Right now, it's not even close with Jeff Green and OJ Mayo vs Oden. Jeff Green is a 6'9" SF that does EVERYTHING from the SF spot and is versatile enough to slide down to the 4. When it's all said and done, he could end up being the 2nd best player out of the draft after Durant. As much of a douche OJ Mayo is, he still plays hard and wants to win. As a rookie he's nearly averaging 19 points a game, and is on the verge of becoming a 25+ PPG guy that can take over games. Rudy Gay is the only one that Oden is close with at this point IMO. They're both pretty good players that do their thing, but I gave the edge to Rudy Gay who has proven he can stay healthy throughout college & the NBA unlike Oden. After seeing the first generation youngsters that came into the NBA early like T-Mac & KG prematurely being worn down, it has to make you believe that someone like Oden that has shown some injuries issues early on might have them return earlier in his career.
You seem to be focused primarily on scoring. Mayo is averaging 18.4 PPG, which is nice for a rookie, but his PER is only 14.1 - below average NBA player.
If Jeff Green "does it all" why is his PER only 13.4? Nicolas Batum, as a 19/20 year old rookie has a 13.0 PER in spite of averaging over 11 PPG less than Green. That's the definition of a do it all player - a guy who fills up a stat sheet in ways other than scoring - and Batum is also a great defender. Forget Oden over Green, if the draft was today, I'd take Batum over Green. He's 3 years younger, plays better defense, and has a lot more "upside".
WRT Oden, you are focusing too much on scoring. Oden's scoring will come, but he already provides GREAT rebounding and tough interior defense. Defense and rebounding win championships - and that's why GMs favor bigs over wing players that have the potential to average 20 - 25 PPG. Oden, as a rookie coming off microfracture knee surgery currently has a TRB% (total rebound percentage) of 20.2%. That puts him among the league leaders as a rookie recovering from a major injury. By comparison, a healthy Dwight Howard ha a TRB% of 17.3% as a rookie and has a career TRB% of 20.5%.
And, of course, Oden has barely scratched the surface of what he will become. Never before has a rookie entered the league after sitting out a year to recover from microfracture knee surgery. Even experienced players like Amare and Zach Randolph took almost two years to retrurn to their pre-surgery production level and those guys had the benefit of multiple years of NBA experience to fall back on.
Oden is JUST starting to get back some of the athleticism he lost - and he still lhas a PER of 18.1 and a TRB% of 20.2%. Even if he never averages over 15 PPG, he will have a bigger impact on his team's won-loss record that Durant and Mayo. Remember, Bill Russel wasn't a great scorer, but he has 10 rings. Again, defense and rebounding win
NBA titles, which are MUCH more important than individual scoring titles. Durant may win several of the latter, but my money is on Oden to win more of the former.
BNM