Why didn’t Sharpe play for Kentucky? (1 Viewer)

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Register Log in

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
UKRAINEFAN said:
Do you have any evidence at all that he doesn't like school or what his grades were in school or is this complete speculation?
Click to expand...
No. Like the post said. I got nothin.
Just all speculation but this very scenario has happened many times. That's why i am not buying into the Conspiracy Theories that are saying there are other reasons he didn't play at Kentucky.
The kid wanted to play pro out of High School. It's pretty much the most simple answer. Today's rules prohibit that.
 
Fairly-Hard said:
No. Like the post said. I got nothin.
Just all speculation but this very scenario has happened many times. That's why i am not buying into the Conspiracy Theories that are saying there are other reasons he didn't play at Kentucky.
The kid wanted to play pro out of High School. It's pretty much the most simple answer. Today's rules prohibit that.
Click to expand...
Some people go to college to learn.

Some people go to college to get drunk and party.

Some people go to college to meet chicks.

Some people go to college so they can become millionaire athletes.
 
Fairly-Hard said:
The kid wanted to play pro out of High School. It's pretty much the most simple answer. Today's rules prohibit that.
Click to expand...
All he had to do was wait one year after graduating high school and apply for the draft. There was no need to join ANY college team.
 
Natebishop3 said:
He got to learn and practice with one of the top programs in the country. What was the downside?
Click to expand...
So you think he knew he was never going to play for Kentucky? He just wanted to practice with them? That is belied by statements from Calipari, who said publicly that he was looking forward to Sharpe playing for Kentucky this coming season.
 
Bingo Bango said:
All he had to do was wait one year after graduating high school and apply for the draft. There was no need to join ANY college team.
Click to expand...
If he just waited and did nothing you think his draft stock would be as high as joining Kentucky?

Also gave him the option to return to Kentucky next year if he decided to wait on the draft.

What's the advantage for him to not join any college team as you propose?
 
Bingo Bango said:
So you think he knew he was never going to play for Kentucky? He just wanted to practice with them? That is belied by statements from Calipari, who said publicly that he was looking forward to Sharpe playing for Kentucky this coming season.
Click to expand...

He likely planned to go pro but his fall back option was going back to Kentucky next year if his draft stock slid or he got injured, etc.

Calipari of course would say that for the chance he returns to their program the following year. He's probably happy to have #1 prospects practicing at his program.
 
Bingo Bango said:
So you think he knew he was never going to play for Kentucky? He just wanted to practice with them? That is belied by statements from Calipari, who said publicly that he was looking forward to Sharpe playing for Kentucky this coming season.
Click to expand...
I don’t think he ever had any intention of playing. I’m not sure if Calipari knew that.
 
More than likely there was $50-100k passed under the table from alumni to him to go to Kentucky.

Which he did.

"Thanks for the money, I'm going to the NBA!"
 
WesleyMatthews said:
He likely planned to go pro but his fall back option was going back to Kentucky next year if his draft stock slid or he got injured, etc.

Calipari of course would say that for the chance he returns to their program the following year. He's probably happy to have #1 prospects practicing at his program.
Click to expand...
Yeah there’s no downside for Kentucky, besides obviously that he didn’t end up playing, but they still got a #1 prospect to go there, they still boosted their recruiting class. He can still claim another Kentucky player in the NBA.
 
Natebishop3 said:
I don’t think he ever had any intention of playing. I’m not sure if Calipari knew that.
Click to expand...
But, even if that was his intention, going to Kentucky covered his bases. If his draft stock slipped, he had the opportunity to play NCAA next season. It is smart; testing the waters for the future, while still maintaining an alternative path forward to reach goals.

I'm not sure how people can't understand that. It is simply smart, pragmatic behavior to ensure the best path forward for himself.
 
theprunetang said:
But, even if that was his intention, going to Kentucky covered his bases. If his draft stock slipped, he had the opportunity to play NCAA next season. It is smart; testing the waters for the future, while still maintaining an alternative path forward to reach goals.

I'm not sure how people can't understand that. It is simply smart, pragmatic behavior to ensure the best path forward for himself.
Click to expand...

Great, another highly selfish move, contributing to the death of the collegiate system, is now being lauded as smart and pragmatic. I want to build a team with team-first players. I know that's increasingly difficult in the one-and-done era, but at least pretend to care about something other than oneself.

It costs programs a lot of money for each high profile athlete they cater to. I'm sure Kentucky can afford this one letdown, but if it becomes a common bridge between HS and NBA, it'll be a significant issue. Colleges will have to decide whether it's even worth going after the top recruits, which could lead to a much worse product on the court.

I don't buy that Kentucky benefits in any way from Sharpe having been there. Any mention of him won't be as a Kentucky product, rather as the kid who didn't play for Kentucky. He'll always be the one whose context begs the question, "why not?" That's negative advertising for the program, no matter how good he becomes. There's also scholarship ramifications with how many players can practice. I don't know how that was handled this year, but they presumably had an open slot?
 
handiman said:
Great, another highly selfish move, contributing to the death of the collegiate system, is now being lauded as smart and pragmatic. I want to build a team with team-first players. I know that's increasingly difficult in the one-and-done era, but at least pretend to care about something other than oneself.

It costs programs a lot of money for each high profile athlete they cater to. I'm sure Kentucky can afford this one letdown, but if it becomes a common bridge between HS and NBA, it'll be a significant issue. Colleges will have to decide whether it's even worth going after the top recruits, which could lead to a much worse product on the court.

I don't buy that Kentucky benefits in any way from Sharpe having been there. Any mention of him won't be as a Kentucky product, rather as the kid who didn't play for Kentucky. He'll always be the one whose context begs the question, "why not?" That's negative advertising for the program, no matter how good he becomes. There's also scholarship ramifications with how many players can practice. I don't know how that was handled this year, but they presumably had an open slot?
Click to expand...
Some people go to college so they can get a job.

Sharpe went to college and he got a job.

Seems like a win :dunno:
 
handiman said:
Great, another highly selfish move, contributing to the death of the collegiate system, is now being lauded as smart and pragmatic. I want to build a team with team-first players. I know that's increasingly difficult in the one-and-done era, but at least pretend to care about something other than oneself.

It costs programs a lot of money for each high profile athlete they cater to. I'm sure Kentucky can afford this one letdown, but if it becomes a common bridge between HS and NBA, it'll be a significant issue. Colleges will have to decide whether it's even worth going after the top recruits, which could lead to a much worse product on the court.

I don't buy that Kentucky benefits in any way from Sharpe having been there. Any mention of him won't be as a Kentucky product, rather as the kid who didn't play for Kentucky. He'll always be the one whose context begs the question, "why not?" That's negative advertising for the program, no matter how good he becomes. There's also scholarship ramifications with how many players can practice. I don't know how that was handled this year, but they presumably had an open slot?
Click to expand...

If Sharpe had done this at say like... Washington State, do you think he would have been drafted as high?

Being recruited by and signing with a program like Kentucky adds value to a player.

It also adds value to a program like Kentucky, once again, they got a top recruit who went on to play in the NBA.

Back to the Washington State example, if he had done this to a program like that the talk would be there are major problems with that program for a player like Sharpe not to play for them. No one is saying that about Kentucky.
 
handiman said:
Great, another highly selfish move, contributing to the death of the collegiate system, is now being lauded as smart and pragmatic. I want to build a team with team-first players. I know that's increasingly difficult in the one-and-done era, but at least pretend to care about something other than oneself.

It costs programs a lot of money for each high profile athlete they cater to. I'm sure Kentucky can afford this one letdown, but if it becomes a common bridge between HS and NBA, it'll be a significant issue. Colleges will have to decide whether it's even worth going after the top recruits, which could lead to a much worse product on the court.

I don't buy that Kentucky benefits in any way from Sharpe having been there. Any mention of him won't be as a Kentucky product, rather as the kid who didn't play for Kentucky. He'll always be the one whose context begs the question, "why not?" That's negative advertising for the program, no matter how good he becomes. There's also scholarship ramifications with how many players can practice. I don't know how that was handled this year, but they presumably had an open slot?
Click to expand...
Agree to disagree. This was a well thought out post, and I understand your perspective, but the reasoning doesn't do much for me. Probably a personal bias on my account.

These colleges make sooooooooooo much money off of these kids, and have long held all of the power. My personal bias comes into play here, because I will always be more interested in individuals doing what is best for themselves collectively, and gaining personal power, responsibilities, and actual agency in the process. Calipari uses these kids, as do all college programs, as cash cows. Yet, if he blows out his knee at UK, there is almost no safety net in place. One must look out for their own best interest in this dog eat dog world. And maybe student athletes should have a little bit more agency, and actually have a say in their own fucking lives. Empower those whose literal bodies are generating all of the money.
 
handiman said:
Great, another highly selfish move, contributing to the death of the collegiate system, is now being lauded as smart and pragmatic. I want to build a team with team-first players. I know that's increasingly difficult in the one-and-done era, but at least pretend to care about something other than oneself.

It costs programs a lot of money for each high profile athlete they cater to. I'm sure Kentucky can afford this one letdown, but if it becomes a common bridge between HS and NBA, it'll be a significant issue. Colleges will have to decide whether it's even worth going after the top recruits, which could lead to a much worse product on the court.

I don't buy that Kentucky benefits in any way from Sharpe having been there. Any mention of him won't be as a Kentucky product, rather as the kid who didn't play for Kentucky. He'll always be the one whose context begs the question, "why not?" That's negative advertising for the program, no matter how good he becomes. There's also scholarship ramifications with how many players can practice. I don't know how that was handled this year, but they presumably had an open slot?
Click to expand...

What a bunch of worthless delusional ramblings.

Are you going to yell at some clouds next?
 
theprunetang said:
Agree to disagree. This was a well thought out post, and I understand your perspective, but the reasoning doesn't do much for me. Probably a personal bias on my account.

These colleges make sooooooooooo much money off of these kids, and have long held all of the power. My personal bias comes into play here, because I will always be more interested in individuals doing what is best for themselves collectively, and gaining personal power, responsibilities, and actual agency in the process. Calipari uses these kids, as do all college programs, as cash cows. Yet, if he blows out his knee at UK, there is almost no safety net in place. One must look out for their own best interest in this dog eat dog world. And maybe student athletes should have a little bit more agency, and actually have a say in their own fucking lives. Empower those whose literal bodies are generating all of the money.
Click to expand...
To me, the whole point of college is to further your personal success. If it’s not for that, why else am I paying off a shit ton of student loans?

so why the hell would anyone fault a kid for using a college to further his personal success? He doesn’t owe them anything.
 
Bingo Bango said:
All he had to do was wait one year after graduating high school and apply for the draft. There was no need to join ANY college team.
Click to expand...
My uneducated guess was he graduated early to practice with KY and planned to play for them next year. He then discovered he'd be at least in the top 8 this year (gleaned from what I've read). Cal told him if he played next year, he'd be the overall #1. His agent did the math and coming out this year made more sense than playing next year.

Generally if you enter college early, you redshirt, not play. Anyway, just my $0.02.
 
Our resident "Dog" who is very Sly is going to take Calipari and the entire Kentucky Program down now? I see years of NCAA sanctions in the future!
All because of S2.
Hope you aren't a Wildcat fan.
 
Seems many are over thinking this. In a timeline like this i see this very plausible:

goes to kentucky.
Sees his stock rise as scouts are onto him. His agent says he is likely a first round pick now or a number one pick next year. But if he plays now and doesn't instantly succeed, his stock could drop.
Though he likely had initial thoughts of playing a year, his stock rose enough and with agents advice, went into this years draft.
 
maxiep said:
My uneducated guess was he graduated early to practice with KY and planned to play for them next year. He then discovered he'd be at least in the top 8 this year (gleaned from what I've read). Cal told him if he played next year, he'd be the overall #1. His agent did the math and coming out this year made more sense than playing next year.

Generally if you enter college early, you redshirt, not play. Anyway, just my $0.02.
Click to expand...

Beat me to it. :)
 
Fairly-Hard said:
Our resident "Dog" who is very Sly is going to take Calipari and the entire Kentucky Program down now? I see years of NCAA sanctions in the future!
All because of S2.
Hope you aren't a Wildcat fan.
Click to expand...
njvYZPT.png
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top