The Rate My Wallpaper Thread (1 Viewer)

[30 standing ver]

^Overall 9.9/10 especially liked the rookie one.
The ghost-6.5/10

 

[rjnavarrete]

Rate my latest creation! It's a Work In Progress, so help me out with some tips, etc.

 

[eginobili20]

make a better background, more exciting one

 

[rjnavarrete]

Rate this:

 

[twool913]

Looks good, 8.5/10, but who am i to rate? Only thingi noticed is on the main pic of AI on the left of his face (his cheek) you need to crop it a little better.

 

[rjnavarrete]

Fixed the cropping. Big difference. Makes the wall look much better.

 

[Mr.Fundamentals]

8.6/10 - I really like the iverson-pass background. I also see your credits text down in the bottom is smaller and not spaced like som of your other wallpapers, overall good job.

 

[rjnavarrete]

Just pumped this out today.

 

[s@bz]

My first wall

Here is mine. Just got Photoshop yesterday and tried to make something. I am just glad it looks like something lol. Tell me what you think.

 

[rjnavarrete]

Pretty good man. 5/10 needs better font and some background. Rate this:

 

[Mr.Fundamentals]

Damn RJ, your a machine, creating Wallpaper after wallpaper after wallpaper. I am really feeling this one. Maybe you can place the middle dwayne wade picture somewhere else like beside the main one. I really don't like the BIG font that much, can't get a good look at the letter I. other than that the wallpaper looks real good. 8.0/10 and an 8.8/10 if you add those changes

 

[Knicks Analyst]

RJ-Needs some work, the main pic is pretty ugly for that wall and it seems like it was slapped together rather impatiently.

 

[rjnavarrete]

I was going for a different look on this wall. That's why I gaussian blurred the main pic. And trust me, fine tuning the wall wasn't very impatiently done. Well, I guess Mr. F and I are the only ones that liked seeing something out of the ordinary. Thanks for the comments.

 

[rjnavarrete]

Version 2, any better?

 

[s@bz]

An update of my first wall. I changed the text up and added two more pics. Tell me what you think. And feel free to give any suggestions.

<div align="center"></div>

 

[eginobili20]

hey, can you also post non basketball ones? i have got one from lance armstrong. my newest,dont do a lot of walls so ...

 

[Smoke]

pretty cool concept

<div class="quote_poster">Quoting eginobili20:</div><div class="quote_post">hey, can you also post non basketball ones? i have got one from lance armstrong. my newest,dont do a lot of walls so ...
</div>
pretty cool concept of live strong lance armstrong.

9/10.

<div align="center"><u><font face="Garamond"><font size="4">very clean, nice simple background ( not too much ) just n overall good wallpaper. ( i have to admit Lance does his thing. <font size="5">but hey one things for sure he couldnt play basketball in that commercial. lol swat.)</font></font></font></u></div>

 

[rjnavarrete]

Hey, I would give it a 6 at most. Why? Crop the whole background. Look at that image on the right. You can see the street/backroungd through the frame and wheels Take youe time. Also, everyone rate mine up there. The D-Wade one.

 

[eginobili20]

rj21: i wanted the bg like that

. and the wheels: the pic doesnt show the whole wheel so I didnt cut the whole graph would have taken too much time that i dont have.
your dwade one: The background is a little plain plus the three, id put its opacity little higher. anyway cool pics + effects. 8/10

 

[TimFlem]

RJ Dwayne Wade V2 is a 6. There's nothing to it. Just some text and 2 images. It's like mostly all of your other walls except the t-mac one. You should take alot more time in your work and try to make everything gel together instead of throwing some pics on there.

 

[s@bz]

eginobli I give yours a 9/10. I really like the text a lot!

RJ21 I give yours a 7.5/10. I am not feeling that big three.

Here is my new wall.

Tell me what you think. And how about we make this rule. You need to rate others before you post one of your own? It will help people get theirs rated more.

 

[s@bz]

Here is my new one. It is sort of the same thing, just using vectors.

 

[KBC]

I'm really not feelin the first one. The effect on the pics makes my eyes hurt. And the text doesn't really match the theme (all the swirls, seems more relaxed and the text is more intesnse). I like the second one a little better. The vector is nice, but I still don't like the text, and I think you went a little overboard on the backround swirls.

Rate: 6/10

RJ - I like the two pics, but I don't like the big 3 in the backround. But take that out and the bg is too plain....

Rate: 7.5/10

 

[eginobili20]

s@bz: im not feeling the background. Why dont youg ive wade some colour? nice font tho. 6/10
[KBC] what about mine?

 

[rjnavarrete]

Rate mine, please.

 

[eginobili20]

the big jayz pic is too blue seems a lil weird to me. A black would have made it higher than 7.8/10

 

[rjnavarrete]

here?

 

[eginobili20]

now i notice the two faces are too closet o each other, but colours are much better, what about the stroke around the jay-z text, you wanne leave it blue? It would be close to a 8.6

BTW: you could join walls-cave.com wiht the speed you have

 

[rjnavarrete]

Yea, I tried. Dude, recommend me. are you on the team? If so, tell em you know an up and coming designer!!

 

[eginobili20]

oh, when did you try? If id be in the team id highly recommend you - but i myself dont make a lot of walls so .. when did you try? They didnt let you in?