Rate My Signature Thread

[M Two One]

I thought you're supposed to rate the person above you?

 

[P.A.P.]

Whoa thats a great pic N4S, mainly because of the background and the angle the pics taking from. I love the coloring effects you've done to it. From the nice blue to the green to the yellow, it's amazing. The only thing that prevents it from being a dime is Boozer's pose, but you can't really fix that. 9.85/10

 

[Chutney]

lol, M2One got skipped.

I like the idea, but I personally would've made the flag have a ripped effect instead of a dripping effect. Also the edges of the flags look a little jagged.

8/10.

 

[Notorious]

______________

The UNC shot is alil blurry, i couldnt figure out how to make it so it wasnt, and i couldnt find a better pic of it.
______________

Lol, its oversized, but i got bored and made this for another forum.
______________

______________

How do you make a gradient inside text? In the end i had to cover it with one that made it darker then i wanted to.
______________

______________
I got the idea for this iverson sig by looking at Windmills DWade Visa Card. Not the idea of the sig, the idea of dividing it up like he did.

 

[Windmill360?]

I think your James sig is the best by far, although the image is kinda raw and grainy. I also really like the PP one, it could use better font though. If you want to put a gradient on the font just double click the font layer and look for gradient overlay then mess around with that.

Good job overall, keep practicing.

 

[Notorious]

<div class="quote_poster">Windmill360? Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">I think your James sig is the best by far, although the image is kinda raw and grainy. I also really like the PP one, it could use better font though. If you want to put a gradient on the font just double click the font layer and look for gradient overlay then mess around with that.

Good job overall, keep practicing.

</div>

Yeah, i HATE font right now, its so hard to find one that works well for a pic... I was gonna change the font on the paul pierce one too, cuz i dont like it and its too dark. Hold up, ima post afew more sigs and rate yours in a minute.

 

[Iggy]

I like the Lebron sig. I rate it a 9.5/10.

Rate the sig made by Windmill below!

 

[Notorious]

<div class="quote_poster">Epidemik Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">I like the Lebron sig. I rate it a 9.5/10.

Rate the sig made by Windmill below!</div>

8/10

Im going to try one of those ( Text w/Pic) for the heat some time soon when i have time, i like it. However, i think his Mavs one is better.

And 9/10 for Windmills KG sig,
I LOVE the background, and the text is cool, whats it called?

Rate: (These are a "set", i wanted to put them both in the same sig, but it was crowded with the crazy bkrd i made.Oh, and since its the Utah Jazz, the buildings in the background are Salt Lake City)

 

[NTC]

The backgrounds are nice on the left hand side, but the right hand side is kind of bland, the cutting is pretty bad, and it really needs some text or pattern on the left.

4/10 for both.

BTW, that font you wanted to know the name of is '04b_03b'

 

[Notorious]

<div class="quote_poster">NTC187 Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">The backgrounds are nice on the left hand side, but the right hand side is kind of bland, the cutting is pretty bad, and it really needs some text or pattern on the left.

4/10 for both.

BTW, that font you wanted to know the name of is '04b_03b'</div>

It wasnt the cutting, it was the renders i used. Where do you guys find good pics, other then Google and Yahoo Sports? I wasnt sure about text, i didnt know what i was gonna write, so i didnt write anything, i can still add some tho. The right hand side of the BKGD is boring because it was a lighting effect that i did to the background. So there was like a Flare right there, then i messed with it.

Ill be trying some different styles in the next week or so, to help me "grow" and learn. So youll see ALOT of experimenting going on, just warning

 

[Notorious]

Last one before i go to sleep... I was thinking of who to do a sig on, and i saw Windmills KG sig, and an old Trench KG sig, so i decided to do him. Im probly gonna add more effects later if i get the chance.

 

[NTC]

Thats pretty nice, it would look better though if the background was black, or if the photo of Garnett was wearing the white home uniform (so it works better with the colour, the blue/black contrasts too much for my liking)

7/10

 

[Windmill360?]

<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Last one before i go to sleep... I was thinking of who to do a sig on, and i saw Windmills KG sig, and an old Trench KG sig, so i decided to do him. Im probly gonna add more effects later if i get the chance.

</div>

Yea I agree with NTC on that. The blue background doesnt really go with the picture. You could have used minnesota colors like the green or black or the turquoise color. Also you could try putting some color effects into the render to blend it a bit more.

 

[M Two One]

Notorious - KG sig - 7/10

Rate mine below.

 

[NTC]

8/10, very clean, espcially impressed because from what I gather you're fairly new to Photoshop.

Nice job

Let's hear some more feedback fro my sig.

 

[M Two One]

NTC - Chris Webber - 9/10

I love the colors and the cut out. The left side of the image is really cool with the multiple color fades like on the Pistons emblem. Looks like a black out behind it. I just don't get the right side image, what exactly is that circular thing? I also can see another player's face in the background, makes him look weird. I believe it is Chauncey Billups?

 

[N4S]

^ Creative but porrly executed.

Rate: (just a piece, not really considered a sig.)

 

[M Two One]

<div class="quote_poster">N4S Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">^ Creative but porrly executed.</div>

Which, mine??

 

[Notorious]

Thanks guys, and yeah, the background was sposed to be Turqouise-ish, but i made 3 layers of brushes with different colors, and when i added the minnesota city part, it turned blue instead of Turquoise.

 

[Iggy]

4/10
Try to get a better picture, and maybe outline the letters.

 

[Notorious]

<div class="quote_poster">Epidemik Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">4/10
Try to get a better picture, and maybe outline the letters.</div>

Yeah, i didnt like the outcome, im gonna make a new one when i have more time. Im working on a new sig, wait a few hours and itll be up!

 

[NTC]

<div class="quote_poster">M Two One Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">NTC - Chris Webber - 9/10

I love the colors and the cut out. The left side of the image is really cool with the multiple color fades like on the Pistons emblem. Looks like a black out behind it. I just don't get the right side image, what exactly is that circular thing? I also can see another player's face in the background, makes him look weird. I believe it is Chauncey Billups?</div>

I didnt cut anything out, I just manipulated this photo:

 

[M Two One]

Ah ok, I was wondering why the guy's head was appearing in the background. Still, cool stuff.

 

[Notorious]

Also, i remade the KG one, without the blue. Whadya think?

And, my first-ever attempt at a photo manip. Going for that old-school retro look.

Crits and Comments please

 

[M Two One]

<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Also, i remade the KG one, without the blue. Whadya think?

</div>

Much Better. 8/10.

EDIT* Rate this new one. My first attempt at effects aside from using the layer options. Which looks better of the three versions? The second lists his major accomplishments and the third also shows the team sponsor logo.

 

[Notorious]

DAMN! I was working on this real nice Gilbert Arenas sig, and i finished. So i go to save, and my PS goes beserk, and starts rapidly switching from the mouse to the Hourglass, and i had to close it. I HATE THIS! Now i have to try to remake it. Ill post it when im done.

^I like the second sig, its not blurred and it doesnt have that lil white thing.

 

[M Two One]

<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">^I like the second sig, its not blurred and it doesnt have that lil white thing.</div>

They're all the same, bro, differences are added text for the second one and the sponsor logo for the third (the little white thing). They're blurred a bit except the main image because he's a cyclist while in motion from the original photo.

Sorry about your sig that you lost. Happened to me often when I used to work with that program from Microsoft. I can't remember the name, but you could do similar stuff as in Photoshop. Though I never made any sigs.

 

[Notorious]

<div class="quote_poster">M Two One Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">They're all the same, bro, differences are added text for the second one and the sponsor logo for the third (the little white thing). They're blurred a bit except the main image because he's a cyclist while in motion from the original photo.

Sorry about your sig that you lost. Happened to me often when I used to work with that program from Microsoft. I can't remember the name, but you could do similar stuff as in Photoshop. Though I never made any sigs.</div>

K, im running a scan too see if theres any virus's cause i dont think my brother did anything about the ones i found yesterday. Yeah, the logo is kind of in a wierd place, i think thats why i didnt like it. I like the text on the Left side though, cuz it makes it look more "busy" while still not being messy.
Can you rate or Crit my other sigs that i made?

 

[M Two One]

Your Paul Pierce sig I like a lot - 9/10

I don't like that Butterfinger one, quite a blurry background - 4/10

Lebron sig - 8/10

You're doing very well though, good work, bro.

 

[Legacy]

<div class="quote_poster">Notorious Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">

</div>

Your best sig. I really like this one. Text could have been better, but other than that it's great.