Denver fans after Nurk was traded: He is not a good teammate.
Knicks fans after we sign Kanter: He can’t play defense and lazy.
Heat fans after Whiteside was traded: He is a lazy bum
X- Factor here is that they don’t have Dame as their leader. Whiteside will help this team
While this is a good point, I think there's also the element of Portland playing a somewhat unconventional "drop" defense, where the center concedes open long 2's and 3's, but clogs the rim. It's designed around guards fighting through screens and running their asses off, and not putting your big in a place where he draws ticky-tack fouls. This is directly counter to the general NBA trend of "switchable" bigs who help in contesting threes. We just don't ask that of our centers hardly ever.
We ran this defense with Plumlee too. Plumlee is always remembered for getting us Nurkic (and a pick!), but we acquired him for Rhonae Holland Jefferson and Steve Blake. Nobody wanted him. Ed Davis benefited as well, and it was basically the only way you can even keep Leonard on the court.
What is the recurring theme here? 2000's style big centers can still stay on the court in Portland even in crunch time. (And use their time here to convince other teams they can work for them too!) Big guys set big screens, setting up Dame's offense, and big guys can guard the rim, making up for penetration we concede with our small back court.
Just watch Boston. My guess is a lot of Celtics fans are going to pull their hair out when Kanter suddenly isn't any good at defense anymore again, when the reality is he needs the right defense around him (Portland's) and he's perfectly capable. But if you try to plug him into Horford's old role, jesus. They are fucked. I can't wait to see how Meyers Leonard is an utter defensive disaster in Miami.
Portland (rightly) has a reputation for resurrecting careers. A lot of that, I think, is the example of professionalism Dame and CJ set, and obviously some great shooting coaching. But I think Stotts' drop defensive scheme does a lot to make Portland a place where big centers can find new life. People who are skeptical of the Whiteside trade are missing both components of what Portland does well at the center position--dropping defense and raising professionalism.