Ayton was really good? But just how good?
I remember the year Hassan Whiteside spent as a Blazer. A lot of fans hated him and thought he sucked. But how does Whiteside in his year as a Blazer compare to Ayton this last season? Maybe that can gauge just how 'good' Ayton was:
Points/100-possessions: Ayton 23.2....Whiteside 24.7 (Whiteside 1.5 more points on 2.2 fewer shots)
Rebonds/100-possessions: Ayton 16.4....Whiteside 21.5
Blocks/100-possessions: Ayton 1.6....Whiteside 4.7
FTA/100-possessions: Ayton 2.4....Whiteside 5.7
Off Rating: Ayton 115....Whiteside 125
Def Rating: Ayton 112....Whiteside 107
Net Rating: Ayton +3....Whiteside +18
FG%: Ayton .566....Whiteside .621
FT%: Ayton .667....Whiteside .686
eFG%: Ayton .573....Whiteside .624
TS%: Ayton .583....Whiteside .644
Points/Shot: Ayton 1.23....Whiteside 1.48
PER: Ayton 17.7....Whiteside 25.0
FT Rate: Ayton .128....Whiteside .340
Total Reb Rate: Ayton 18.2%....Whiteside 23.6%
Off Reb Rate: Ayton 10.9%....Whiteside 13.6%
Assist Rate: Ayton 8.5%....Whiteside 5.9%
Block Rate: Ayton 2.9%....Whiteside 8.4%
Winshares/48: Ayton .113....Whiteside .204
BPM: Ayton -0.7....Whiteside +3.2
VORP: Ayton 0.4....Whiteside 2.6 (cumulative; but Whiteside 650% higher VORP on 67% more minutes)
it's a clean sweep, across the board for Whiteside...except for assists rate. And considering Ayton is a poor passer, that make Whiteside terrible
but other that that....
* Whiteside was an elite rim-protector & shot-blocker. Yeah, sometimes he'd go overboard hunting shots to block and allow back door offensive rebounds. But he had a definite impact in altering opponent shots. When Whiteside was on the floor, opponents had a eFG% of .523; when he was off the floor, it was .538. When Ayton was on the floor, opponents had an eFG% of .570; when he was off the floor it was .531. Those are huge differences
* same is true for the overall opponent offenses. When Whiteside was on the floor opponents had an offensive rating of 113.8; off the floor it was 116.9. Not the same, at all, for Ayton. When he was on the floor, Opponents had an offensive rating of 118.4; when he was off the floor 113.6
* if you're keeping track, Whitesides on/off-team/opponent net offensive rating was +8.0. Ayton's was -5.1
to me, rim protection and paint defense are, generically, the most important skills for a modern big. Rebounding is quite important too and Whiteside was much better at that, at both ends of the floor, especially offensive rebounding. Whiteside got to the FT line at a much higher rate which meant he was drawing fouls on defenders and getting opponents in the bonus; not the case with Ayton. They both suck as passers. Whiteside was better at screens
the only skill advantage Ayton has is mid-range shooting; without drawing fouls. I don't see much value in that. I wasn't very fond of Whiteside, but IMO, he did things well that had more value
so I guess maybe the question was Whiteside underrated or is Ayton overrated; or a combo of both. Some people claimed Whiteside had empty stats. If he had empty stats, are Ayton's even emptier?
so very glad he's gone