At the time of the Eovaldi trade, I said I understood Cashman's line of thinking. He did trade away a "fine player" (my description) in Prado along with Phelps for the package of Eovaldi, Jones and German.
YOU were the one who made Jones out to be more than he was....
...yes Cashman was looking for LH pop off the bench who can play 1b and RF in Jones, but the centerpiece was Eovaldi a young very hard thrower who they believed could turn the corner and develop into an effective SP for years to come. He hasn't and is still the same pitcher he's always been.
It was a gamble as are many trades....but nobody ever said at the time it was a GOOD trade including me, so stop the bullshit.
And Domingo German was also included which became a bone of contention for you. You thought he was just a throw-in of little consequence but at the time he was a 21 year old SP with a 2.33 ERA and 1.15 WHIP in five minor league seasons. I also understood why Cashman would want him as part of the deal. Maybe YOU think it was stupid or irresponsible trying to get both Eovaldi and German....and it hasn't worked out.
Bad trade.