OT MLB Major Rule Changes For 2023 Season

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Users who are viewing this thread

Ironically this is the rule change I'm fearing ... getting rid of the human element of the game ... but I know it's coming
I've heard this before, and I don't really understand. it seems that the "human element" is mistakes. Why would you not want to eliminate inaccuracies in calls? It's not something that's possible in football or basketball, but everything in baseball is kind of a yes or no input. Eliminating bad calls seems pretty ideal.
 
I've heard this before, and I don't really understand. it seems that the "human element" is mistakes. Why would you not want to eliminate inaccuracies in calls? It's not something that's possible in football or basketball, but everything in baseball is kind of a yes or no input. Eliminating bad calls seems pretty ideal.
I don't mind umps having different strike zones as long as they are consistent, the human factor isn't necessarily an error, but an oddity to the game of baseball. Think of it like how no two fields are exactly alike, they are all a little different in dimension in the outfield, it gives baseball a different flair to it.
 
Disagree. And I don't know why it's apparently OK for a football game to last 3+ hours, but not a baseball game. And FWIW, the 24 second clock has been around for 85+ years and was implemented when the NBA was still in its infancy.

You think the changes are worthwhile?, that's OK, I don't.
The NBA continues to make a TON of changes to make the game more enjoyable, and more offensive minded, not just the 24 second clock.

- 3 seconds in the key was because Wilt could just camp out there and dominate.

- Similarly, goal tending was instituted to stop Wilt and Russ from blocking everything

- 10 seconds to bring the ball up court, and now 8 seconds - to speed the game up

- the 3-pt shot to add excitement and scoring

- As you will recall, in the 1990s, game scores were in the 90s mostly, and were defensive snoozefests. Jerry Colangelo headed a whole committee to figure out how to increase scoring. Games now are in the 120s and much more enjoyable to watch. Getting rid of hip-checking was one answer.

- Getting rid of tip-offs to start each quarter sped the game up too

Etc. Things change. Baseball needed some big adjustments. Just look at TV attendance. People are more impatient, and like scoring and offense.
 
The NBA continues to make a TON of changes to make the game more enjoyable, and more offensive minded, not just the 24 second clock.

- 3 seconds in the key was because Wilt could just camp out there and dominate.

- Similarly, goal tending was instituted to stop Wilt and Russ from blocking everything

- 10 seconds to bring the ball up court, and now 8 seconds - to speed the game up

- the 3-pt shot to add excitement and scoring

- As you will recall, in the 1990s, game scores were in the 90s mostly, and were defensive snoozefests. Jerry Colangelo headed a whole committee to figure out how to increase scoring. Games now are in the 120s and much more enjoyable to watch. Getting rid of hip-checking was one answer.

- Getting rid of tip-offs to start each quarter sped the game up too

Etc. Things change. Baseball needed some big adjustments. Just look at TV attendance. People are more impatient, and like scoring and offense.


Well said, and point taken...FWIW, I didn't bring up the NBA. But yeah, I get your comparison.
 
Last edited:
I don't get why they'd need larger bases at all....I don't mind the pitch clock and kind of like the one timeout for batters....the game needs to speed up but larger bases are like saying it's ok to use cork bats again...
 
Apparently larger bases decreases injuries and increases stolen bases.
 
Apparently larger bases decreases injuries and increases stolen bases.
I don't see how a larger base would cause fewer injuries but it does make it easier to steal a base. I'm for leaving the bases alone
 
I don't see how a larger base would cause fewer injuries but it does make it easier to steal a base. I'm for leaving the bases alone
Gives more space for defenders and runners to not occupy the same space, occupying the same space leads to collisions and that leads to injuries. It might not seem like a lot but every little inch helps, just ask Mrs. HCP!
 
I don't see how a larger base would cause fewer injuries but it does make it easier to steal a base. I'm for leaving the bases alone
ABC News:

"Besides the activity on the basepaths, Major League Baseball is hoping the change will help reduce injuries. While testing the bigger bases in the minors, there was a 13% decline in what the league calls “injury events near the bases” from 2021 to 2022."
 
ABC News:

"Besides the activity on the basepaths, Major League Baseball is hoping the change will help reduce injuries. While testing the bigger bases in the minors, there was a 13% decline in what the league calls “injury events near the bases” from 2021 to 2022."
I'd have to say that in all my years of playing baseball, I've never seen a bag injure someone but I have seen a runner injure someone with cleats which in my view would happen regardless of the bag size....in minor leagues there's less aggressive base stealing. A guy like Ty Cobb would try to take out a player for a steal..I guess if it keeps players safer, it's going to be implemented. will tarnish stolen base records a bit but the 3 pt shot did the same in hoops...Jerry West would have had thousands more pts if he'd had a 3 pt shot.
 
I'd have to say that in all my years of playing baseball, I've never seen a bag injure someone but I have seen a runner injure someone with cleats which in my view would happen regardless of the bag size....in minor leagues there's less aggressive base stealing. A guy like Ty Cobb would try to take out a player for a steal..I guess if it keeps players safer, it's going to be implemented. will tarnish stolen base records a bit but the 3 pt shot did the same in hoops...Jerry West would have had thousands more pts if he'd had a 3 pt shot.

I've seen twisted ankles, hyper-extended knee, torn ligaments from stepping on the base improperly when running, but hell, I've seen that sort of thing at 2B, 3B, and at HP...so I don't see how making the bases bigger is gonna help protect the base runners...if anything it would seem to make for an even bigger place to get hurt on.
 
Come on you guys! It's obvious that bigger bases will decrease injuries. More surface area means the chance of an intersection is lessened.
 
They could actually eliminate bags altogether and have the base level with the ground like homeplate is. Would be tougher for umps to call but safer I guess.
 
They could actually eliminate bags altogether and have the base level with the ground like homeplate is. Would be tougher for umps to call but safer I guess.
I think the physical properties of the base are important. Runners depend on them to slow their momentum when stealing, they practically overrun the bags now they have so much speed. A flat plate would make it way harder to steal and probably slow down base runners who use the bag to turn etc.
 
I think the physical properties of the base are important. Runners depend on them to slow their momentum when stealing, they practically overrun the bags now they have so much speed. A flat plate would make it way harder to steal and probably slow down base runners who use the bag to turn etc.
And there is nothing more enjoyable to watch than a perfectly executed hook slide. Which would disappear entirely if the bases were flush.......
 
Would it be too much to ask in the new rule era that the Mariners make the playoffs 2 years in a row? I now.....it's crazy talk.....next thing you know I'll want the Blazers to actually have a chance to contend.
 
In all seriousness though, it's gotta tough to be a Blazers fan and watch an incredible talent like Lillard all these years, but no championship.
 
I get trying to speed up the game, but I hate the pitch clock and I hate the runner on second in extra innings.
 
I get trying to speed up the game, but I hate the pitch clock and I hate the runner on second in extra innings.
Pitchers seem to hate the new balls which are great for homeruns with fast balls and changeups but sliders and curves are way less controllable.
 
Back
Top