?
Adidastmac.jpg
 
<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Oh, lol. I dont know, I couldnt find ANY good pictures of Yao, and the tmac one was of him dunking.See?
Adidastmac.jpg
</div>



Cool T-Mac pic.

I don't like the Yao pic. Doesn't look that good.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Quote:</div><div class="quote_post">
The_Roots_by_N4S_by_BBallCentral_GF.jpg
</div>

I like some of your other work better. This one has that same wavy line pattern you've been using a lot in the others. The text at the bottom is kind of boring to me with the block backdrop. The image is too light for my taste and it could use a bit more contrast. Also the pattern doesn't look that good going over the image as it is IMO. 7/10


<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">
Check this, ive been in a slump and cant come up with anything real good, but heres my latest: C+C
roadtochamp.jpg

The background is a photomanip i did, of a road, and if you look closely, the Larry O'Brien(Sp?) Trophy is at the end.(Get it, road to championship?)</div>

Yao render looks too saturated. If you're going to use two images make sure they have similar saturations at least. I wouldnt have noticed the O'brien trophy if you hadn't told me and it's impossible to tell that it's at the top of a road. Good concept and idea but it could be executed a lot better. Also I don't really feel those blurs coming off of the back of their heads. 6/10







Kobesig2.jpg
 
<div class="quote_poster">Mercury Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Cool T-Mac pic.

I don't like the Yao pic. Doesn't look that good.</div>
I know, i couldnt find any good pics.
<div class="quote_poster">Windmill360? Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Yao render looks too saturated. If you're going to use two images make sure they have similar saturations at least. I wouldnt have noticed the O'brien trophy if you hadn't told me and it's impossible to tell that it's at the top of a road. Good concept and idea but it could be executed a lot better. Also I don't really feel those blurs coming off of the back of their heads. 6/10</div>

Ok, thanks for all the comment, that helps me alot.

This any better?
roadtochamp-1.jpg


I cant think of any way to "execute" the idea better. If i make it bigger, then it wont fit.
 
I like it, just not the photo of McGrady. Good choice on the text in my opinion. Yao also seems a bit blurry. 7/10

Windmill - Kobe sig - 9/10

Rate my new one below.
 
My teacher needed a pic resized and made bigger to the full length that could fit on a paper as much as possible. I'll try to get the link to the picture but let me know if any of you could make it bigger without getting it blurry. I could get some extra-credit points. Thanks!
 
<div class="quote_poster">N4S Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">^ Yao pic is real choppy. 5/10

Rate:
pharrellzk2.jpg
</div>

I couldnt find any yao pics in your galleries/links.

9/10, real clean. How do you make those lines like this and the roots one?

C+C
channing.jpg
 
I'm always gettin' skipped it seems. lol

Anyway that Channing one is a bit blurry, but the background is pretty nice. 7/10.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top