Rate My Signature Thread

[Notorious]

<div class="quote_poster">Trench Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">468 by 100 are the limits.</div>

But you can do smaller ones, right?

 

[N4S]

<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Is this any better?

BTW, Trench, whats the limits on the size of a Sig here at JBB?</div>

Your best!

 

[bbwtrench]

<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">But you can do smaller ones, right?</div>

Yes. you can use smaller ones.

 

[Notorious]

<div class="quote_poster">N4S Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Your best!</div>

Serious? Dang, everybody has so different opinions. Lol.

C&C:

The pic was sepia/black and white(had no color) so it was kinda hard to work with, but wutever.

 

[Glen Infante]

I'd scoot Chris more towards the middle if you're going to leave out all that space.

 

[Windmill360?]

<div class="quote_poster">Infante Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">I'd scoot Chris more towards the middle if you're going to leave out all that space.</div>

I think it needs more lighting effects on the CP one. It's too dark for me.

The DW one could have a better background.

Edit:

 

[Glen Infante]

Amare sig is nice. 8's on that. Not feelin the nuggets sig. The text just ruined it imo. 5. Your Nowitzki sig is ballin' though. That's an 8 as well.

 

[bbwtrench]

Amare is definately a good sig. 8/10. Im with Infante, that text with the stroke is just ugly in the Nuggets sig. 4/10 not feeling the outer glow around the renders either.

 

[Windmill360?]

Great manip. I like the colors and the effects that are going on in the lower half. Not really feeling the debris though. Sadly, there aren't enough signatures of coaches

I want to make an Avery one now.

 

[Glen Infante]

That LeBron sig is impressive. Very sleek. I'm diggin' that very much.

I could live without the text up top, but other then that it's very good. 9.

 

[bbwtrench]

8/10 on the Lebron sig. I dont like the text on top and the saturation on h is face is a little too high. Lower it a bit, and bam. I'd like it more. haha

 

[Windmill360?]

 

[bbwSwish]

You're getting very good man. I'm in love with your last two sigs.

 

[Notorious]

I dont know, for some reason i dont like your latest style. I think i like blended renders more, thats just me tho. I like on the Tmac sig where it says Kobe, Lebron, Wade in the background, nice.

I made this manip, playing around with certain stuff, C&C

Original:
http://i140.photobucket.com/albums/r3/cpau...lls022516_1.jpg

Manip:

 

[Glen Infante]

Not feelin this one too much bruh. 4.

 

[Windmill360?]

Notorious: It looks very muddy. You could have chosen a more appealing color. I don't like the cube effect around CB's head. Overall very murky and hard to read (not the text just the image).

 

[N4S]

Pretty decent. Needs some more text and coloring could be a bit better.

Rate: (my grundy side of things)

 

[Windmill360?]

<div class="quote_poster">N4S Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Pretty decent. Needs some more text and coloring could be a bit better.

Rate: (my grundy side of things)

</div>

Nice look. Good color choice and the image fits well too. I just think that the image could be more visible and not as light.

 

[Notorious]

<div class="quote_poster">Windmill360? Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Nice look. Good color choice and the image fits well too. I just think that the image could be more visible and not as light.

</div>

Meh. I think you should blend your renders. I think thats the reason im not liking some of your sigs. Looks like you did the sig, then just took a render and stuck it on top. I guess thats just my opinion, so it doesnt matter much, but i like blended ones, it helps it flow.

 

[bbwtrench]

<div class="quote_poster">Windmill360? Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Notorious: It looks very muddy. You could have chosen a more appealing color. I don't like the cube effect around CB's head. Overall very murky and hard to read (not the text just the image).

</div>

Im usually not into too much color, but it fits the sig well here. I like it alot. 9/10. I think you could have had a little more lighting effects though.

 

[N4S]

 

[Notorious]

<div class="quote_poster">N4S Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">

</div>

Nice, i like all the little patterns and stuff at the left. Only problem is i hurt my neck looking at it for awhile, lol.

C&C:I tried to make it more simple like you told me N4S

BTW, it has a border, but its white, and the bg here is white, so it doesnt show well.

 

[NTC]

Dont like what you've done with the text on that one.

 

[bbwtrench]

Text is ugly and the lighting is too bright. 6/10 for Smith.

 

[Notorious]

What can i do to fix the text problem? Im taking N4S's advice and making V2's of my sigs to make myself a better designer. C&C:

 

[Midnight Green]

<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">What can i do to fix the text problem? Im taking N4S's advice and making V2's of my sigs to make myself a better designer. C&C:

</div>

The right side of the sig is hot, but the left side needs some work I'd give it a 7-10.

 

[Notorious]

<div class="quote_poster">Blur Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">The right side of the sig is hot, but the left side needs some work I'd give it a 7-10.</div>

Like i said above, what do you think i could do to make it better, on the left side.

 

[N4S]

Rate:

 

[Midnight Green]

<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Like i said above, what do you think i could do to make it better, on the left side.</div>I'm not really sure but make Wade stand out more some how, he gets too lost in the BG in the current version with all the effects around him.

 

[Windmill360?]

Notorious:

WillSmith - picture is alright. you just went too bright with the contrast/saturation. As for the text, I have a tendency to read it as "swmiiltlth" instead of "will smith". maybe you can rearange it somehow.

Dwade - I don't like the "spilt milk" blotches at all. It as if you added them in just for the heck of it. Also wade's head looks mishapen at the top? The text is fine though.

N4S:

It's great but it still looks similar to your other work. 8/10