Just Wondering...

[Mr. J]

Who do you dislike more: Scott Layden or Isiah Thomas? They both were/are terrible GM's, but which one would you prefer?

 

[The One & Only]

Garbage or Garbage....hard decision....

I can't decide but all I know is we need some serious changes.

 

[Chutney]

I think, living in the Isiah era, people forget how terrible Layden was. I'd take Isiah (wow, I feel like my IQ just dropped).

 

[Tha CTown Knick]

Layden. Isiah is bad but Layden was beyond horrible.

 

[Tribute to H2O]

They both sucked horribly. Layden took a good team and made it bad. Then Isiah came along, took the bad team and made it into the worst team in franchise history while making it the most expensive. I'll have to go with Layden on this one. As bad as his trades were the players always came ready to play hard unlike the dumb gutless bums Isiah brought in. Ward/H20/Van Horn/Kurt Thomas/Mutumbo>>>Marbury,Crawford,Woods,Rose,Curry any day of the week and twice on Sundays.


Anyway I think Isiah Thomas should be fired.

 

[The One & Only]

<div class="quote_poster">Quote:</div><div class="quote_post">Anyway I think Isiah Thomas should be fired.</div>

You say that in every post....

 

[02civic]

By isiah is worse than Layden...like H20 said, even though they werent that good they still played hard...at least hard compared to the **** the Knicks are putting out in Isiahs term

 

[Platehpus]

Layden was way worse. Howard Eisley? Shandon Anderson?

 

[giftedvisionz]

A GM who made some bad decisions or a little 7 year old boy GM who seems like he's playing manager in a game of NBA Live? I am totally confident when I say that 75% of the people here could do a better job than Isiah.

 

[Really Lost One]

<div class="quote_poster">Quoting giftedvisionz:</div><div class="quote_post"> I am totally confident when I say that 75% of the people here could do a better job than Isiah.</div>
all i know is that i could have. i was shocked when isiah didnt protect a potential lottery pick when he traded it to chicago. if i were gm i wouldnt have thought twice about doing that. also, i know better than to have a roster with guys like marbury, francis, rose, richardson, and crawford. i mean, how the hell does he think that would work out? they all play pretty much the same position, and all they do is shoot the ball.

anyways, its hard to imagine any gm that can be worse than isiah

 

[02civic]

<div class="quote_poster">Quoting Platehpus:</div><div class="quote_post">Layden was way worse. Howard Eisley? Shandon Anderson?</div>

Nothing wrong with Shandon Anderson as a player. Howard Eisley did well at times as well...with other teams. Not exactly great players but i'd take both Howard and Shandon over Malik Rose and Francis.

 

[Platehpus]

he was exposed countless times in the 03-04 playoffs against the nets, which might be one of the reasons i hate on him....but dude should never be a starter in todays league