Lets compromise while keeping it real.
Crabbe is an elite 3pt shooter. No doubt about it.
He has slightly improved his side step and shoot and a step in and shoot, but he has yet to show anything consistent when it comes to driving by guys to the hoop.
He hasn't shown anything special about his passing(mostly because he gets passed to and then shoots).
His defense is above average but nothing to write home about because he reaches in too often rather than moving his feet to get in front.(This is fixable)
His rebounding is below average (don't care about average for the position) when he is bigger than our other guards and they still out rebound him.
In today's NBA, I would put his value at $12 mill. Not a penny more.
His defense is not above average. He's the worst defender on a very bad defensive team. He is NOT a 3 and D guy. He's a 3 guy.
In a summer of bad contracts, Crabbe's was one of the worst. Sure, Noah and Parson's are worse, but that's due to injuries. Is there a more overpaid healthy player in the NBA right now that Allen Crabbe? Maybe Timofey Mozgov, but even that's debatable. They are two very different players, but Mozgov gives you defense and rebounding and makes $2.5 million a year less than Crabbe. Whether Mozgov's contract is "better" or worse than Crabbe's really doesn't matter, if you're contract comes up in the same conversation as Mozgov's, you know you're overpaid.
As far as last summer's spending spree, it was still possible to get bargains that give you what Crabbe does (or more) for a a lot less money.
Seth Curry - 2 years at $3 million/year, 3FG% = .420, PER = 15.4
Dion Waiters - 1 year at $2.9 million/year, 3FG% = .394, PER = 14.5
Anthony Tolliver - 2 years at $8 million/year, 3FG% = .406, PER = 11.1
Courtney Lee - 4 years at $12.5 million/year, 3FG% = .407, PER = 11.7
Mareese Speights - 2 years at $1.4 million/year, 3FG% = .381, PER = 18.4
Just because there were a few really bad contracts doesn't make Crabbe's somehow less bad. And sure, we were't the only ones to miss out on bargains like Seth Curry, but we are the only ones paying Allen Crabbe $18.5 million a year.
BNM