That's odd. I don't seem to recall ANYONE in this forum ever saying we should TOTALLY ABANDON running ISOs for Roy. Perhaps you could provide a link.
Yes, it is a great tool - as long as it isn't your ONLY tool. When you run it six times in a row it gets easier for the defense to stop each time. When all five defenders, the opposing coach, the ballboys and the cheerleaders all know exactly what play is coming it becomes less and less effective. After getting stopped six times in a row, perhaps it's time to give something else a try.
Yes, by all means keep the Roy ISOs. Just mix them in with other plays to keep the defense honest. If the entire defense is allowed to key on Roy it makes him much less effective. With Miller, Aldridge, Bayless and Martell (the way he's been playing lately) we certainly have enough offensive weapons that we don't have to run the ICE play for Roy every time down the court over the last 3 or 4 minutes if the game. We have seen how that kills our momentum and allows the defense to focus on stopping one player. So, we can still run the Roy ISOs 50% (or more) of the time, but mix it up a little, use the talents of our other players and make the defense guard all five players, not just one.
BNM