POR drafting the last 3 years has been atrocious...there is no way around it and no sugar coating it...
I'm not over the moon about the players we've collected, but let me try to coat some sugar.
Nolan Smith was not projected as a 1st round pick anywhere I saw, he was projected as a 2nd round pick and by REACHING for him POR passed up on Faried who WAS well regarded by a lot of scouts AND was a need (b\u PF) for the team. FURTHERMORE there were other highly regarded players (Marshon Brooks, Norris Cole) on the board....it was a horrible pick, no other way around it, and to make matters worse not only has Nolan Smith generally looked bad and shown that he is likely more of a "combo" guard\SG than a PG but those three players taken after him all have looked good this year, particularly Faried. Buchanan is a bad scout...his reasonings were need, senior, came from big time program, character....all stupid reasons to select a player for the NBA....You don't use those as your main "selling\reasoning" points and outweigh them over talent & NBA position....
First: I agree that Nolan was a dodgy pick, although I think he has turned out worse than could reasonably be predicted.
HOWEVER: the pick does not prove that Buchanan is a bad scout. We don't know that this was Buchanan's call. While it's conspiracy theorizing to lay EVERYthing at Nate's feet, this pick does smack rather of McMillan. He has long worked with Coach K (the original one) for team USA and probably wanted a senior from a big program whose coaching he felt he could trust. Coach K had plenty of time to sell Nolan up.
I'm not convinced that Marshon Brooks or Norris Cole are better picks. Brooks makes Jamal Crawford look pass-first and Norris Cole has cooled off massively since looking vaguely good while playing with the Miami 3. I bet Nolan could look pretty good in that situation (in fact, it would be ideal for him, as Wade or James could handle the ball.)
Faried is making us look stupid. But not just us.
However, the player I continue to think we really should have drafted is Nicola Mirotic, who has just become the first player ever to win back to back "rising star" awards in the Euroleague, and looks like an only-slightly-poor man's Pau Gasol.
Finally, remember: picked BEFORE Nolan were such greats as Jimmer Fredette (10), Marcus Morris (14), Chris Singleton (18), Tobias Harris (19). Some of those might turn out decent, but so might Nolan (in the right situation) and they've certainly done little so far.
Luke Babbitt has finally shown that he may have some use as an off the bench scorer, but he was a reach at #16....particularly when you see guys like Chase Budinger and Chandler Parsons for HOU, both similiar players, taken in the 2nd round and who have played better to date....just a stupid reach pick, and Buchanan's comments were basically 50\40\90...just dumb, especially when you had some good PG prospects like Avery Bradley & Eric Bledsoe who were available?
Don't we have Pritchard to thank for Luke Babbitt? Didn't he sing his praises on the way out the door?
I was dead against Budinger, I remember, as he had a "soft" label, and I still don't think he's all that. And Parsons went undrafted, so EVERYBODY whiffed on him (and signed with Houston as a free agent). I'm with you on Bradley, who has turned out to be very useful for Boston, although he's not a "PG prospect" at all. The reason he sank so low is because he, like Bledsoe, cannot run a team. Bradley is only having success now because he's playing with a veteran team with a ton of scorers, and alongside Rondo.
Elliot Williams has shown some flash of good potential, he will be an undersized SG but he has shown talent as possibly being an off the bench scorer, but here is the problem...He can't stay healthy, he has Roy\Oden syndrome...I hope he can come back and stay healthy, if so then this pick looks better...
True.
Armon Johnson was\is HORRIBLE what a waste of a pick, instead of addressing a PG at #16 which they should of done they tried to bandaid it here, should have gone BPA here and I refuse to believe that Johnson was BPA, if he was then POR scouts really are awful...Fields, Stephenson, Jeremy Evans...Ainge (Bradley, Harangody), O'Conner (Hayward, Evans) and Walsh (Rautins, Fields & J.Jordan) all potential GM candidates fared much better than POR
Funny that you sing the praises of Bledsoe and trash Armon, when both are pretty similar. Good to great athletes who are too short to play SG and have no PG skills. And no pick in the second round is EVER terrible, because 90% of players in the second round are out of the league in 2 years. Okay, that stat was made up on the spot, but I bet it's not far off. Let's look at the two picks before Armon, shall we?
32 Oklahoma City Thunder Dexter Pittman C, 6-11, 303 Texas
33 Sacramento Kings Hassan Whiteside C, 7-0, 235 Marshall
I rest my case.
and then you have 2009....the punting of a pick (Claver) who may never even come over to the NBA, you don't think Casspi, Beabouis (worked out in POR at least twice) or Taj Gibson would have helped?
Beaubois is ANOTHER short shooting guard. He looked good for a while for Dallas, but they've cooled on him considerably. Casspi has also pretty much disappeared. Taj Gibson was a "boring" pick - Ed O would've screamed, because I think he was 23 when he was drafted. Clearly Chicago (who've picked up Gibson, Asik and Mirotic, all with low picks) are doing something very right. I get the impression that Claver was a fallback when (a) ALL of the PGs the Blazers wanted went in the five picks before Claver (seriously, by the 16th pick they had to be thinking "we're BOUND to get ONE of the PGs we want" and then this happened:
Code:
17. 76ers Jrue Holiday PG
18. Timberwolves Ty Lawson PG
19. Hawks Jeff Teague PG
20. Jazz Eric Maynor PG
21. Hornets Darren Collison PG
...so Claver was picked just so the Blazers didn't have to fill a roster spot right now. Stashing is a time-honored Spurs tradition.
Then we take Cunningham & Pendergraph with high 2nd round picks, both end of bench NBA types over a guy like Dejuan Blair (projected 1st round consensus pick) Why b\c of injury? really?
Jesus, do we have to rehash Blair AGAIN? YES because of injury! See your comments about Elliot Williams. And remember, the Blazers' doctors had declared Darius Miles' knees unfit to play, so we couldn't really go endorsing Blair. In fact, I seem to recall hearing he got a medical red flag from just about every team.
So sorry, but anyone defending Buchanan must be either insane or a serious homer, his track record is horrible...
Why do people say "sorry" when they don't mean it?
Buchanan hasn't looked awesome, that's for sure. But in every draft, there are worse picks above him, and most of your complaints are about THE SECOND ROUND, which is where basically they let the interns make the picks because IT REALLY DOESN'T MATTER. If you get a half-decent pick in the second round you know you're incredibly fortunate. If your player is a dog, it's what you expect!
Out of those NINE players taken in THREE years, you have ZERO starters and possibly 2? 3? rotation players and that is being very generous....So it is obvious to see why this team has a talent deficiency gap, they just have failed miserably in the draft of adding young talent to this roster and this with more picks in the last 3 drafts (9) than a lot of other teams.
Let's look at some
lottery picks in that time:
Code:
2009
2. Grizzlies Hasheem Thabeet C
6. Timberwolves Jonny Flynn PG
8. Knicks Jordan Hill PF
11. Nets Terrence Williams SG
12. Bobcats Gerald Henderson SG
13. Pacers Tyler Hansbrough PF
14. Suns Earl Clark SF
2010
2 Philadelphia 76ers Evan Turner SG, 6-7, 214 Ohio State
3 New Jersey Nets Derrick Favors F, 6-10, 246 Georgia Tech
4 Minnesota Timberwolves Wesley Johnson F, 6-7, 195 Syracuse
8 Los Angeles Clippers Al-Farouq Aminu F, 6-8, 210 Wake Forest
11 New Orleans Hornets Cole Aldrich C, 6-11, 245 Kansas
12 Memphis Grizzlies Xavier Henry G, 6-6, 210 Kansas
13 Toronto Raptors Ed Davis F, 6-9, 215 North Carolina
14 Houston Rockets Patrick Patterson F, 6-8, 223 Kentucky
2011
2. Timberwolves Derrick Williams PF
3. Jazz Enes Kanter C
4. Cavaliers Tristan Thompson PF
6. Wizards Jan Vesely SF
7. Kings Bismack Biyombo PF
10. Bucks Jimmer Fredette PG
12. Jazz Alec Burks SG
14. Rockets Marcus Morris PF
Feel better?