I believe the Harry Potter car was a Ford Anglia - the Alfa looks very old fashioned, but it was actually the first mass produced car ever designed in an air-tunnel and had an amazing Cd of 0.33 - which is still respectable today.
This is a Ford Anglia:
This is a Giulia Super:
There are certainly some things that resemble each other - but you will see that the Alfa's roof does not taper the way the Anglia's does - in the Anglia it was done for "fashion", the Alfa did it for aerodynamic purposes. Of course, the Anglia was a very old fashioned car, pushrod engine, drum brakes all around and a 3 speed transmission. The Alfa has an overhead twin cam engine (pretty much every modern engine still uses that), 5 speeds and disc brakes all around.
The Alfa is considered by many to be the first mass-produced sport-sedan (about 3 years before the BMW 1600-2 that we know as the 2002.
They do a little bit look alike, but not really if you see them in person.