Rate My Signature Thread

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Register Log in
<div class="quote_poster">Windmill360? Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Notorious:

WillSmith - picture is alright. you just went too bright with the contrast/saturation. As for the text, I have a tendency to read it as "swmiiltlth" instead of "will smith". maybe you can rearange it somehow.

Dwade - I don't like the "spilt milk" blotches at all. It as if you added them in just for the heck of it. Also wade's head looks mishapen at the top? The text is fine though.

N4S:

It's great but it still looks similar to your other work. 8/10</div>
Oops, i forgot to post the other versions. Here:
dwyanewade2.jpg


V2(With rest of hat)
dwyanewade2v2.jpg


V3(Without Splatter stock)
dwyanewade2v3.jpg


V4(Different Render, Splatter)
dwyanewade2v4.jpg


V5(Different Render, No Splatter)
dwyanewade2v5.jpg
 
Tried something new again:
kobecontest-1.jpg


EDIT:Am i allowed to wear this? Its a lil bit taller then the max here.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Tried something new again:


EDIT:Am i allowed to wear this? Its a lil bit taller then the max here.</div>

Haha...you answered your own question.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Blur Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Haha...you answered your own question.</div>

No i didnt. There might be exceptions allowed. Its only 10 pixels larger.

C&C:
LTContest.jpg
 
<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">No i didnt. There might be exceptions allowed. Its only 10 pixels larger.
</div>

There isn't...
 
<div class="quote_poster">Blur Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">There isn't...</div>

Ok, why cant you just rate my sigs? God...
 
That L.T sig is very nice, its simple yet effective.

7.5 / 10
 
<div class="quote_poster">Trench Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">No exceptions. 100px is max height.</div>

Ok. Ive gotten used to 110 now that im at other sites also. Ill just have to remember 100 for here. I got it.
 
Notorious
Kobe Sig: I like how you broke the Laker-mold of Purple and Gold in this sig. I like the stroked effect on the Kobe render, but my only thing is that the background pictures of him look repetitive at such high opacities. The text looks a bit out of place, as well. Overall, a solid 8/10.

Paul Sig: Reminds me of designs by someone I know. Very dramatic, but the text again looks a bit out of place and draws away from the overall image. I would've gone with something a bit more Gothic for the text and left the picture to fill in the rest of the details. But I love the simplicity (didn't overdo any brushing). The text and border take away from the whole thing, but it's a great sig (roll with the simplicity). 8.5/10, could easily be a dime, though.

LT Sig: I like this one, you did well with the text. Though, to be honest, I would've picked a different picture of LT and lowered the opacity of the effect behind him. It's difficult to do football sigs because you can't capture the entire emotion of one given picture, but you did good with this one, for sure. If that's a lens flare in the middle-area, try slapping a darker layer over it, because it draws attention where there shouldn't be attention drawn (unless I am blind). And add a border! 8.5/10.

Blur
Wade Sig: I love the text, the render/main pic is what gets me, I wish you went with something more. . . action packed. Good sig though, but the size as well. . I think it would look a lot cleaner had you gone smaller, but to each his own. 8.5/10

NTC
Webber Sig: I don't really like the BG to be honest, seems too brushed up (for my taste), but the text work is great. The main pic looks like the top layer, which, maybe add another and try a different effect. Nice use of the border, some sigs can't pull off that big of a stroke, this one does. 8/10.

Trench
Phil Jackson Sig: This is pretty cool, I like how you fit the background into the image and not the other way around. I just think it might be over done in some areas (by his index finger, behind his head), other than that it's a real creative touch to it. 9.5/10.

Right-O. . the last time I put a sig up was a while ago. . and I can only remember N4S (back when he was Need4Sheed) makin' sigs of the lot of us in this thread. But, I have the week off and thought I'd try my luck at it again. I'd like to think simplicity is my M.O., so keep that in mind
lol.gif
. Anyways, enough babbling, I'll be sure to post some of my older ones up here, to get re-rated.

This is Noel Gallagher, of Oasis, great song writer, and total bad-ass. Click the thumbnail, por favor.
 
Wow. I wish people would rate all sigs like that. Nice rating. BTW, theres borders on both the Kobe and Tomlinson, there just white. Thats cause at all the other forums im on the skin is dark/black.

Your sig is pretty nice. Like you said, its really simple, but in this case it looks pretty good. It needs something more. Its good, just nothing "pops" and makes it look extra special.
 
Man, I thought this sig by Windmill was the hottest thing I had seen in a while ... you guys rate it.
 
Pakman: Love that sig. Don't know, but there is something that I really like about it. 9.5/10

Notorious: Nice sig. I like the background and the colors, but some of the text is really hard to read. 8/10
 
<div class="quote_poster">Carter Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Pakman: Love that sig. Don't know, but there is something that I really like about it. 9.5/10

Notorious: Nice sig. I like the background and the colors, but some of the text is really hard to read. 8/10</div>

Yeah, the chargers text is supposed to be hard to read, and the eyes on the prize one i accidentally moved it too far into the light. Ill move it when i get the chance.
 
<div class="quote_poster">N4S Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Why would you make it hard to read? pointless.</div>

Well, it was supposed to be able to see chargers, but not make it like stand out too much. Not exactly pointless, like those people who put tiny unreadable text/lyrics to fill up space.
 
8/10 for the C-Paul sig. I'm feelin it, I like what you did the render. Text looks pretty good, but I think there are font choices that would better suit the dark theme of that sig.

What about my Grant Hill sig? It didn't even start out as a sig at first, just messing around with stuff but I like it. The hardest part was the text because I wanted to put "still kickin" somewhere in the sig but it was hard to fit it in there:
ghillsig.jpg
 
<div class="quote_poster">N4S Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">^ Very busy. Tone the bg down a bit. 5/10

Rate:
1coreyyj8.jpg
</div>

I know, it was a pain to look at, but I guess after a while I just figured 'Ah whatever'... I do agree that it is very busy though.

Maggette sig: 7.5/10

Another good piece. I don't like the orange so much though, I think a blue or red Clippers color would fit it better.
 
N4S: Great sig. I'm fine with the color. Render could be a little more clear. 8.5/10

Notorious: Not feeling that style at all. The background is just a mess and it was a bad choice in coloring too. Way to complicated on the bottom left area. Also Kanye seems to be floating in the middle of the picture. There is nothing to tie everything together. Every part seems like it's own i.e. the text, render and background. The background kind of separates everything too. 4/10
 
<div class="quote_poster">Windmill360? Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">N4S: Great sig. I'm fine with the color. Render could be a little more clear. 8.5/10

Notorious: Not feeling that style at all. The background is just a mess and it was a bad choice in coloring too. Way to complicated on the bottom left area. Also Kanye seems to be floating in the middle of the picture. There is nothing to tie everything together. Every part seems like it's own i.e. the text, render and background. The background kind of separates everything too. 4/10</div>

It was supposed to be abstract.

0/10 for yours, its a fish
laugh.gif


What do you guys think of this, i was just playing around with it:
dwyanewademj.png
 
Stick to what you were doing before, the colors on that is ugly, and the BG isn't good.

Edit: What the hell Notorious, you swithced the sig on me, it was a Kanye one first. That MJ Dwyane sig is something serious though. 10
 
notorious, 10/10. best sig i've seen on here in awhile. on the same hand, im no sig pro, so maybe theres mistakes, but what do i know? haha. i love it either way.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">It was supposed to be abstract.

0/10 for yours, its a fish
laugh.gif


What do you guys think of this, i was just playing around with it:
dwyanewademj.png
</div>

6.5/10 I like the concept and idea, but the background and colors just don't fit.
 
Would be a better Mike sig or Dwane sig. Both of them together looks kinda weird.

Some of these dudes are gassed up on corny graphics, that they don't see that your background is fine the way it is.

I like the sig, I'd just pick one of the two and stick with it. 8.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)

Featured content

Back
Top