Rumor What's going on in Portland? (2 Viewers)

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Users who are viewing this thread

Slave labor is literally what prison labor is. Read the 13th amendment:

Section 1. Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.”

I underlined the part that matters here.

So yes, slaves. People, even criminals, are humans, and should not be subject to unpaid labor. This is just my opinion; the city could pay to have the litter cleaned up but they don’t.
Actually prisoners volunteer to become trustees and work outside during the day...get some fresh air and exercise...I think it's a false equivalency calling them slaves..they also get free ddental and medical and gym membership....Bikers used to brag about wintering in jail and getting sober and new tats pumping iron and networking, all the free medical shit and then get out in the summer and ride. Any prisoner who doesn't want to work in a trustee program or kitchen or library, etc doesn't have to as far as I know..
 
Actually prisoners volunteer to become trustees and work outside during the day...get some fresh air and exercise...I think it's a false equivalency calling them slaves..they also get free ddental and medical and gym membership....Bikers used to brag about wintering in jail and getting sober and new tats pumping iron and networking, all the free medical shit and then get out in the summer and ride. Any prisoner who doesn't want to work in a trustee program or kitchen or library, etc doesn't have to as far as I know..
upload_2024-5-14_13-26-23.jpeg

Sorry--I don't actually have a comment on the topic one way or the other; just love it when a Shawshank reference is relevant.
 
I think it's a false equivalency calling them slaves.

I mean, I didn’t write the 13th amendment but they did explicitly say slavery was legal if the slave is a prisoner. I don’t know how false the equivalency can be if it’s in the text itself.

Free services are not income; at best it’s a company town/company scrip situation, and I don’t think that should be allowed either.

My best friend spent 18 months in the pen when he was 19. He didn’t really like to talk about the time and he came out really messed up by the experience; maybe he didn’t earn a spot with the trustees and his time was just not as cozy.
 
I mean, I didn’t write the 13th amendment but they did explicitly say slavery was legal if the slave is a prisoner. I don’t know how false the equivalency can be if it’s in the text itself.

Free services are not income; at best it’s a company town/company scrip situation, and I don’t think that should be allowed either.

My best friend spent 18 months in the pen when he was 19. He didn’t really like to talk about the time and he came out really messed up by the experience; maybe he didn’t earn a spot with the trustees and his time was just not as cozy.
I volunteered for free for the Gleaners program to distribute food to the disabled and elderly and I know it's not the same but there are lots of things that get accomplished with volunteer labor. In places like the Congo they have forced labor in the cobalt mines, etc...we use trustees here to do county cleanup projccts..
 
I think where I struggle with it is considering it "voluntary" if it is only done by prisoners and is done below market rates.

At least pay them minimum wage.

They should be allowed and even encouraged to do those jobs, sure. But they should be paid at least minimum wage to do it.
 
That, I'm okay with. Fine anybody you can actually prove did actual damage with so many dollars worth of repair and they can pay it off by working to clean up/repair it.
 
Last edited:
I volunteered for free for the Gleaners program to distribute food to the disabled and elderly and I know it's not the same but there are lots of things that get accomplished with volunteer labor. In places like the Congo they have forced labor in the cobalt mines, etc...we use trustees here to do county cleanup projccts..

Yes, there is no ethical production under capitalism; there’s blood on the cobalt in our computers, along with everything else. It’s unsustainable. But I’m talking about prisoners in the US and how they are legally slaves. The prisoners should be paid and if they aren’t they are slaves, by the definition of the constitution.

I’ve talked in other threads about how I would love a situation where non violent crime is met with rehab and public service. But even then, if the work is not voluntary, they should be paid minimum wage at least. You volunteered, and volunteer work is wonderful. It’s also voluntary.

Prisoners get so much stigma and difficulty finding work or making ends meet immediately after being released. It contributes to the recidivism rates we see. If they got paid for their work, and had money waiting for them when they were released, that might help lower that rate by giving free people who served their time a cushion to land on. (Of course these are all steps towards not needing so much retributive justice in the country but that’s going to take time)
 
That, I'm okay with. Fine anybody you can actually prove did actual damage with so many dollars worth of repair and they can pay it off by working to clean up/repair it.
As long as the police officers can be fined too, if it can be determined that their escalation into violence incited the damage.
 
As long as the police officers can be fined too, if it can be determined that their escalation into violence incited the damage.
Absolutely. Police should definitely be held accountable for that kind of thing. In fact I'd say police who escalate should be fired or at the very least suspended without pay.
 
Yes, there is no ethical production under capitalism; there’s blood on the cobalt in our computers, along with everything else. It’s unsustainable. But I’m talking about prisoners in the US and how they are legally slaves. The prisoners should be paid and if they aren’t they are slaves, by the definition of the constitution.

I’ve talked in other threads about how I would love a situation where non violent crime is met with rehab and public service. But even then, if the work is not voluntary, they should be paid minimum wage at least. You volunteered, and volunteer work is wonderful. It’s also voluntary.

Prisoners get so much stigma and difficulty finding work or making ends meet immediately after being released. It contributes to the recidivism rates we see. If they got paid for their work, and had money waiting for them when they were released, that might help lower that rate by giving free people who served their time a cushion to land on. (Of course these are all steps towards not needing so much retributive justice in the country but that’s going to take time)
I completely disagree...people write books and get college degrees in prison and some get job training through the trustee program...there are places in the world where prisons are run like slave plantations but that's not here. the biggest problem with our prison system is it doesn't make every prisoner reenter society with a marketable skill. I'm not saying prison doesn't suck but it's better here than Myanmar or Siberia. Our prison system is flawed, but not as flawed as it could be.
 

giphy.gif
 
Slave labor is literally what prison labor is. Read the 13th amendment:

Section 1. Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.”

I underlined the part that matters here.

So yes, slaves. People, even criminals, are humans, and should not be subject to unpaid labor. This is just my opinion; the city could pay to have the litter cleaned up but they don’t.
OAR 291-081-0030 – Inmate Compensation - OregonLawsOregonLawshttps://oregon.public.law › ... › Chap. 291 › Division 81
 
The traffic there is a warzone.
You got that right. We have learned to pick our days and times carefully when we want to go into town. It really hurts me to say it, but drivers in the PDX (which includes a huge swathe of southern WA) have inexplicably morphed into the worst drivers in the entire country. Started happening about the time local high schools quit providing driver's education.....truly pathetic.
 
I mean, I didn’t write the 13th amendment but they did explicitly say slavery was legal if the slave is a prisoner. I don’t know how false the equivalency can be if it’s in the text itself.

I'm not unsympathetic to your viewpoint here, but the 13th doesn't say all prisoners are and must be slaves, it only says that it's ok if some are.

barfo
 
I'm not unsympathetic to your viewpoint here, but the 13th doesn't say all prisoners are and must be slaves, it only says that it's ok if some are.

barfo
Wait. That doesn't seem any better...

Was there ever a law that said certain people must be slaves? Didn't the law almost literally just say that "it's ok if some are"?
 
Wait. That doesn't seem any better...

Was there ever a law that said certain people must be slaves? Didn't the law almost literally just say that "it's ok if some are"?

Correct as far as I know. I was really just disagreeing about "prison labor = slave labor". One could imagine a prison job that was optional, paid prevailing wages, etc.

barfo
 
Correct as far as I know. I was really just disagreeing about "prison labor = slave labor". One could imagine a prison job that was optional, paid prevailing wages, etc.

barfo
For sure. But it seems to me that the law should prevent all prisoners being used as slaves.

I can see an exception for when the punishment is specifically related to reparations for the crime they've been found guilty of, and determined by the judge at sentencing.

And then, only if there are safeguards in place to prevent abuse of that system. For example, if a judge is divying out these kinds of creative sentences regularly their record should be up for review and or investigation.

I'm not sure if there is currently a process in place for that kind of oversight or not.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top