Rate My Signature Thread

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Register Log in
yeah i like em. you just make them from scratch? If so great job

and Ed, i dont like to rate stuff. I dont rate stuff. I give comments and critiscism because in my opinion you can learn much more from comments then you ever can from a simple rating. And i never stopped, if you look above i cnced everyones sig.

It got skipped so here:
U1231-1181982902.jpg


U1231-1181982946.jpg
 
I don't really feel either version. The text is almost impossible to read because of the color, and I know its a "style" but I really don't like the shape or the way it has no boarder. Thats just my opinion I'm sure people at graphic forums would probably tell you different.
 
If you make the Text more visible, Notorious, then it would be nice. I like it, I think it is done well, just better text and maybe a bit lighter.
 
Who wants Yi????

WI WANT YI!!!!

At least I do.

Rate the siggy please.
 
That'd be nice to get Yi. Maybe Pax has something in mind, who knows with him. Sig is rockin' for sure. Love the text and alterations. Background is nice, a bit plain, but it represents the Bulls so the colors match and I like the fans applauding to the actual point of your sig. Nice work!

8/10
 
<div class="quote_poster">Ed! Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Who wants Yi????

WI WANT YI!!!!

At least I do.

Rate the siggy please.</div>

lol I love it, maybe he can fall the Sixers way.
fingersx.gif
 
Um, who is the sig supposed to be about? Other then that the lettering is a bit weird but I like the style


6/10 because I don't understand the sig.
 
Pharoahe Monch. Hiphop Artist. Check him out. Underrated.
 
Oh, ok, yea, if it's that, I like it, just abit dark, but good. I re update my 6/10 to a 8/10.
 
<div class="quote_poster">N4S Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">
U35-1181747995.jpg
</div>

I like it. The background looks sorta simple but it definitely works. The text flows nicely with the sig. 8/10

Rate (Just experimenting with stuff):
calderon-sig2.jpg


You can rate my current Trevor Ariza sig if you want to also.
 
^ 5/10 seems to be missing alot. Try some more stocks.

Rate:
U35-1182633541.jpg
 
9/10.. I'm loving alot of your work N4S. I have no complaints other than its kinda too bright.

Rate my sig made by Windmill360
 
colors are funny and text is ehh. render effects look nice and the bg stocks are great. one of your better recent sigs for sure.

i havent gotten a chance to get on here much lately with school ending and whatever but im back and ima try filling as many open requests i can.

flash.png


damon.jpg
 
<div class="quote_poster">N4S Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">^ 5/10 seems to be missing alot. Try some more stocks.

Rate:
U35-1182633541.jpg
</div>

Turn down some of the lighting and throw a border on there and its a solid 9.
 
<div class="quote_poster">Apollo Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Turn down some of the lighting and throw a border on there and its a solid 9.</div>

There is a border. A white one.
fingersx.gif


Rate:
U35-1183249226.jpg
 
its ok. not really up to your normal, but its nice.

<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">
flash.png


damon.jpg
</div>

???
 
<div class="quote_poster">Quote:</div><div class="quote_post">
U35-1181747995.jpg
</div>

Wow, I really like this one. I have no idea who Pharaoh Monch is, but great work, N4S!

Yeah, it looks simple, but if it were any busier, it would look cluttered.
 
ugh. ok vc i like the sig, what did NTC do to it tho? and anyway could someone rate mine? lol.
 
10/10 nice sig i don't no who he is but it's great.
Untitled-2-copy-2.jpg


^Rate this one
 
<div class="quote_poster">N4S Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Needs better text. 5/10

Rate:
U35-1183920068.jpg
</div>

Original. I like the texture. 8/10

Heres a new one for ya...

<div align="center">
swissbeatz.jpg
</div>
 
<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">ugh. ok vc i like the sig, what did NTC do to it tho? and anyway could someone rate mine? lol.</div>

I saved it to a size that would be allowable on the forum, lol.
 
haha, woot woot.

and trench its pretty cool,pen tool lines are decent. just i dont like all the colors. maybe keep it to 2-3 colors instead.

U1231-1184606207.png


U1231-1184606248.png
 
Roger Federer gets a 8/10 and Chase Utley lands a 9/10. I'm not contributing a sig to rate, so don't bother with my stuff. I should request a Nadal sig later. Haha!
 
I don't know if I have permission from Voodoo Child, but his sig, is AMAZING! 10/10. I love the text, and the picture, is great. I think best of all, it gets the message across. Good Job VC.

For the Utley, 8/10, a bit busy for me, but overall I found it not to bad. For Roger Federer, I best of all time, 9.3/10. Great job, but the text could be better.
 
I don't get what the big deal is about text all the time? If it doesn't look retarded and isn't times new roman verdana or other basic fonts being used then what's the difference?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top