Rate My Signature Thread

[bbwtrench]

I agree, that new Kweli sig is pure sick. 10/10 wow, I gave you a dime Notorious! haha

 

[NTC]

Those last 3 are your best works so far Notorious,

8/10 for Talib Kweli #1
9/10 for Corey Magette
10/10 for Talib Kweli #2

Wanted to show a friend of mine some of my work, and as I was talking to her, I was messing around with a background, so I decided to throw somthing a bit "feminine" together to show her, as all my stuff is Basketball, Football, Rappers and MMA, lol, anyway here it is, about 20 minutes work:

 

[Notorious]

take off the texture-y stuff over the sig, and itll be nice. just the stuff over her makes it seem so unclear. good job though.

 

[hustler]

Rate simple yet nice sig made by NTC.

 

[NTC]

<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">take off the texture-y stuff over the sig, and itll be nice. just the stuff over her makes it seem so unclear. good job though.</div>

Nah well I personally think its what makes the sig, I was going for that "grungy beautiful" look.

 

[Notorious]

ok then tone it down and erase it over her face. itll be better IMO.

Hustler its good, but too bright and a bit low qualitty. 7.5/10
Lebron:

 

[NTC]

That one is a step back after the previous 3, too dark, poor font selection and I'm not a big fan of the background. I like the effects around LeBron though.

6/10

Also Notorious, I tired to PM you but your Inbox is full, but can you PM me some of the Graphics Sites you post on? I need to get back into it, and there are still techniques I have never picked up that I need to learn.

 

[Notorious]

my bad. isnt it supposed to tell you when its full? lol.

 

[Windmill360?]

Lebron: I like everything about it except where the text is placed. It's almost right in the middle and it looks too small. I'd go with a different option on the text. The background is nice though.

8/10

 

[NTC]

Hahahaha, I liked the background I used on my last sig, and I wanted to make an Amir Johnson piece, so I tried switching the colours around, didnt come out as nice as it looked with the other colours, but meh, didnt really put alot into this one so low ratings are expected, lol.

 

[bbwtrench]

Text is horrible. No offense, but I dont like it NT. The background is clean and the cut looks decent. I think its a little too saturated.

6/10

 

[NTC]

Yeah, well like I said I only rushed through it, so meh. I'll have another play around with it tomorrow and see what I can come up with.

 

[hustler]

Lol he looks like he's in an old school Raptors jersey. But other than that, Amir Johnson ftw.

 

[bbwtrench]

Thought this was set to 100px in height. Bummer. lol. Anyway, my latest.

 

[Notorious]

text is bad. the rest is nice though. especially the effects. nice job.

 

[bbwtrench]

Text is always bad! I quit text LMAO! Heres another.

 

[Windmill360?]

Both are awesome. I don't think the text is that bad on the other one, but it could be more creative. Those are awesome patterns. Did you use a brush on those? If so what kind?

 

[bbwtrench]

There are no patterns. I used a ton of stocks for texture. Been trying some new stuff instead of brushes and the like.

 

[NTC]

Yeah I hate text, lol, its easily the hardest part of a signature.

I like that Angelina Jolie (?) one though, its nice, 7/10

And your Proof (?) one is sick, 8/10

 

[Notorious]

yeah nice effects on your current.

Yeah, i know, wtf, hockey? but its for a gfx league.

 

[Ed!]

Looks nice. I'd make the text more visible though, I didn't even realize it was there for a sec.

Who wants to rate my Thabo > Wade sig?

 

[NTC]

Man, this text business is really pissing me off, I hate it. Nothing works. Grrrrrr.....

Ed!, that sig is nice, I've always liked it when I've seen it about on here, did you make it yourself? I like the background and the text works well, cut is pretty nice too, although I would've personally made it a little bigger. Nice work though.

8/10

 

[Notorious]

 

[bbwtrench]

 

[M Two One]

Anyone want to make a sig or stylish picture using birds of prey? Just for experimentation. If so, I have excellent shots you can try out. Just a suggestion for a change of pace.

Also, Ed! makes his own stuff. He put together a sweet Luol Deng sig for me a while back.

 

[bbwSwish]

Ed! is an awesome designer. He hooked me up with my Dwight sig. He's been around for awhile and he's one of my favorite designers on the board. I remember when him and TimFlem held down the fort years ago.

 

[NTC]

Ok, I updated my sig a little bit, most notably the font. Let me know if its an improvement or not.

 

[Notorious]

wtf? you guys do know this is the Rate The Sig thread? First i got skipped, then trench.

Trench, its nice just not as nice as your other latest ones. text seems to be just thrown out there, bg is messy.

M21, again ok. A lil too simple. No real effects or bg(cept logo). Text seems to fit well though.

Swish, render effects and bg are nice, text fits, and its overall a solid sig.

NTC, text is hot, bg seems a lil funny with the grunge texture you put in, but the sig in general is much better then before.

 

[Ed!]

^ Actually, you're one who stopped rating stuff, thus causing everyone else to stop.

Anyways the John Legend is nice, good stuff.

 

[M Two One]

<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">M21, again ok. A lil too simple. No real effects or bg(cept logo). Text seems to fit well though.</div>

The sig I'm using is done by Windmill. I'm not into making sigs anymore because I don't like much of my work on those and especially wallpapers; sports jerseys are more of my interest. Sorry for going off-topic here everyone, but look for yourself and compare.

Mine:

Originals: