I don't have to imagine hard to think of a time when Mo has played as badly, or worse, than CJ.
In this last five games:
2-7 (10 points)
2-8 (4 points)
1-4 (3 points)
1-7 (2 points)
3-9 (7 points)
You're talking about small sample sizes, but how many games has Mo actually put up double figures shooting?
I counted. 19 games out of 49 that he's played in has he gone over double figures. That's less than 40% of the games he has played in. CJ scored 15 last night. Mo has only gotten 15 or more points five times ALL YEAR. That's only 10% of his games. CJ has done it twice in the last two games.
The guy averages 24 minutes per game, and yet he is one of our most inconsistent scorers. He is shooting under 40% from the field. That's horrible. The guy is just flat out overrated as a scorer, he is extremely inefficient, and his over dribbling and poor decision making is really hurting the team. Since he went out CJ has really stepped up. He's shooting a combined 15-28 over the last three games for 53.5% from the field, and 7-13 from three for 54%. You say small sample size, but I say there's a direct connection between Mo going out and CJ playing markedly better.
You've singled out ONE stat - the ONE thing C.J. currently does better than Mo. I never said C.J. wasn't a better shooter than Mo. In fact, I compared him earlier in this thread to Travis Outlaw light. ALL C.J. gives us right now is the ability to create his own shot. He doesn't create for his teammates and he turns the ball over WAY too much. Of course, C.J. has a much higher BBIQ than Travis Outlaw and 16 games into his rookie season he's already the equivalent to Outlaw in his prime. So, obviously he has a MUCH higher ceiling than Travis Outlaw.
But, ask yourself this: of those 5 games, how many have the Blazers won? How many did we blow a 4th quarter lead? How many assists did C.J. have? More critically, how many 4th quarter assists did he have? How many TOVs did he have? More critically, how many 4th quarter TOVs did he have?
So yeah, he shoots better than Mo Williams, but does everything else worse (at this point in his young career). I don't know were to look this up, but Mike Barrett is constantly saying that Mo Williams leads the ENTIRE NBA in 4th quarter assists. We don't get that, any of that with C.J. McCollum. What we get is very, very few 4th quarter assists and multiple critical 4th quarter TOVs. I, for one, don't think it's a coincidence that we are now blowing 4th quarter leads and losing the close games we used to win. Of course, that's not all on C.J., but his poor overall 4th quarter play sure isn't helping us win those close games.
I'm not down on C.J. I just recognize his limitations. Right now, he's a shooter that can create his own shot, but does little else and turns the ball over way too much - even for a rookie.
I actually think C.J. and Mo can play well together on the second unit as they have complimentary skills. I'd like to see that when Mo comes back. Dorell has pretty much played his way out of the rotation and I'm fine with C.J. getting his minutes, but because there is more to playing basketball than a single skill, he is not yet an adequate replacement for Mo.
BNM