You and a few others get ridiculously defensive about any kind of criticism of Aldridge. Constructive or otherwise. The last player that I was a "die hard" about was Damon Stoudamire. I was a huge Damon fan when we traded for him, and I defended his drop in statistics against all kinds of criticism. Damon burned me. The piece of shit broke a cardinal sin by complaining about playing time when we were just about to start our series against the Spurs in the WCF. After that I refused to blindly defend players.
Bringing up Shooter's thread about Davis and Lillard is a bad comparison. Shooter was saying that Davis actually had a shot at rookie of the year. I "flew off the handle" because he called me a homer for saying that he was wrong. Am I saying that Aldridge is a bad player? No. Am I saying that he didn't deserve to be an All-Star? No. I've said that I would consider trading him if the right deal came around for the Blazers, and I've said that some fans would complain less about him if he rebounded more.
That's not complaining.