Rate My Signature Thread

[Hunter]

Since the original Rate My Signature thread was being abused by users posting signatures with other site's logos on them as an attempt to get users to go to that site, we have decided to delete the old one and start a new one.

Here is a friendly reminder of the rules for this thread:

1. No posting of signatures with other sites logos on them(It is considered spam according to our guidelines).
2. Please rate the person's signature above you with a rating (1-10)
3. If you get a low rating, don't take it personally as everyone has different tastes.
4. Our signature guidelines for graphics allow a user to have one graphic with a maximum size of 468x100 pixels. If you are found having graphics that exceed that limit, your's will be deleted and your graphics priveledges revoked.

Thanks!

 

[MiamiBalla12]

Hunter doesn't have one for me to rate so any ratings on mine by CK.

 

[stkf]

8/10 kinda plain by its alright.

http://i21.photobucket.com/albums/b299/nba...ures/alston.png

 

[Buckets]

MiamiBalla12: 6/10
STKF: 5.5/10, not feeling the text or colors on this one.

 

[Bobcats]

Not a big fan of the card graphics. 6/10.

 

[TnNeG]

Bobcats: Text needs work, b/g is too blue, not really liking the effect on the player. 6/10

 

[Buckets]

Bobcats: 6/10
TNG: 8/10

 

[bbwTwinTowers]

Buckets- way too plain, bad text, 4/10

Any on mine by STKF

 

[N4S]

I like it alot, throwback. 9/10

Rate:

 

[Ming637]

N4sheed: Can't see the 'West' text, but other than that, it's good. 9.5/10

Rate:

EDIT: Where can I get nice borders?

 

[Miami Flash City]

Ming637: TO sig 8/10
MJ sig 8.5/10
Has been rated before but still looking for some different opinions so..ne rates on mine?

 

[Buckets]

Ming637:
Terrell: 7/10, Make the Logo less visible and place the text better.
Jordan: 7/10, Same thing.

Truth: 7.5/10.

 

[B.e.]

Don't like the BG its to pinkish, text is used a lot by you...6/10

 

[bbwTwinTowers]

OOOOO, very nice sig, 9.5/10. Nive avy too

Any more comments on mine.

 

[stkf]

i love it.. whoever made it must be a sig expert.

Rate:

 

[TnNeG]

B-22: that's a sick sig. good job who ever made that. 9/10
STKF: logo is too visible... not really sure what to say else. 7.5/10 I think you gotta still work on that one

 

[Buckets]

B-22: Dime. No complaints.
STKF: 7.5/10, not liking it for some reason just dont know why.
TNG: 8/10.

New Set For Me.

 

[B.e.]

I like this one......8.5/10 but I think you should try some different things as a designer....by the way everybody Ed! made my sig

 

[stkf]

<div class="quote_poster">Quoting B-22:</div><div class="quote_post">I like this one......8.5/10 but I think you should try some different things as a designer....by the way everybody Ed! made my sig</div>


Ed! is good @ sigs

Rate My Favorite Sig!

 

[Buckets]

STKF: 8.5/10. Not liking text and bg color isnt right.

 

[bbwTwinTowers]

Buckets: I'm likeing ot 8/10

How about mine I got from another board

 

[buzzer555]

B-22: 9.5/10 ~ Love this sig, I think it's flawless.
STKF: 7/10 ~ Not feeling the colour and choice of text. the bg seems empty to me and i think the boykins pic is a little too saturated.
Buckets: 9/10 ~ I really like this sig, simple and clean. The colours belend real well.
TwinTowers: 8.5/10 ~ change some fo the fonts and make the Hill pic less saturated and it will be sweet. the bg is really nice.

 

[stkf]

vick... nice... 8/10

and

 

[N4S]

Colors clash very much so in this one. Just by looking at it, it looks as if its a Hornets sig but than it's a nuggets player. Which kills it. 7/10

 

[stkf]

<div class="quote_poster">Quoting N4S:</div><div class="quote_post">

Colors clash very much so in this one. Just by looking at it, it looks as if its a Hornets sig but than it's a nuggets player. Which kills it. 7/10</div>


what bout that second one.

 

[.cabangbang]

How is this one?

 

[shankyoass]

^ 6/10. A little too messy for my taste.

 

[Skiptomylue11]

I actually like Twin Tower's Grant Hill. It seems a tad away from being awesome, but the message still gets through. 8.5/10

Ming637's Terrel Owens: 8.5/10
B-22's Jordan: 8/10
jtam's random girl: 6.5/10 no basketball in the picture
J-Rich23 - 7/10 the text blends in with the sig a bit too much

Rate:Rate:Rate:

 

[N4S]

<div class="quote_poster">Quoting STKF:</div><div class="quote_post">what bout that second one.</div>

Look at the colors on his jersey. They are no where near the bg.

Soft Parade or TNG aka Nick, aka Elmo, any on this?

 

[buzzer555]

^ Everything is great but I think that the font is holding it back. 9.5/10