Game Thread 2019 Civil War - Saturday, November 30th, 1:00 PM

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Register Log in

Current thoughts on these teams this year?

  • Total voters
    14
GhostOfPGA said:
Herbert, the o-line minus Sewell, and Dye aren’t gonna let this team lose today. Last game at Autzen is a special thing.
Click to expand...

as a Duck fan I'd like to think so. I've seen some crazy things happen in the Civil War though. And just last week, some real crazy things happened to both teams. Rivalry games can be a lot more unpredictable
 
wizenheimer said:
as a Duck fan I'd like to think so. I've seen some crazy things happen in the Civil War though. And just last week, some real crazy things happened to both teams. Rivalry games can be a lot more unpredictable
Click to expand...
As a Duck fan, I am so excited for Herbert to be in the NFL.
 
hoopsjock said:
You're going to regret saying that the next time a guy like Braxton Burmeister is the starter.
Click to expand...
lol, Taggart screwed that kid up for life didn't he. Refused to run any semblance of an offense, only passed the ball against 7-8db sets and then would scream at him for throwing it into traffic. I was so glad FSU took Taggart...
 
TorturedBlazerFan said:
As a Duck fan, I am so excited for Herbert to be in the NFL.
Click to expand...

these are the WR's Darron Thomas and Marcus Mariota had:

Jeff Maehl
Keanan Lowe
Drew Davis Sr.
De'anthony Thomas
Josh Huff
Lavasier Tuinei
Byron Marshall
Dwayne Stanford
Raashan Vaughn
Bralon Addison
Devon Allen
Darren Carrington
Charles Nelson

these are the TE's:

David Paulson
Malachai Lewis
Brandon Williams
Colt Lyerala
Pharoh Brown
Evan Bayliss
Johnny Mundt

these are the RB's:

Lamichael James
Kenjon Barner
De'anthony Thomas
Byron Marshall
Thomas Tyner
Kani Benoit
Royce Freeman
Tony Brooks-James

that was 5 years of the skill positions at Oregon

in overlap, Herbert has had a couple of seasons of Freeman and Benoit at RB. A season of Bayliss and Mundt at TE; 2 seasons of Nelson at WR, and 1 season of Carrington

and he's had Breeland at TE and 1 good season of Dillon Mitchell at WR. That's what he's had

that's it in 4 years. Compare the skill Herbert had to work with vs the skill Thomas and Mariota had to work with. It's about as big a mismatch as you could find. And a QB with mediocre skill support is not going to be all-american. Just won't happen
 
wizenheimer said:
these are the WR's Darron Thomas and Marcus Mariota had:

Jeff Maehl
Keanan Lowe
Drew Davis Sr.
De'anthony Thomas
Josh Huff
Lavasier Tuinei
Byron Marshall
Dwayne Stanford
Raashan Vaughn
Bralon Addison
Devon Allen
Darren Carrington
Charles Nelson

these are the TE's:

David Paulson
Malachai Lewis
Brandon Williams
Colt Lyerala
Pharoh Brown
Evan Bayliss
Johnny Mundt

these are the RB's:

Lamichael James
Kenjon Barner
De'anthony Thomas
Byron Marshall
Thomas Tyner
Kani Benoit
Royce Freeman
Tony Brooks-James

that was 5 years of the skill positions at Oregon

in overlap, Herbert has had a couple of seasons of Freeman and Benoit at RB. A season of Bayliss and Mundt at TE; 2 seasons of Nelson at WR, and 1 season of Carrington

and he's had Breeland at TE and 1 good season of Dillon Mitchell at WR. That's what he's had

that's it in 4 years. Compare the skill Herbert had to work with vs the skill Thomas and Mariota had to work with. It's about as big a mismatch as you could find. And a QB with mediocre skill support is not going to be all-american. Just won't happen
Click to expand...
So basically not much NFL talent for any of them. Freeman has probably been the best pro?

I think your better argument for herbert is that he's had so many different coaches.
 
tlongII said:
fify
Click to expand...
enhanced-buzz-14913-1408707298-14.jpg
 
TorturedBlazerFan said:
So basically not much NFL talent for any of them. Freeman has probably been the best pro?

I think your better argument for herbert is that he's had so many different coaches.
Click to expand...

iirc, 13 of the guys Thomas/Mariota played with have played in the NFL. Freeman is the only one that Herbert played with unless Carrington made it
 
THE HCP said:
Devastating loss for our Ducks last week. Can’t believe this game is on the PAC-12 Network. Ducks should handle the Beavs pretty easily in my opinion, but it has been fun seeing the Beavs win some game this season. #GoDucks
Click to expand...
Why is it on the Pac 12 network? WTH. I can't believe it either.
 
wizenheimer said:
iirc, 13 of the guys Thomas/Mariota played with have played in the NFL. Freeman is the only one that Herbert played with unless Carrington made it
Click to expand...
Did they stick or did coaching, their QB’s make them look better than they were?
 
Wright for the kickoff return TD!

that was an interesting stat: there have been 98 kickoffs returned for TD's in the civil war. That seems real high
 
wizenheimer said:
Wright for the kickoff return TD!

that was an interesting stat: there have been 98 kickoffs returned for TD's in the civil war. That seems real high
Click to expand...
The state of Oregon and special teams blunders, name a better duo.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

BoBoBREWSKI
Civil War Scenario
2
Replies
30
Views
2K
Natebishop3
Natebishop3
chris_in_pdx
Biggest Civil War ever?
Replies
8
Views
2K
tlongII
tlongII
SlyPokerDog
Oregon State, Oregon agree not to use the term ‘Civil War’ for its sports rivalry games
7 8 9
Replies
253
Views
18K
wizenheimer
wizenheimer
SlyPokerDog
Game Thread The final Pac-12 Civil War! 11/24/2023
4 5 6
Replies
151
Views
6K
Ripcity4life77
R
SlyPokerDog
Game Thread Beavers vs Ducks, The 129th Civil War Game! Saturday, 12pm, Autzen!
2 3
Replies
62
Views
2K
kjironman1
kjironman1

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top