time for the -1/+1 vote away game

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Users who are viewing this thread

LaMarcus Aldridge 14
Luke Babbit 9
Nicolas Batum 18
Jerryd Bayless 7
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 9
Wesley Matthews 11
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 18+
Joel Przybilla 8
Brandon Roy 17
Elliot Williams 6-
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 14
Luke Babbit 9
Nicolas Batum 18
Jerryd Bayless 6-
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 9
Wesley Matthews 11
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 18
Joel Przybilla 8
Brandon Roy 18+
Elliot Williams 6
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 13-
Luke Babbit 9
Nicolas Batum 19+
Jerryd Bayless 6
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 9
Wesley Matthews 11
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 18
Joel Przybilla 8
Brandon Roy 18
Elliot Williams 6
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 14+
Luke Babbit 8-
Nicolas Batum 19
Jerryd Bayless 6
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 9
Wesley Matthews 11
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 18
Joel Przybilla 8
Brandon Roy 18
Elliot Williams 6[/QUOTE]
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 14
Luke Babbit 8
Nicolas Batum 19
Jerryd Bayless 6
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 9
Wesley Matthews 11
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 19 +
Joel Przybilla 8
Brandon Roy 18
Elliot Williams 5 -
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 14
Luke Babbit 6
Nicolas Batum 19
Jerryd Bayless 6
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 9
Wesley Matthews 11
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 19
Joel Przybilla 8
Brandon Roy 19
Elliot Williams 5

Batum and Oden having more points then Roy? Come on guys

I've now given Roy 3 of the 9 points he's received; I can't be blamed. :)
 
Last edited:
LaMarcus Aldridge 15 +
Luke Babbit 6
Nicolas Batum 19
Jerryd Bayless 5 -
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 9
Wesley Matthews 11
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 19
Joel Przybilla 8
Brandon Roy 19
Elliot Williams 5
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 15
Luke Babbit 5 -
Nicolas Batum 19
Jerryd Bayless 5
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 9
Wesley Matthews 11
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 19
Joel Przybilla 8
Brandon Roy 20 +
Elliot Williams 5
 
I believe Babbit should have another point as PtldPlatypus took two away
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 15
Luke Babbit 5
Nicolas Batum 20+
Jerryd Bayless 4-
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 9
Wesley Matthews 11
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 19
Joel Przybilla 8
Brandon Roy 20
Elliot Williams 5
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 15
Luke Babbitt 6 (added one because PtldPlatypus subtracted two)
Nicolas Batum 20
Jerryd Bayless 3 -
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 10 +
Wesley Matthews 11
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 19
Joel Przybilla 8
Brandon Roy 20
Elliot Williams 5
 
Poor Eliot Williams, no love because he skipped summer league.
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 15
Luke Babbitt 7+
Nicolas Batum 20
Jerryd Bayless 3
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 10
Wesley Matthews 11
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 19
Joel Przybilla 8
Brandon Roy 20
Elliot Williams 4-
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 15
Luke Babbitt 7
Nicolas Batum 19 -
Jerryd Bayless 3
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 10
Wesley Matthews 11
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 20 +
Joel Przybilla 8
Brandon Roy 20
Elliot Williams 4
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 16+
Luke Babbitt 6-
Nicolas Batum 19
Jerryd Bayless 3
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 10
Wesley Matthews 11
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 20
Joel Przybilla 8
Brandon Roy 20
Elliot Williams 4
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 16
Luke Babbitt 6
Nicolas Batum 20
Jerryd Bayless 3
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 10
Wesley Matthews 11
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 20
Joel Przybilla 8
Brandon Roy 20
Elliot Williams 3
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 16
Luke Babbitt 6
Nicolas Batum 20
Jerryd Bayless 2 -
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 10
Wesley Matthews 12 +
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 20
Joel Przybilla 8
Brandon Roy 20
Elliot Williams 3
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 16
Luke Babbitt 6
Nicolas Batum 20
Jerryd Bayless 2
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 11 +
Wesley Matthews 12
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 20
Joel Przybilla 7 -
Brandon Roy 20
Elliot Williams 3
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 16
Luke Babbitt 6
Nicolas Batum 20
Jerryd Bayless 1 -
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 11
Wesley Matthews 12
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 21 +
Joel Przybilla 7
Brandon Roy 20
Elliot Williams 3
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 16
Luke Babbitt 6
Nicolas Batum 20
Jerryd Bayless 2 +
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 11
Wesley Matthews 12
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 20 -
Joel Przybilla 7
Brandon Roy 20
Elliot Williams 3
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 16
Luke Babbitt 6
Nicolas Batum 20
Jerryd Bayless 2
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 11
Wesley Matthews 12
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 21 +
Joel Przybilla 6 -
Brandon Roy 20
Elliot Williams 3
 
This game should have a rule to conserve the total points at each position. You started with 30 points at center, 50 forward, and 70 guard. You should finish with that, or maybe 30 center, 60 forward, and 60 guard.

You currently have 39 center, 52 forward, and 59 guard. You have basically given Rudy's points to Oden. Centers are now disproportionate.
 
This game should have a rule to conserve the total points at each position. You started with 30 points at center, 50 forward, and 70 guard. You should finish with that, or maybe 30 center, 60 forward, and 60 guard.

You currently have 39 center, 52 forward, and 59 guard. You have basically given Rudy's points to Oden. Centers are now disproportionate.
But centers are more important to a title run than any other position, so that makes sense. Besides, this is a vote away game till only one player is left (of course that's hypothetical since everyone will get tired of this thread before the end)



But, this is just a game to pass the time. So if you come up with a game I will play by whatever rules you come up with, as long as it keeps my attention.
 
Besides, this is a vote away game till only one player is left

Ah yes. So one position will ultimately emerge, asymmetric and disproportionate. You are right. As things are going, I predict the winner will be Oden, not Roy or Batum.
 
My objection would have held had the goal been to come up with a 5-man team.
 
Ah yes. So one position will ultimately emerge, asymmetric and disproportionate. You are right. As things are going, I predict the winner will be Oden, not Roy or Batum.

I will be very surprised if there is a winner.
 
Im loving this game and I might just finish it myself if I have to

LaMarcus Aldridge 16
Luke Babbitt 6
Nicolas Batum 20
Jerryd Bayless 1 -
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 11
Wesley Matthews 12
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 21
Joel Przybilla 6
Brandon Roy 21 +
Elliot Williams 3
 
This game should have a rule to conserve the total points at each position. You started with 30 points at center, 50 forward, and 70 guard. You should finish with that, or maybe 30 center, 60 forward, and 60 guard.

You currently have 39 center, 52 forward, and 59 guard. You have basically given Rudy's points to Oden. Centers are now disproportionate.

I've tried suggesting rules in the past that would make this go more quickly and smoothly, but to no avail. What will happen is it'll come down to a few players with 50+ points each. Then the next month or so will be spent trying to slowly take one of those totals down to zero, but fans will vote them back to even again. Eventually everyone will get tired of it (more quickly so if the mods don't sticky this thread) and the game will stop unresolved.
 
I hate this game but couldn't resist the opportunity to kill off Bayless.

LaMarcus Aldridge 16
Luke Babbitt 6
Nicolas Batum 20
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 11
Wesley Matthews 12
Andre Miller 11
Greg Oden 21
Joel Przybilla 7 +
Brandon Roy 21
Elliot Williams 3

barfo
 
LaMarcus Aldridge 16
Luke Babbitt 6
Nicolas Batum 20
Marcus Camby 12
Dante Cunningham 10
Armon Johnson 11
Wesley Matthews 12
Andre Miller 10 -
Greg Oden 21
Joel Przybilla 8 +
Brandon Roy 21
Elliot Williams 3
 
Back
Top