The Vince debate has long since become theological for some...with articles of faith, high priest, original sin, and demons, etc.
It's tiresome.
He has played well for the Nets since being acquired. He's had at least three good regular seasons, and two good playoffs. In the 27 playoff games he has played as a Net, Carter has averaged: 26.0 points, 7.1 rebounds and 5.4 assists. He's gone to the foul line almost nine times a game in those 27 games. His big problem has been a drop off in three point shooting in the playoffs, hitting only 31 per cent. Twice, the Nets went to the second round with him.
Last year, his ankle injury was worse than the one RJ sustained two years ago...so bad in fact that his surgery required him to stay off the court for four months. Yet he missed only six games, five immediately afterwards and one late in the season, on the orders of Tim Walsh. In the last five years, Carter has missed 23 games, an average of four and half games a year. In fact, only one NBA superstar has missed as few games--Kevin Garnett.
Carter is most effective in an offense with a scoring big man. No Carter, no field goal percentage title for Mikki Moore. This will be in an interesting year watching him play with the young bigs.