Round 4 Voting

[Oranje]

Round 4 was between 12thman and echo, and the theme was:

Here's a suggestion, allocate each entrant a colour, at random, which could also be associated to a country, and have them design a sig with one predominant colour. See how people can adapt to a style like that.

voting is out of 15. 10 for presentation of the theme, and 5 for the actual sig.

the colours were:

12th - blue
echo - yellow

so, these are the sigs

12thman

echo

 

[twofivefive]

The 12th Man - 7/10 for the theme, it's a good blue that is all over the sig and you can't get more blue than France. 1/5 for looks, it looks much like your others with the white lines on the side and the effects are the same. I don't really like how it goes from dark blue to light blue though.

echo369 - 6/10 for the theme, it's hard to get a good yellow but this one isn't bad and Australia's always been yellow so you've matched it well. 4/5 for looks, definitely one of your better recent sigs. The background is nice, not too plain and not too much going on. Text looks good and the cuts are blended in well.

So my vote goes to echo369.

 

[bbwMax]

12th Man- 8/10 for the theme as i can't actually see any other colour lol. 4/5 for the dig as i really like the layout of the text and the effects.

Total for 12th = 12/15


Echo- 7/10 for the theme as the yellow is a bit pale but yellow is a hard colour. 4/5 for the overall sig, Like the two renders and the effects. but IMO your sigs are starting to look a bit samey

Total for Echo = 11/15

My vote goes to 12th Man

 

[echo369]

come on guys vote..

 

[Evans09]

12th man - 9/10 for the theme as you kept to the colour blue very well.
4/5 for the sig. as it looks fantastic

echo - 6/10 for the theme as the colour isn't all that great
3/5 for the sig. as i think it is one of your worser sig's

 

[Hutcho]

12th Man- 8/10 for theme. Stuck with it and is obvious.
4/5 for sig. Looks classy.
Echo- 8/10 for theme. Did it fairly well.
3/5 for sig. Not all that graphically appealing.

Overall vote goes to 12th man.