I wonder about Isaiah Collier with GS's pick. Granted he did not have a consistent year, but he did break his hand halfway through the season, so that doesn't mean he won't still be the star that many projected him to be before last season.
The combine measurements will be very important. Is he really 6'4 210 lbs? Can he eventually be as good as Scoot? Long term we would only want one of them, but if he is the BPA I am okay with taking him. One of them will have value in a trade in a year or two.
Now if there is a player at another position who also has crazy potential, then take that person. I just don't want this to be another Telfair scenario.