THN top 50 players the worst list I've ever seen in any sporting rankings

[dumpstralmannow]

They must have been drunk out of their minds. For starters, ranking any goalie ahead of Hank is stupid. Stating he hasn't had a dominant playoff run is moronic. He's had tons of dominant playoff games. He's pretty much been dominant every year in the playoffs. His team never scores for him. He's had more dominant playoff games than Quick who was ranked 11 spots ahead of him. Lundqvist who had a save % under .925 in one game vs. Boston a series loss. Quick on the other hand had save % of .886, .893 and .765 in a series loss to Chicago. Yet, both had the same save % for the playoffs because LA played St. Louis and San Jose who can't score for jack in the playoffs and never have been able to. It looks like a Kings fan made up the list because the ranked Jeff Carter 18 which is a disgrace. I wouldn't put him in the top 100. He is lazy, is a travesty defensively and his passing went to complete crap as he had 7 assists in 48 games last season.

That list was so bad THN should be sued for incompetence.

 

[Puckmeat]

What's the link? I'm a little tipsy, and I can't seem to find it.

 

[speeds]

They'd rather make an imperfect list people will pay attention to/rail about than a good one people will read, agree with, and ultimately forget about.

 

[dumpstralmannow]

I have a subscription to the magazine so I read the list.

 

[gonnabluffanyway]

Just too many closed minded writers and sports fans who will not give a player credit for his acheivements, success, and consistency without a ring. Something that, by the way, is a team award. MAF has one and he sucks. Any of these experts who would not have taken Dan Marino as their FFL QB? (thats right, no ring)

 

[Disturbed]

I got my THN Yearbook yesterday and read thru it.....Hank is like #24. Nash is not even in the top 50. There are some pretty surprising names on the list.....Couture #28.....Eberle #34.....Tavares #5.....I love Taveres but 5?.....Bergeron #9.....Doughty #10

Seriously who puts this list together.

I hate the Pens but even Malkin is #7. Malkin is absolutely one of the 3-4 best players in the NHL

 

[dumpstralmannow]

Eberle was just awful last year. I had him in fantasy. He was pathetic. Nash was 10 times better. Nash scored tons of huge goals in the third period last year. He dominated games in the third period. Doughty was pathetic last year. He stunk. I had him in fantasy and I actually dropped him. That list was clearly made up by a Rangers hater. Putting Quick 13 and Carter 18 clearly showed me the list was a joke. Quick was actually bad in the regular season. Looks like to me the list was made up by a Kings fan.