Trade Ben Simmons poll (3 Viewers)

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Register Log in

What's the most you would give up for Ben Simmons?

  • Total voters
    145

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 4 (members: 0, guests: 4)
Buffalo Custard said:
Remember this: a major trade now is an acknowledgement that the roster WAS the problem. That is directly contrary to Olshey's established position. Personally, I suspect he is willing to die on that hill.
Click to expand...
As has been pointed out, we just got 6 new players this summer (while losing 8 from the previous roster) translating to >40% turnover from last year's roster. What he said and what he did are quite divergent.
 
Buffalo Custard said:
Remember this: a major trade now is an acknowledgement that the roster WAS the problem. That is directly contrary to Olshey's established position. Personally, I suspect he is willing to die on that hill.
Click to expand...
This is incredibly faulty logic.

I'll guarantee that nobody said the Warriors' roster was the problem in 2016 before they signed KD. They simply took an already great roster and made it better. (No, I am not saying that the Blazers' roster is comparable to the 2016 Warriors--please nobody claim that I did.)

If Neil honestly believes the roster is good enough to contend, but also honestly believes that a trade will make it better, those are not inherently contradictory beliefs.
 
illmatic99 said:
As has been pointed out, we just got 6 new players this summer (while losing 8 from the previous roster) translating to >40% turnover from last year's roster. What he said and what he did are quite divergent.
Click to expand...

I don't consider players like Blevins, RHJ, or Giles to have any relevance to the teams roster continuity.

Melo and Kanter were the only guys in the rotation that didnt return.

The prior year it was Ariza and Whiteside gone, who regularly started.

After the WCF we lost Aminu, Harkless, Kanter, Turner, Curry, Leonard

I'd say this summer where all the starters returning and only two rotational player changes was right there with any offseason for the least changes.

I'm interested to see what the Billups changes look like and hopefully better health, but a narrative that Neil made significant roster changes is not true.
 
WesleyMatthews said:
I don't consider players like Blevins, RHJ, or Giles to have any relevance to the teams roster continuity.

Melo and Kanter were the only guys in the rotation that didnt return.

The prior year it was Ariza and Whiteside gone, who regularly started.

After the WCF we lost Aminu, Harkless, Kanter, Turner, Curry, Leonard

I'd say this summer where all the starters returning and only two rotational player changes was right there with any offseason for the least changes.

I'm interested to see what the Billups changes look like and hopefully better health, but a narrative that Neil made significant roster changes is not true.
Click to expand...

I can agree with that, but I don't think his lack of changes to the starters and primary rotation have been due to some supposed hard-headedness.
 
WesleyMatthews said:
I don't consider players like Blevins, RHJ, or Giles to have any relevance to the teams roster continuity.

Melo and Kanter were the only guys in the rotation that didnt return.

The prior year it was Ariza and Whiteside gone, who regularly started.

After the WCF we lost Aminu, Harkless, Kanter, Turner, Curry, Leonard

I'd say this summer where all the starters returning and only two rotational player changes was right there with any offseason for the least changes.

I'm interested to see what the Billups changes look like and hopefully better health, but a narrative that Neil made significant roster changes is not true.
Click to expand...

Glad to see some folks get it.
 
illmatic99 said:
Rich Paul needs to get to work and start throwing grenades on NBA Twitter. Force their hand by not just making it "bumpy" but downright ugly.
Click to expand...

If that happens part of me just wants to see Morey take a hard stand and say fine sit out we wont trade you, good luck.

Its ridiculous a player finishing year 1 of a $170 million rookie extension can hold a franchise hostage... but if a player gets out of shape, hurt, old, or ineffective the team has to eat these shit contracts.
 
WesleyMatthews said:
If that happens part of me just wants to see Morey take a hard stand and say fine sit out we wont trade you, good luck.

Its ridiculous a player finishing year 1 of a $170 million rookie extension can hold a franchise hostage... but if a player gets out of shape, hurt, old, or ineffective the team has to eat these shit contracts.
Click to expand...
Well it goes both ways. Morey has been trying to trade Ben from the moment he came to Philly last year, and has full power to send him wherever he wants to without Ben's discretion. Not to mention the public ridicule he's faced from fans/teammate/coach.

I tend to side with the players on this sorta stuff. Why support billion $ franchises over multi-millionaire players?
 
illmatic99 said:
Well it goes both ways. Morey has been trying to trade Ben from the moment he came to Philly last year, and has full power to send him wherever he wants to without Ben's discretion. Not to mention the public ridicule he's faced from fans/teammate/coach.

I tend to side with the players on this sorta stuff. Why support billion $ franchises over multi-millionaire players?
Click to expand...

Morey job is to try and do trades to improve the roster. That is part of why a player is in a sports league that gives him a $170 million contract.

If Ben wants to threaten a hold out or whatever that is his choice and I believe he should be able to do it.

I also believe the 6ers should be able to say no we won't trade you for less than your worth to us and we won't pay you anything while you sit out.

But it seems like we never get a situation that plays out that way, the player still gets paid while sitting and then gets sent to their preferred team. If this happens differently I will be glad to see it.
 
illmatic99 said:
In the past, perhaps. But I don't see that this year. At least, I would hope not.
Click to expand...

There haven't been any rumors at all that Neil is shopping him. So either he's waiting for someone to make a sweetheart deal, or he's simply not listening.
 
I don’t really understand Moreys plan here. Isn’t the best case scenario a harden situation? Aka he shows up and plays lackadaisical and sort of ruins team chemistry/momentum
 
WesleyMatthews said:
On Mike Richmonds Locked on Blazers podcast Monday he basically said the Blazers roster is set and he doesn't expect a trade. He doesn't believe the Blazers are interested in offering CJ for Simmons. Although the Blazers are normally very quiet on their end when any trade discussions are happening, Mike says there would be more noise from Philly and Ben's agents if any of those talks were happening.

This aligns with Brian Windhorst reporting that its the Blazers who are not interested in a CJ for Simmons trade. Mike says there is a 98% chance the Blazers do not make a trade soon and 99% chance there will not be a Simmons to Portland trade.
Click to expand...

If this is really the case and that's it, this is not good sign, imo.
I love CJ and I think he is great player and I would love to see CJ getting ring in Portland, but this is heart, not brain.
And Blazers played this card (heart over brain) for some time now and it obviously get them nowhere.
If this team don't want to go full time professional and play this "friendship" still, I see Billups going sooner than later.
I think the main reasons Olshey don't want to trade CJ for Simmons are non basketball factors and this is fuckin crazy.
 
royo said:
If this is really the case and that's it, this is not good sign, imo.
I love CJ and I think he is great player and I would love to see CJ getting ring in Portland, but this is heart, not brain.
And Blazers played this card (heart over brain) for some time now and it obviously get them nowhere.
If this team don't want to go full time professional and play this "friendship" still, I see Billups going sooner than later.
I think the main reasons Olshey don't want to trade CJ for Simmons are non basketball factors and this is fuckin crazy.
Click to expand...

If true, Neil should be fired ASAP. Its incredible he still has a job and wasn’t fired along with Stotts. What's even worse is him taking zero responsibility despite having kept Stotts around for nearly a decade.
 
WesleyMatthews said:
Morey job is to try and do trades to improve the roster. That is part of why a player is in a sports league that gives him a $170 million contract.

If Ben wants to threaten a hold out or whatever that is his choice and I believe he should be able to do it.

I also believe the 6ers should be able to say no we won't trade you for less than your worth to us and we won't pay you anything while you sit out.

But it seems like we never get a situation that plays out that way, the player still gets paid while sitting and then gets sent to their preferred team. If this happens differently I will be glad to see it.
Click to expand...
I mean... Did you feel this same way when Dame raised a stink and made all his cryptic posts this summer? He too is in the first yr of a supermax deal. Why doesnt he just shut up and do his job?

Ya I know there are obvious differences between how Dame has handled it vs Rich Paul, but it's a similar premise.

All this said, I dont see why Simmons should come back to that toxic environment. He's admittedly willing to be fined so lets see how this plays out. It's just interesting how fans side with ownership and management over players so often in these scenarios.
 
illmatic99 said:
Yet another video supporting why we should go after Ben

Click to expand...


A TON of issues there that are coaching oriented in nature in terms of the spacing and movement....or lack thereof. It doesn't change Simmons' weaknesses but they certainly didn't play to his strenghts for large portions of the time either.
 
illmatic99 said:
I mean... Did you feel this same way when Dame raised a stink and made all his cryptic posts this summer? He too is in the first yr of a supermax deal. Why doesnt he just shut up and do his job?

Ya I know there are obvious differences between how Dame has handled it vs Rich Paul, but it's a similar premise.

All this said, I dont see why Simmons should come back to that toxic environment. He's admittedly willing to be fined so lets see how this plays out. It's just interesting how fans side with ownership and management over players so often in these scenarios.
Click to expand...

If Dame did the same comments and demands as Simmons I may think similar, as you said they have acted totally differently.

I think many people don't side with players because its a slap in the face to fans of the team and these guys make more money than others can dream of playing a game for entertainment. Then they fail to back up that contract. Of course owners make a boatload, but they paid a boatload as well. None of the players put in $2 billion of their own money to be a part of the league as many owners have done.

Some players want the guarantee of $ if they get injured but don't honor the commitment to the team if the team struggles. Whats the point of a contract at all then if all the downside is on the team? Why not have all players play on one year deals?

I'm fine if Ben makes these demands, but if the team doesn't trade him, he loses fan interest, and he doesn't get paid I'm fine with that as well. I'd welcome seeing some examples of this behavior backfire on the player because it seems all of these examples get the player what he wants while often hurting the team.
 
illmatic99 said:
I mean... Did you feel this same way when Dame raised a stink and made all his cryptic posts this summer? He too is in the first yr of a supermax deal. Why doesnt he just shut up and do his job?

Ya I know there are obvious differences between how Dame has handled it vs Rich Paul, but it's a similar premise.

All this said, I dont see why Simmons should come back to that toxic environment. He's admittedly willing to be fined so lets see how this plays out. It's just interesting how fans side with ownership and management over players so often in these scenarios.
Click to expand...

Many fans still cling to the quaint notion that players have loyalty to their coaches, team-mates, and fans. Such players are exceedingly rare.

And BTW, the differences between Dame and Simmons in this case are not just obvious, but profound! Even if Dame asked for a trade, he is one of those rare individuals who would continue to act like a consumate professional and keep giving his all on the court. Simmons is wired very differently, and that is why I am not enthusiastic about acquiring him. YMMV,
 
Buffalo Custard said:
Many fans still cling to the quaint notion that players have loyalty to their coaches, team-mates, and fans. Such players are exceedingly rare.

And BTW, the differences between Dame and Simmons in this case are not just obvious, but profound! Even if Dame asked for a trade, he is one of those rare individuals who would continue to act like a consumate professional and keep giving his all on the court. Simmons is wired very differently, and that is why I am not enthusiastic about acquiring him. YMMV,
Click to expand...
It is a conundrum for whoever takes him on. He is uber talented as far as athleticism, play making & defense. But how committed to his craft is he? Maybe a change of scenery is all he needs. Or maybe he turns his next team upside down.
 
Idog1976 said:
If true, Neil should be fired ASAP. Its incredible he still has a job and wasn’t fired along with Stotts. What's even worse is him taking zero responsibility despite having kept Stotts around for nearly a decade.
Click to expand...
Lol
So glad we won’t be getting overrated Simmons. Good job Neil for not making that trade
 
Time to rejoice!! Simmons can go and take his game that hasn’t improved and only regressed since getting to the NBA to another team and we can finally finally stop this Simmons talk lmao.
 
Ben's family will have a huge impact on what his next move will be. His parents and siblings all bend his ear on what he should and shouldn't do which is probably pretty normal.
I don't think he will report to camp right away, but eventually will to avoid losing money. Then it could go either way.
 
Let's make sure we never trade for any player unless they are almost perfect....whether they are a multi-time all star and elite defender/passer or not. Only nearly perfect players are allowed here.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top